Again in an effort to keep other threads on track
My personal belief is that Israel has a legal right to set up camp anywhere in the area of the mandate minus the territory encompassed by Jordan.
Neither Israel's application for statehood not the UNSCR 69 which ratified it mentions specific borders.
Quote
*I Resolutions or decisions on this question were also by the Council in 1946, 1947 and 1948.
adopted
la No further details of the vote are given in the record of the meeting.
10 See Of$cial Records of the Security Council, Third Year,
Supplement for December 1948, document S/1093; and ibid., annde, Supplbment de. d&imbue 1948, document S/1093; et ibid., Fourth Year, Supplement for March 1949, document S/1267. quatridme annie, SuppMment de mars 1949, document S/1267.
11
a3Voir Pro&-verbaux ofjciels du Conseil de skcuritk, troisi2me
1. Decides in its judgement that Israel is a peace- loving State and is able and willing to carry out the obligations contained in the Charter, and accordingly,
2. ,Recommendsto the General Assembly that it admit Israel to membership in the United Nations,
1. D&de qu’a son avis Isra61 est un Etat pacifique
capable de remplir les obligations ?Xle faire et, en consCquence,
2. Recommcrrlde12 I’AssemblCe
Is&l comme Membre de I’Organisation des Nations Unies.
Adopt& d la 4148 skance par 9 voiw contre une (Egypto), avec une abstention (Royaume-
Uni de Grande-Bretgne et d’lrlande du Nerd) ,
De’cision
A sa 4448 seance, le 15 septembre 1949, le Conseil a decide que les demandes d’admission a l’organisation des Nations Unies des pays &rum&es dans le projet de resolution present6 par I’Union des RCpubIiques socia- listes sovietiques 24- Albanie, RCpublique populaire de Mongolie, Bulgarie, Roumanie, Hong&, Finlande, Italie, Portugal, Irlande, Transjordanie (Jordanie), Autriche, Ceylan et Nepal - seraient mises aux voix separement.
de la Charte et dispose
Adopted at the 414th meeting by 9 votes to I (Egypt), with I abstention (United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland).
Decision
gtnerale d’admettre
At its 444th meeting,
decided that a separate vote should be taken on the application for membership in the United Nations of each country mentioned in the draft resolution submitted by the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics,24 namely, Albania, the Mongolian People’s Republic, Bulgaria, Romania, Hungary, Finland, Italy, Portugal, Ireland, Transjordan (Jordan), Austria, Ceylon and Nepal.
on 15 September
1949, the Council
Adopted by 8 votes to 3 (EgYPt* Ukrainian Soviet
Adoptge par 8 voix centre 3 (Egypte, RPpubhque sacfaliste sovi6tigue d’ukraine, Union des Rkpubliques socialistes sovit-
tiques) .
STRATEGIQUES 26
Socialist Republic, Union Soviet Socialist Republics).
of
End quote
Doesn't cut and paste very well but its clear enough. There is no mention of borders. Either in the application or the acceptance
My personal belief is that Israel has a legal right to set up camp anywhere in the area of the mandate minus the territory encompassed by Jordan.
Neither Israel's application for statehood not the UNSCR 69 which ratified it mentions specific borders.
Quote
*I Resolutions or decisions on this question were also by the Council in 1946, 1947 and 1948.
adopted
la No further details of the vote are given in the record of the meeting.
10 See Of$cial Records of the Security Council, Third Year,
Supplement for December 1948, document S/1093; and ibid., annde, Supplbment de. d&imbue 1948, document S/1093; et ibid., Fourth Year, Supplement for March 1949, document S/1267. quatridme annie, SuppMment de mars 1949, document S/1267.
11
a3Voir Pro&-verbaux ofjciels du Conseil de skcuritk, troisi2me
1. Decides in its judgement that Israel is a peace- loving State and is able and willing to carry out the obligations contained in the Charter, and accordingly,
2. ,Recommendsto the General Assembly that it admit Israel to membership in the United Nations,
1. D&de qu’a son avis Isra61 est un Etat pacifique
capable de remplir les obligations ?Xle faire et, en consCquence,
2. Recommcrrlde12 I’AssemblCe
Is&l comme Membre de I’Organisation des Nations Unies.
Adopt& d la 4148 skance par 9 voiw contre une (Egypto), avec une abstention (Royaume-
Uni de Grande-Bretgne et d’lrlande du Nerd) ,
De’cision
A sa 4448 seance, le 15 septembre 1949, le Conseil a decide que les demandes d’admission a l’organisation des Nations Unies des pays &rum&es dans le projet de resolution present6 par I’Union des RCpubIiques socia- listes sovietiques 24- Albanie, RCpublique populaire de Mongolie, Bulgarie, Roumanie, Hong&, Finlande, Italie, Portugal, Irlande, Transjordanie (Jordanie), Autriche, Ceylan et Nepal - seraient mises aux voix separement.
de la Charte et dispose
Adopted at the 414th meeting by 9 votes to I (Egypt), with I abstention (United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland).
Decision
gtnerale d’admettre
At its 444th meeting,
decided that a separate vote should be taken on the application for membership in the United Nations of each country mentioned in the draft resolution submitted by the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics,24 namely, Albania, the Mongolian People’s Republic, Bulgaria, Romania, Hungary, Finland, Italy, Portugal, Ireland, Transjordan (Jordan), Austria, Ceylon and Nepal.
on 15 September
1949, the Council
Adopted by 8 votes to 3 (EgYPt* Ukrainian Soviet
Adoptge par 8 voix centre 3 (Egypte, RPpubhque sacfaliste sovi6tigue d’ukraine, Union des Rkpubliques socialistes sovit-
tiques) .
STRATEGIQUES 26
Socialist Republic, Union Soviet Socialist Republics).
of
End quote
Doesn't cut and paste very well but its clear enough. There is no mention of borders. Either in the application or the acceptance
