Recent content by Typist2

...which you are willing to defend in some detail.

More arguing against assertions of a poster's own invention. I never made any claim that my proposal could improve the lives of everyone on Earth. We have absorbed 10-12 million largely poor uneducated immigrants in recent years, and have not foundered. The highly educated and capable...

Not hundreds of thousands. Approximately eight million of the smartest, best educated, most capable people on Earth. And nobody "sends them" to America but themselves.

Yes, and what is the result of all that negotiation? Not peace and security for the Jewish people. At some point we should recognize the bankruptcy of that process. Except that Israel does not have the ability to make the entire middle east under Israeli control. Please recall that...

As my post reveals, depending on Arabs to do this or that in order to secure peace for Jews is not a fact, not a requirement, but a choice. It seems entirely reasonable to question the validity of making one's security policy dependent upon one's enemies. How does endlessly talking about...

Ok, fair enough. I apologize for some rhetorical excess, which is my bad, but must admit I find it tiresome to deal with thread clogging objections which can be dismissed as fast as I can type. I welcome constructive attempts to improve the plan, or replace it with a better one. It...

Laws can be changed. Consider the President who gets to go on TV and credibly claim that he has solved the Mideast conflict once and for all. Sounds like a second term for that guy. A shitload of Americans will have a cow no matter what anybody proposes about anything. Blah, blah...

Same old, same old, same old thing. I have a proposal that would make the Jews of Israel much safer than they are now, and you have no proposal. You have the energy to sit back and say why anything I type is wrong, Wrong, WRONG, but you don't have the energy to come up with a better...

All you're interested in is defeating me. This is revealed by the lack of any constructive proposal of your own. America has accepted a great many immigrants since it's founding, including as many Jews as are currently in Israel. This is a policy going back over 200 years. Um, if Jews...

Any plan, from anybody, with the potential to permanently solve the Mideast conflict is going to be objected to by somebody. If there was an easy, convenient, uncontroversial way to solve this, such a plan would have been implemented long, long ago. Therefore, I take it as a given that any...

First, please explain why the plan requires a permanent preferential treatment. Second, are you aware that U.S. immigration policy already contains a number of rules and regs which favor one group over another? As example, immigrants from Central America are treated differently than those...

A key reason that the Mideast conflict continues endlessly is that a great many people on all sides of the issue have become hopelessly addicted to the ego inflation that can be derived from the finger pointing blame game. As example, note that it's impossible to start a thread about the...

Are you aware that there are already as many Jews in the United States as there are in Israel, and nobody is complaining about that? You STILL had not received a response because you're shouting hysterical paranoid gibberish. C'mon guys, which is more important, security for Jews, or a...

The history of the Jews is that for the vast majority of Jewish history most Jews have lived somewhere other than Israel, a fact which continues to this day. Again, I have a point of view, and so do you. You are pushing your idea just as much as I am pushing mine, so let's discard this...

Well, ok, that's true, agreed. It's also true that lots of people want lots of things. Sometimes we have to decide which of the many things we want is the most important to us. I'm proposing that the Jews of Israel can have a land of their own, or durable peace and security, but...