Should private donations to Israel be tax deductible?

[RoccoR]

RE: Should private donations to Israel be tax deductible?
⁜→ P F Tinmore, et al,

BLUF: Don't get excited. The catch is this. You have been advocating the Right of the Arab Palestinians to kill any Jewish Citizen anywhere for anything. That is NOT the spirit of the intent.

m. The duty of a State to refrain from using terrorist practices as state policy against another State or against peoples under colonial domination, foreign occupation or racist regimes and to prevent any assistance to or use of or tolerance of terrorist groups, saboteurs or subversive agents against third States;

...

(COMMENT)

The reason this does not work → is that the Arab Palestinian don't believe in this or live by this at all. They see it as a set of protections that only apply to the Arab Palestinians and NOT the Israelis (Jewish immigrants).

In April 1920, the Allied Powers convened in San Remo, Italy to discuss a Treaty with Turkey and the Mandates for the Occupied Enemy Territory and the Administration to follow. It was then that the Allied Powers adopted the Balfour Declaration. During that same period, the Grand Mufti (a former Ottoman Army Officer) helped to organize riots in Nebi Musa and Jerusalem.

The propensity for Arab Palestinian Violence became evermore pronounced with each advancement in the establishment of self-governing institutions in which the Jewish Agency helped to develop, but for which the Arab Higher Committee rejected.

Most Respectfully,
R

 

[Hollie]

RE: Should private donations to Israel be tax deductible?
⁜→ P F Tinmore, et al,

BLUF: In normal banter in this forum thread, we tend to equate the State of Israel and the Jewish National Home as one in the same. Since we don't talk about the Jewish National Home much as a special identity, in 98% of the discussion in the thread, it makes no difference. BUT! In this case, it does.

SHORT ANSWER: No!

What if for 1% of US GDP, Britain had the power to override your strategic decisions?

Youtube Video

(COMMENT)

Setting aside (for the moment) the Balfour Declaration (1917) at the San Remo Conference (1920) the Allied Powers effectively formed a legally binding pact → to establish → in Palestine → a National Home for the Jewish people.

◈ The concept forging "Israel" is based on a political framework through the Right of Self-Determination.​

​

◈ The concept of assembling a Jewish National Home is based on a framework of Religious Freedom.​

The first concept is the assistance and aid to a foreign government in its self-protection of Israel against those entities, and non-state actors, attempting to overthrow the very well developed free state by a league of nations that are not quite competative with Israel.

The second concept is the a 501(c)(3) tax-exempt status for the protection and preservation for the religious organization pertaining to the Jewish Faith.

(IF-THEN CONDITIONAL ANSWER)

Contributions to Israel do not fall under the intent of religious freedom exemption applicable to the Jewish National Home [501(c)(3) tax-exempt status]. NOW! IF the intent of the donation is to contribute to the protection and preservation for the freedom afforded to the Jewish National Home, THEN that does meet the intent of the tax exemption.

NOTE (See the difference?):
• The purpose of the Israeli Defense Force (IDF) is to preserve the State of Israel, to protect its independence, and to foil attempts by its enemies to disrupt normal life within it.

• International Board of Jewish Missions (IBJM) is a multi-faceted worldwide mission organization that reaches out specifically to God’s chosen people, the Jews. Most of our ministries are designed to help our current missionaries reach Jewish people, and enlist and train new missionaries to further the work of Christ.
• The Mission of the Jewish Agency (and associate or subsidiary companies) is to plant the seeds of friendship between Jewish communities separated by distance, since 1929, we have been securing a vibrant Jewish future for generations to come.

Just my thought...

Most Respectfully,
R

Setting aside (for the moment) the Balfour Declaration (1917) at the San Remo Conference (1920) the Allied Powers effectively formed a legally binding pact → to establish → in Palestine → a National Home for the Jewish people.

You love that external interference. Those with the guns can hand out rights to their friends. Must be that old government employment talking.

The LoN and the Mandate could not, and did not, create a Jewish state. The creation of Israel was a unilateral move that was outside of the legal framework for a "national home."

Israel is the mooch capital of the world. It was created with OPM and exists on OPM.

You’re getting frantic. You’re not thinking clearly.

Israel Economy Facts & Stats

Find out how Israel ranks internationally on Economy. Get the facts and compare to other countries!

www.nationmaster.com

Tell us more about your silly “mooch” slogan.

Offer comparisons to the mini-caliphates (welfare black holes) of Gaza and the West Bank.

Tell us more about your silly “mooch” slogan.

Sure, everything from Rothschild to the little blue boxes, to foreign country handouts, to Golda Mair going to the US to mooch money for their 1948 war, to tax deductible "charities," to sweetheart corporate deals. Not to mention everything stolen from the Palestinians including robbing all the banks in Palestine in 1948.

There is not a bigger bunch of freeloaders on the planet.

That was a drooling reiteration of so many of your conspiracy theories. As expected, you didn't address the nationmaster data showing that Israel has developed a world-class economy.

That hurts your feelings, right?

Is deflection all you got?

Pretty typical slogan when you can't form a coherent response.