Senate Precedent: Former Civil Officer Put On Trial For Acts While In Office!

mascale

Gold Member
Feb 22, 2009
6,836
800
130
Likely House Managers will be successful during the first day debate about the Constitutional Ability to even create the Senate Trial of the Article of Impeachment. The reason is that the Senate already--decades ago--settled the issue. The impeached at that time was a Secretary of War, Belknap. At the bottom of the article linked, there is that and also another one named.


_____________________________
Scholar Frank O. Bowman also pointed out another precedent: the 1876 impeachment trial of William Belknap, who served as Secretary of War for President Ulysses S. Grant. Belknap faced allegations of receiving kickbacks, and he resigned moments before the House approved articles of impeachment. The House charged Belknap with “basely prostituting his high office to his lust for private gain.” At Belknap’s trial, the Senate passed a motion in a 37 to 29 vote that “William W. Belknap, the respondent, is amenable to trial by impeachment for acts done as Secretary of War, notwithstanding his resignation of said office before he was impeached.” The Senate later acquitted Belknap on all charges, lacking a two-thirds majority to convict.

A third precedent is the case of federal judge West Hughes Humphries. Humphries left the federal bench in Tennessee to join the Confederacy as a judge without resigning his federal commission. In January 1862, House member John Bingham led the investigating committee, which charged Humphries with high crimes and misdemeanors. The Senate found Humphries guilty on seven charges in June 1862, and in a separate vote, a unanimous Senate disqualified Humphries from holding federal office again.
_____________________________

Pundits agree that the Trumped-Up Administration had effectively abdicated presidential duties by November 5, 2020(?)! Still, the actual term went through to completion, timely creating the Impeachment Article with the basis in the widely known evidence. A Senate vote was taken, and passed: even in 1876.

"Crow, James Crow: Shaken, Not Stirred!'
(Pharaoh's subjugation, alliance arithmetic: Is alleged of a deity, even now: Deut: 23: 19-20. The precedent created the fact of Holocaust, according to many, over the centuries.)
 
The fantasy of vindictive feelings from the snowflake children rolls on as having witch hunted for years they will try and burn the witch at the stake even though the witch has no powers anymore
Vindictive retaliatory innane snd childish are these “leaders” who are anything but leaders but are masters of feelings obsessions and appeasement
 
Guessing Pelosi told the Capitol police to remove barricades and open the doors.
 
Likely House Managers will be successful during the first day debate about the Constitutional Ability to even create the Senate Trial of the Article of Impeachment. The reason is that the Senate already--decades ago--settled the issue. The impeached at that time was a Secretary of War, Belknap. At the bottom of the article linked, there is that and also another one named.


_____________________________
Scholar Frank O. Bowman also pointed out another precedent: the 1876 impeachment trial of William Belknap, who served as Secretary of War for President Ulysses S. Grant. Belknap faced allegations of receiving kickbacks, and he resigned moments before the House approved articles of impeachment. The House charged Belknap with “basely prostituting his high office to his lust for private gain.” At Belknap’s trial, the Senate passed a motion in a 37 to 29 vote that “William W. Belknap, the respondent, is amenable to trial by impeachment for acts done as Secretary of War, notwithstanding his resignation of said office before he was impeached.” The Senate later acquitted Belknap on all charges, lacking a two-thirds majority to convict.

A third precedent is the case of federal judge West Hughes Humphries. Humphries left the federal bench in Tennessee to join the Confederacy as a judge without resigning his federal commission. In January 1862, House member John Bingham led the investigating committee, which charged Humphries with high crimes and misdemeanors. The Senate found Humphries guilty on seven charges in June 1862, and in a separate vote, a unanimous Senate disqualified Humphries from holding federal office again.
_____________________________

Pundits agree that the Trumped-Up Administration had effectively abdicated presidential duties by November 5, 2020(?)! Still, the actual term went through to completion, timely creating the Impeachment Article with the basis in the widely known evidence. A Senate vote was taken, and passed: even in 1876.

"Crow, James Crow: Shaken, Not Stirred!'
(Pharaoh's subjugation, alliance arithmetic: Is alleged of a deity, even now: Deut: 23: 19-20. The precedent created the fact of Holocaust, according to many, over the centuries.)
He wasn't the president.
 
He was the precedent. The Republicans will be fielding the bogus deflection defense that precedent does not apply in Senate Impeachment trial, on Articles passed during the term of office. Further in common is the matter that the Chief Justice is also under no Constitutional compulsion to vacate regular duties: That since the criminal has already left the building--and effectively since November 5, 2020.

"Crow, James Crow: Shaken, Not Stirred!'
(Pharaoh's subjugation, alliance arithmetic: Is alleged of a deity, even now: Deut: 23: 19-20. The precedent created the fact of Holocaust, according to many, over the centuries.)
 
He was the precedent. The Republicans will be fielding the bogus deflection defense that precedent does not apply in Senate Impeachment trial, on Articles passed during the term of office. Further in common is the matter that the Chief Justice is also under no Constitutional compulsion to vacate regular duties: That since the criminal has already left the building--and effectively since November 5, 2020.

"Crow, James Crow: Shaken, Not Stirred!'
(Pharaoh's subjugation, alliance arithmetic: Is alleged of a deity, even now: Deut: 23: 19-20. The precedent created the fact of Holocaust, according to many, over the centuries.)

If they pull it off, it will set the stage for impeaching Obama when the Republicans regain congressional control in 2022. Long overdue, given that Obama is a war criminal.
 
He was the precedent. The Republicans will be fielding the bogus deflection defense that precedent does not apply in Senate Impeachment trial, on Articles passed during the term of office. Further in common is the matter that the Chief Justice is also under no Constitutional compulsion to vacate regular duties: That since the criminal has already left the building--and effectively since November 5, 2020.

"Crow, James Crow: Shaken, Not Stirred!'
(Pharaoh's subjugation, alliance arithmetic: Is alleged of a deity, even now: Deut: 23: 19-20. The precedent created the fact of Holocaust, according to many, over the centuries.)
Biden is the criminal. That is why the Dems impeached Trump the first time because he asked about the Biden crimes in the Ukraine on a phone call.
 
He was the precedent. The Republicans will be fielding the bogus deflection defense that precedent does not apply in Senate Impeachment trial, on Articles passed during the term of office. Further in common is the matter that the Chief Justice is also under no Constitutional compulsion to vacate regular duties: That since the criminal has already left the building--and effectively since November 5, 2020.

"Crow, James Crow: Shaken, Not Stirred!'
(Pharaoh's subjugation, alliance arithmetic: Is alleged of a deity, even now: Deut: 23: 19-20. The precedent created the fact of Holocaust, according to many, over the centuries.)

If they pull it off, it will set the stage for impeaching Obama when the Republicans regain congressional control in 2022. Long overdue, given that Obama is a war criminal.
And they can impeach Kamala in 2022, as Joe Xi will have resigned by then.
 
There is no "If." The precedent is sufficiently ancient history to have already been by-passed in the Obama Administration. The brake has been applied already. That April 15, "Timely" stuff still applies.

"Crow, James Crow: Shaken, Not Stirred!'
(Pharaoh's subjugation, alliance arithmetic: Is alleged of a deity, even now: Deut: 23: 19-20. The precedent created the fact of Holocaust, according to many, over the centuries.)
 
He was the precedent. The Republicans will be fielding the bogus deflection defense that precedent does not apply in Senate Impeachment trial, on Articles passed during the term of office. Further in common is the matter that the Chief Justice is also under no Constitutional compulsion to vacate regular duties: That since the criminal has already left the building--and effectively since November 5, 2020.

"Crow, James Crow: Shaken, Not Stirred!'
(Pharaoh's subjugation, alliance arithmetic: Is alleged of a deity, even now: Deut: 23: 19-20. The precedent created the fact of Holocaust, according to many, over the centuries.)

If they pull it off, it will set the stage for impeaching Obama when the Republicans regain congressional control in 2022. Long overdue, given that Obama is a war criminal.
Not to mention that he affected 1/6 of the US economy by intentionally lying to the American People about keeping your doctor.

Oh,....but wait....he is clean and articulate....a story book man.....so that gives him a pass?
 
He was the precedent. The Republicans will be fielding the bogus deflection defense that precedent does not apply in Senate Impeachment trial, on Articles passed during the term of office. Further in common is the matter that the Chief Justice is also under no Constitutional compulsion to vacate regular duties: That since the criminal has already left the building--and effectively since November 5, 2020.

"Crow, James Crow: Shaken, Not Stirred!'
(Pharaoh's subjugation, alliance arithmetic: Is alleged of a deity, even now: Deut: 23: 19-20. The precedent created the fact of Holocaust, according to many, over the centuries.)

If they pull it off, it will set the stage for impeaching Obama when the Republicans regain congressional control in 2022. Long overdue, given that Obama is a war criminal.
And they can impeach Kamala in 2022, as Joe Xi will have resigned by then.
I give him another 4 months before Pelosi invokes the 25th amendment and Kamala lassos in the cabinet. It was not Trump Pelosi was after with that move....it was Biden. That's my opinion
 
SC Patriot contending that a large population of uninsured is just what the Pandemic needs(?)! Dead children everywhere, now to be said the Republican brand(?)!

"Crow, James Crow: Shaken, Not Stirred!'
(Pharaoh's subjugation, alliance arithmetic: Is alleged of a deity, even now: Deut: 23: 19-20. The precedent created the fact of Holocaust, according to many, over the centuries.)
 
SC Patriot contending that a large population of uninsured is just the Pandemic needs(?)! Dead children everywhere, now to be said the Republican brand(?)!

"Crow, James Crow: Shaken, Not Stirred!'
(Pharaoh's subjugation, alliance arithmetic: Is alleged of a deity, even now: Deut: 23: 19-20. The precedent created the fact of Holocaust, according to many, over the centuries.)
you are a sick dude.

Cya
 
Fortunately, there is ObamaCare: Despite all the protests and claims of reform--actually never attempted. The Precedent goes forward!

"Crow, James Crow: Shaken, Not Stirred!'
(Pharaoh's subjugation, alliance arithmetic: Is alleged of a deity, even now: Deut: 23: 19-20. The precedent created the fact of Holocaust, according to many, over the centuries.)
 

Forum List

Back
Top