Discussion in 'Music' started by -Cp, May 26, 2005.
Which one do you think was the most deserving on the recent "American Idol"?
Both are fantastic, but Carrie carries that country singing twang into almost every song.
I thought Bo was much more versatile. For that reason I thought he should have won.
But hey, they both won we know that.
Carrie is much better looking IMO, I enjoy looking at her. Therefore I think she should have won.
She's a FOX (do they still use that term?). But Bo energized the stage every time he walked on,
no one else did that.
My reasoning exactly!
For me personally, Bo sings the kind of music I'm more apt to listen to, and he's damn good at it. But I liked Carrie too, and for those stretchs I lean toward country music she would fit the bill nicely. There was no wrong choice this time around.
Bo had a much better stage presence and seemed to be more comfortable on stage. He also took a lot of chances to exhibit his talent that Carrie did not take. His performance with Led Zeppelin was outstanding. He seemed like he had been performing with them forever. I usually like country music much better than rock, but this time I thought Bo's talent was greater than Carrie's. I am sure he will be another Clay Aiken and do just fine in the music business.
I think both of them will rock the charts...
Carrie can rock my...uh I mean, ya..what Mr P said.
Definitely Bo.. Carrie's so...'typical', and very predictable. Bo had an awesome range of abilities...
(And he's hot to boot!)
Separate names with a comma.