Are nuclear weapons incompatible with democracy?

Delta4Embassy

Gold Member
Dec 12, 2013
25,744
3,044
280
Earth
Nuclear weapons are incompatible with the U.S. constitution and democracy Harvard Magazine Mar-Apr 2014

"In her new book, Thermonuclear Monarchy: Choosing Between Democracy and Doom (W.W. Norton), Scarry argues that the very existence of nuclear arsenals is irreconcilable with the U.S. Constitution and in fact betrays the basic purpose of the social contract that governs any civil society: forestalling injurious behavior. “Nuclear weapons undo governments, and undo anything that could be meant by democracy,” she says. “They put the population completely outside the realm of overseeing our entry into war—or having a say in their own survival or destruction. We have to choose between nuclear weapons and democracy.”

In her book, Scarry asserts that the United States, “…a country formerly dependent on its population, its legislature, and its executive acting in concert for any act of defense—has now largely eliminated its population and its legislature from the sphere of defense, and relies exclusively on its executive.”

Nuclear weapons are monarchic."

rest at link
 
This is a Republic.....not a Democracy.

Actually, the US is a democracy. Did you not notice that leaders are chosen by majority votes, and that majority votes also are the method for passing our legislation? Just because it's a republic does not mean it is not also a democracy. The two are not mutually exclusive.

So why do you hate democracies? Why do you refuse to admit the democratic side of America?
 
This is a Republic.....not a Democracy.

Actually, the US is a democracy. Did you not notice that leaders are chosen by majority votes, and that majority votes also are the method for passing our legislation? Just because it's a republic does not mean it is not also a democracy. The two are not mutually exclusive.

And you're lying about my supposedly hating Democracy. Why do you hate the truth????

So why do you hate democracies? Why do you refuse to admit the democratic side of America?

Our elections are Democratic, but our government is a republic. We elect representatives to vote in our stead.
 

Forum List

Back
Top