In comparing the two brothers, there is no way statistically that Eli is in his brothers league. When you look at yardage thrown, TDs to Ints, QB ratings and four league MVPs, Peyton is a top 5 QB of all time. But Peyton has always had teams he could not beat. In College, he could not beat Florida. Spurrier got in his head. In the pros, he could not beat New England. Bill B had his number. For a dozen years, Indianapolis was a favored team to win at the start of the season. Once the playoffs started, the Colts were almost always a top seed and favored to win. Peyton never seemed to come up big. Eli and the Giants were never favored to win anything. Eli came up big in big games and carried teams that were far from great to two championships. Where Peyton has been an underachiever with the teams he played for, Eli has been an overachiever Eli also has something Peyton doesn't........Historic wins Beating an 18-0 team with a last second game winning drive is perhaps the most historic win in all of football Repeating it against the same team is also historic. There is no single win in Peytons career where he had a monster drive in a huge game to win. No unbelievable play where he came up big in crunch time. In the Manning gene pool, Peyton got most of the raw talent. Eli got most of the heart.