excalibur
Diamond Member
- Mar 19, 2015
- 25,138
- 50,089
- 2,290
The time to do it is now.
They'd put it off before, to their own detriment.
Before the province even had a name, Alberta’s politicians demanded limits on the federal government’s power. “The new province in the West will not consent to be dictated to from Ottawa,” Calgary lawyer and senator James Lougheed said in 1904, as reported by the Weekly Albertan.
He was talking about education, but that sense of frustration with Ottawa has been a part of politicking in Alberta since the province joined Confederation in 1905.
According to the 1911 census, one in five Albertans came from south of the border, a figure much higher than the 3 percent reported across the rest of the country. Americans went on to dominate the United Farmers of Alberta, which formed the provincial government from 1921 to 1935. US investment then drove the early development of the oil and gas industry. Between 1955 and 1970, nine of the Calgary Petroleum Club’s presidents were American. The American influence on Alberta’s character has left its citizens wearing cowboy hats and boots, and also with a propensity for a “populist and anti-federalist” approach to government, says Nelson Wiseman, professor emeritus of political science at the University of Toronto.
The frustration with Ottawa came to a head in 1980 when prime minister Pierre Elliott Trudeau brought in the National Energy Program, which put price controls on Canadian natural gas and oil and routed tax revenues to the federal government. Then-premier Peter Lougheed (grandson of the earlier senator) announced that Alberta would reduce its supply of oil to the rest of the country and launch a legal challenge. Lougheed later became a driving force in adding the amending formula—which gave no province a veto but allowed dissenting provinces to opt out of amendments to the Constitution Act, 1982—and the notwithstanding clause to the Charter of Rights and Freedoms.
Throughout his battles with Trudeau, Lougheed remained committed to a united Canada. The same was not true of all Albertans. It was during this conflict that the independence movement got its first real foothold in the province. In 1982, the first separatist, Gordon Kesler, a rancher and rodeo competitor who ran under the Western Canada Concept party, was elected to the Alberta Legislature.
Since then, politicians from Alberta have pushed back against the federal government most aggressively when the Liberals are the governing party. In 2001, after Jean Chrétien won his third majority, six high-profile politicos from Alberta, including future prime minister Stephen Harper, sent an open letter to premier Ralph Klein. They called for building “firewalls around Alberta, to limit the extent to which an aggressive and hostile federal government can encroach upon legitimate provincial jurisdiction.”
We are now seeing an echo of that period—a Liberal government yet again in Ottawa, and Alberta trying to find a way to assert itself. But a few things are different this time round. For one, a segment within the separatist movement wants to join the United States. “That’s brand new, and that’s a combination of Trump’s threats of annexation combined with support of many conservatives of Donald Trump,” says Duane Bratt, professor of public policy at Mount Royal University.
For another, the push for independence appears to be coming from the top. “It is being ginned up by the government of Alberta. We’ve never had a separatist premier—a separatist government—before,” says Bratt.
Danielle Smith made her political career by befriending those most likely to see the federal government as a hostile power. In 2021, her soon-to-be chief of staff, Rob Anderson, co-wrote a document called the Free Alberta Strategy. It outlined a path to prepare the province for independence should Ottawa refuse Alberta’s demands. The following year, Smith’s first tabled bill as premier introduced the Alberta Sovereignty within a United Canada Act, which would allow the province to suspend the enforcement of federal regulations.
On April 29, 2025, with Mark Carney’s Liberal government barely a day old, Smith jumped into action. Her government introduced a bill that would loosen requirements for triggering a citizen-initiated referendum, opening the door to a vote on independence. She reiterated demands that she’d put to Carney before the election, including guaranteed access to a port for landlocked Alberta; an end to environmental regulation from the federal government; a ban on export taxes on Alberta products; and equalization payments to be switched to a per-capita basis.
And she upped the ante on the spectre of separatism.
“There is a large and growing number of Albertans that have lost hope in Alberta having a free and prosperous future as a part of Canada,” she said.
...
They'd put it off before, to their own detriment.
Before the province even had a name, Alberta’s politicians demanded limits on the federal government’s power. “The new province in the West will not consent to be dictated to from Ottawa,” Calgary lawyer and senator James Lougheed said in 1904, as reported by the Weekly Albertan.
He was talking about education, but that sense of frustration with Ottawa has been a part of politicking in Alberta since the province joined Confederation in 1905.
According to the 1911 census, one in five Albertans came from south of the border, a figure much higher than the 3 percent reported across the rest of the country. Americans went on to dominate the United Farmers of Alberta, which formed the provincial government from 1921 to 1935. US investment then drove the early development of the oil and gas industry. Between 1955 and 1970, nine of the Calgary Petroleum Club’s presidents were American. The American influence on Alberta’s character has left its citizens wearing cowboy hats and boots, and also with a propensity for a “populist and anti-federalist” approach to government, says Nelson Wiseman, professor emeritus of political science at the University of Toronto.
The frustration with Ottawa came to a head in 1980 when prime minister Pierre Elliott Trudeau brought in the National Energy Program, which put price controls on Canadian natural gas and oil and routed tax revenues to the federal government. Then-premier Peter Lougheed (grandson of the earlier senator) announced that Alberta would reduce its supply of oil to the rest of the country and launch a legal challenge. Lougheed later became a driving force in adding the amending formula—which gave no province a veto but allowed dissenting provinces to opt out of amendments to the Constitution Act, 1982—and the notwithstanding clause to the Charter of Rights and Freedoms.
Throughout his battles with Trudeau, Lougheed remained committed to a united Canada. The same was not true of all Albertans. It was during this conflict that the independence movement got its first real foothold in the province. In 1982, the first separatist, Gordon Kesler, a rancher and rodeo competitor who ran under the Western Canada Concept party, was elected to the Alberta Legislature.
Since then, politicians from Alberta have pushed back against the federal government most aggressively when the Liberals are the governing party. In 2001, after Jean Chrétien won his third majority, six high-profile politicos from Alberta, including future prime minister Stephen Harper, sent an open letter to premier Ralph Klein. They called for building “firewalls around Alberta, to limit the extent to which an aggressive and hostile federal government can encroach upon legitimate provincial jurisdiction.”
We are now seeing an echo of that period—a Liberal government yet again in Ottawa, and Alberta trying to find a way to assert itself. But a few things are different this time round. For one, a segment within the separatist movement wants to join the United States. “That’s brand new, and that’s a combination of Trump’s threats of annexation combined with support of many conservatives of Donald Trump,” says Duane Bratt, professor of public policy at Mount Royal University.
For another, the push for independence appears to be coming from the top. “It is being ginned up by the government of Alberta. We’ve never had a separatist premier—a separatist government—before,” says Bratt.
Danielle Smith made her political career by befriending those most likely to see the federal government as a hostile power. In 2021, her soon-to-be chief of staff, Rob Anderson, co-wrote a document called the Free Alberta Strategy. It outlined a path to prepare the province for independence should Ottawa refuse Alberta’s demands. The following year, Smith’s first tabled bill as premier introduced the Alberta Sovereignty within a United Canada Act, which would allow the province to suspend the enforcement of federal regulations.
On April 29, 2025, with Mark Carney’s Liberal government barely a day old, Smith jumped into action. Her government introduced a bill that would loosen requirements for triggering a citizen-initiated referendum, opening the door to a vote on independence. She reiterated demands that she’d put to Carney before the election, including guaranteed access to a port for landlocked Alberta; an end to environmental regulation from the federal government; a ban on export taxes on Alberta products; and equalization payments to be switched to a per-capita basis.
And she upped the ante on the spectre of separatism.
“There is a large and growing number of Albertans that have lost hope in Alberta having a free and prosperous future as a part of Canada,” she said.
...
