Biden Amin. should've adopted an enclave strategy in Afghanistan.

[harmonica]

Way to move the goalposts. I said nothing about turning all of Afghanistan into an enclave and you well know it

You are being dishonest.

hahahhahaha---no, I didn't move anything--just adding ANOTHER point on how it's totally different
...and, doesn't matter---you can't have that many enclaves per territory because Afghanistan is MUCH bigger
...what will these enclaves accomplish?

 

[Dayton3]

hahahhahaha---no, I didn't move anything--just adding ANOTHER point on how it's totally different
...and, doesn't matter---you can't have that many enclaves per territory because Afghanistan is MUCH bigger
...what will these enclaves accomplish?

I never suggested what you are claiming. You are dishonest. I could say a liar but I would suggest you are simply ignorant about what you are talking about.

Try studying some history.

 

[harmonica]

Oh yeah, 66,000 Afghan soldiers were killed in battle because they "didn't give a shit".

Tell some more lies.

YOU are dishonest--the Taliban went through the country like a hot knife through butter
surrenders after surrenders ----some without a fight--the ANA had American equipment/vehicles/etc--STOP the bullshit----the ANA was crap --just like a lot of South Vietnamese units ....North Vietnam also took care of the South Vietnamese ''quickly''

Hundreds of Afghan troops surrender to Taliban near Kunduz

Hundreds of Afghan security forces on Wednesday surrendered to the Taliban near the northern city of Kunduz, which was seized by the militant group earlier this week.The Washington Post r…

thehill.com

 

[harmonica]

I never suggested what you are claiming. You are dishonest. I could say a liar but I would suggest you are simply ignorant about what you are talking about.

Try studying some history.

Berlin and Afghanistan !!!! hHAHAHHAHAHAHAHHAH wooooojoogogoogogogoooohoohoho
.....sounds like you've been doing drugs

 

[Dayton3]

YOU are dishonest--the Taliban went through the country like a hot knife through butter
surrenders after surrenders ----some without a fight--the ANA had American equipment/vehicles/etc--STOP the bullshit----the ANA was crap --just like a lot of South Vietnamese units ....North Vietnam also took care of the South Vietnamese ''quickly''

Hundreds of Afghan troops surrender to Taliban near Kunduz

Hundreds of Afghan security forces on Wednesday surrendered to the Taliban near the northern city of Kunduz, which was seized by the militant group earlier this week.The Washington Post r…

thehill.com

Dishonest on your part. The Afghan National Army was abandoned by the United States just as the South Vietnamese Army was abandoned by the United States.

How can you expect people to fight when their most powerful ally abandons them?

 

[harmonica]

Dayton3 you just admitted they can't fight their own wars---which they should--thank you --yes-yes-yes

 

[Dayton3]

Dayton3 you just admitted they can't fight their own wars--

Why? The U.S. didn't win its independence on its own.

 

[harmonica]

Dayton3 hahhahahahahahh--you haven't proved they will work ...YOU claimed it--YOU have to prove it

 

[Dayton3]

Dayton3 hahhahahahahahh--you haven't proved they will work ...YOU claimed it--YOU have to prove it

West Berlin worked quite admirably. I know there are major differences between Berlin and Afghanistan but that in no way indicates the same basic strategy would not work.

 

[Dayton3]

from the wikipedia entry on West Berlin harmonica


West Berlin (German: Berlin (West) or West-Berlin) was a political enclave which comprised the western part of Berlin during the years of the Cold War.

 

[harmonica]

Dayton3 BERLIN!!!!!! it's nothing like Afghanistan ----that is beyond ridiculous

 

[Dayton3]

Dayton3 BERLIN!!!!!! it's nothing like Afghanistan ----that is beyond ridiculous

I said there were major differences. Why do you continue to babble the same line like a mantra?

 

[harmonica]

Dayton3 so, there's major differences, but you say they are comparable????!!!

 

[Dayton3]

Dayton3 so, there's major differences, but you say they are comparable????!!!

I never said that.

 

[Mushroom]

I never said that.

Ultimately, it does not matter. You will never do any good talking with people that have their mind completely made up, and have no room for any thoughts other than their own. It has been decided it is a bad idea, therefore it is a bad idea.

Is why I barely even try any more. A lot in here have shown they have absolutely no concept at all, they are entirely talking from a political viewpoint. That is all the justification they need.