I Think That We Should Change The No Discussing Moderation Actions On The Public Board Rule

[Road Runner]

Please hear me out first. As if people want to whine I say let them whine!! After all, they're only opening themselves up to public humiliation. I got this idea when just recently seeing AyeCantSeeYou deal with a whiner although I can see why the rule exists, I say that we should give them what they want and deserve which is attention.

So no this isn't me complaining about the rules so if the mods still say no I will say okay, but please don't close this thread as I think that this could make for a really good and interesting discussion. I'm just curious what everybody else thinks about this and to see if the mods can see my side about this.

 

[Dante]

Please hear me out first. As if people want to whine I say let them whine!! After all, they're only opening themselves up to public humiliation. I got this idea when just recently seeing AyeCantSeeYou deal with a whiner although I can see why the rule exists, I say that we should give them what they want and deserve which is attention.

So no this isn't me complaining about the rules so if the mods still say no I will say okay, but please don't close this thread as I think that this could make for a really good and interesting discussion. I'm just curious what everybody else thinks about this and to see if the mods can see my side about this.

I'll meet you on the other side

 

[Road Runner]

I'll meet you on the other side

Ah, right on cue here's the whiner that I was speaking about on my OP.

 

[The Duke]

This thread again? Seriously?

 

[Road Runner]

This thread again? Seriously?

Oh come on don't you see my point?

 

[The Duke]

Oh come on don't you see my point?

I have seen this done like literally over 100X. It's fail. Stop.

 

[Dante]

Ah, right on cue here's the whiner that I was speaking about on my OP.

Whiner? Please do not take Liability's label away.

 

[Road Runner]

I have seen this done like literally over 100X. It's fail. Stop.

Well have you ever seen it done without a complaining attitude? I mean if people want to whine then why shouldn't they have the right to? That'll just give us the right to point and laugh at them. It's entertainment in my eyes.

 

[Dante]

I have seen this done like literally over 100X. It's fail. Stop.

RoadRunAway was a Hall Monitor during High School

 

[Road Runner]

RoadRunAway was a Hall Monitor during High School

How is this thread a hall monitor thread? I think that it's the complete opposite actually.

 

[Dante]

Well have you ever seen it done without a complaining attitude? I mean if people want to whine then why shouldn't they have the right to? That'll just give us the right to point and laugh at them. It's entertainment in my eyes.

https://www.usmessageboard.com/threads/compile-a-list-of-threads-that-violate-rules-that.1107713/#post-34664852

 

[Seymour Flops]

Oh come on don't you see my point?

I do see it.

When people troll newly posted threads with off-topic posts, and then whine about getting dinged for it, I prefer that their whining be as public as possible.

When we see such a whiner start an entire thread to cry about how wronged he feels, it is a good demonstration of how much credence we should give his few on-topic posts.

 

[Dante]

How is this thread a hall monitor thread? I think that it's the complete opposite actually.

LOL

 

[Dante]

Ah, right on cue here's the whiner that I was speaking about on my OP.

One day totals not even a full 24 hours yet

This place is nothing without the membership.

 

[Synthaholic]

I Think That We Should Change The No Discussing Moderation Actions On The Public Board Rule​

They will never go for it due to the simple fact that they sometimes make these mod decisions based on momentary emotion rather than the rules. If you are able to call them out on those occasions? Ha! You think they are going to allow themselves to lose an argument in public? No way. They would rather live with their emotional actions, never having to justify them to anyone. Even fellow mods. I've pointed out threads of mine that were dumped even though they completely followed the rules. The answer is always "I don't know who moved that thread (probably a lie), but I can't do anything about it now (probably also a lie)."

 

[Road Runner]

Btw, surprise, surprise that Procrustes Stretched was whining because he couldn't stop talking about Trump again.

Mention Harris and counter with Trump equivalency is somehow being off topic?

Clarification? I do know if one Mentions Trump it's all out attacks that take a thread off into cuckoo-land. But to counter an attack on Harris with an equivalency on Trump is not straying off a topic as far as I can figure out. Can we get a coherent well thought out clarification -- or not?

www.usmessageboard.com

 

[rightwinger]

Specific Moderator actions should not be discussed on the open board

But Moderator policies that led to that action should be fair game

 

[odanny]

All moderator actions should be made public information, if a thread is deleted or moved, it should say "This thread was moved/deleted by ____".

That no one takes accountability leads to impulsive decision making that might otherwise pass.

 

[Dante]

Specific Moderator actions should not be discussed on the open board

But Moderator policies that led to that action should be fair game

This place is nothing without the membership.

 

[boevans]

Won't happen. I have been reading this Board for almost a decade. With three particular posters now with mod power no longer, the Board has really, really become much fairer to all, imho.