Did RNC Talking Points Cherry Pick CBO Report?

Discussion in 'Current Events' started by rayboyusmc, Jan 27, 2009.

  1. rayboyusmc
    Offline

    rayboyusmc Senior Member

    Joined:
    Jan 2, 2008
    Messages:
    4,015
    Thanks Received:
    338
    Trophy Points:
    48
    Location:
    Florida
    Ratings:
    +338


    Clinton: Iran Must Choose Whether To Cooperate With West
    More in Politics: Obama Economy... Specter To Support Holder... Palin Sets Up PAC...
    McCain Blogger: We Almost Kicked NYT Off Our Plane
    Revealed: Rahm's Daily Calls To Begala, Carville, Stephanopolous
    Key Democrat Slams Stimulus, Predicts More Bailouts
    TV Media Cited Bogus CBO Report At Least 81 Times
    WATCH: What Happened To The White House Solar Panels?
    Pentagon No. 2 Could Earn $500K Lobbying Pentagon
    Your request is being processed... Ryan Grim ryan@huffingtonpost.com | HuffPost Reporting From DC Become a Fan Get Email Alerts from this Reporter Controversial CBO Report On Stimulus Turns Out Not To Exist
    stumble digg reddit del.ico.us mixx.com ShareThisJanuary 23, 2009 06:45 PM

    Read More: Cbo, Cbo Report, Cbo Report On Stimulus, Cbo Report Stimulus, Cbo Score Stimulus, Cbo Stimulus, Congressional Budget Office, Huffington Post Cbo, Stimulus Cbo, Politics News
    Show your support.
    Buzz this article up.
    Buzz up!

    Get Breaking News Alerts

    never spam
    Share Print CommentsReports of a recent study by the Congressional Budget Office, showing that the vast majority of the money in the stimulus package won't be spent until after 2010, have Democrats on the defensive and the GOP calling for a pullback in wasteful spending.

    Funny thing is, there is no such report.

    "We did not issue any report, any analysis or any study," a CBO aide told the Huffington Post.

    Rather, the nonpartisan CBO ran a small portion of an earlier version of the stimulus plan through a computer program that uses a standard formula to determine a score -- how quickly money will be spent. The score only dealt with the part of the stimulus headed for the Appropriations Committee and left out the parts bound for the Ways and Means or Energy and Commerce Committee.

    Because it dealt with just a part of the stimulus, it estimated the spending rate for only about $300 billion of the $825 billion plan. Significant changes have been made to the part of the bill the CBO looked at.

    The CBO numbers were given to a small number of congressional Democrats and Republicans, but were not posted online because they're not an official CBO product. (Media outlets, while reporting widely about the "report," have declined to post it online. Here's the whole thing.) Democratic aides say they are certain that the GOP leaked it to the Associated Press in order to undercut the spending portion of the stimulus.

    A Republican aide for the House Appropriations Committee denied involvement, saying that her staff did not see the CBO numbers until after the AP reported them. The Washington Post followed the AP and reported that aides to Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.) provided the report.

    "I didn't leak it. It was sent to the Hill and considered public. If a reporter was writing on it I made sure they had access to it; it's a public document," said McConnell spokesman Don Stewart in an e-mail.

    Story continues below

    Following the press reports, House Minority Leader John Boehner (R-Ohio) pounced, citing the AP, Post, and other reports to make the case that the spending was wasteful. Republican aides roamed the Capitol press galleries, flogging the CBO numbers.

    The press broadly picked up on it and a simple narrative developed: the stimulus bill won't stimulate the economy. The administration tried to push back against the CBO numbers, sending around a set of talking points making the case that the "new CBO spendout rate report is being taken out of context."

    Nevertheless, the narrative continued to dominate. Obama spokesman Robert Gibbs was asked about the CBO numbers Friday by Fox News' Major Garrett, who told Gibbs that "the CBO has said that $219 billion of the $825 billion in the House bill cannot be spent and will not be spent until 2011 at the earliest....What is the President's appraisal of that CBO analysis, and what do you know here that the Congressional Budget Office, a neutral observer, doesn't know?"

    Gibbs told the press that the report looked at "only a portion of the legislation and looked at that portion of the legislation before it began the committee process." Gibbs added that it reflected "a snapshot in time that's long past."

    The White House followed up with a letter from Peter Orszag, head of the Office of Management and Budget. The CBO "analysis, however, did not assess the overall package," wrote Orszag. "Our analysis indicates that at least 75 percent of the overall package (including its tax component and the other spending provisions that were not analyzed by the Congressional Budget Office) will be spent over the next year and a half."

    A new CBO score is due out next week.

    If they change the report to be more favorable to the package, will Fox and friends publish this?

    Controversial CBO Report On Stimulus Turns Out Not To Exist
     

Share This Page