Pumped hydro

Old Rocks

Diamond Member
Oct 31, 2008
63,085
9,749
2,040
Portland, Ore.
Here in the Pacific Northwest they plan to have a reservoir both at the top and the bottom. That alleviates environmental problems, both from leakage of coolents and lubricants, and also from water temperature. Put this in tandem with battery storage, and you have instantaneous response to the demands of the grid, as well has a huge reserve.

 
Water Mills work just as efficiently with NO toxic waste of any kind, and NO pollution of any kind!!!

Water Mills have double uses as water pumps AND electric "turbines". Again, without toxic waste or pollution of any kind.

water-mill-3.jpg


carriage-wheel-water-mill-portogruaro-260nw-144745924.jpg
 
Here in the Pacific Northwest they plan to have a reservoir both at the top and the bottom. That alleviates environmental problems, both from leakage of coolents and lubricants, and also from water temperature. Put this in tandem with battery storage, and you have instantaneous response to the demands of the grid, as well has a huge reserve.



Not a new thing. Also not suitable for everywhere. Not everybody has hills. Mainly just wanted to point out that water will seep into the ground so the no leakage thing isn't quite right. BTW, the top lake is the "battery" in these systems. There is no need for additional battery storage.
 
Not a new thing. Also not suitable for everywhere. Not everybody has hills. Mainly just wanted to point out that water will seep into the ground so the no leakage thing isn't quite right. BTW, the top lake is the "battery" in these systems. There is no need for additional battery storage.
Yes, there is a need for the battery. A battery like the one at the Hornsdale wind farm reacts in milli-seconds. It take a minute or more for the pumped hydro to react. That reaction time is important for grid stability. However, it would be far smaller in MW/hrs than the hydro storage.
 
Water Mills work just as efficiently with NO toxic waste of any kind, and NO pollution of any kind!!!

Water Mills have double uses as water pumps AND electric "turbines". Again, without toxic waste or pollution of any kind.

water-mill-3.jpg


carriage-wheel-water-mill-portogruaro-260nw-144745924.jpg
Now that technology has been around for a long, long time However, it is not efficient compared to a water turbine.
 
How much power does it take to pump all that water up and how much do you get when you release it?

Not to mention removing those umpteen millions of gallons of fresh water from our already over taxed fresh water supply.

Yeah real smart.
 
Here in the Pacific Northwest they plan to have a reservoir both at the top and the bottom. That alleviates environmental problems, both from leakage of coolents and lubricants, and also from water temperature. Put this in tandem with battery storage, and you have instantaneous response to the demands of the grid, as well has a huge reserve.



Are the greens going to let you do that?
How much pumped storage do you need to replace the dams the greens want to eliminate?
 
Yes, there is a need for the battery. A battery like the one at the Hornsdale wind farm reacts in milli-seconds. It take a minute or more for the pumped hydro to react. That reaction time is important for grid stability. However, it would be far smaller in MW/hrs than the hydro storage.

The grid has far more time to adapt than "milli-seconds" to changes in supply and demand. . No batteries are not needed for hydro design like this one. That is the point of them. They can move excess capacity to move water up the hill to sit until needed at night. The US uses a 60 Hz system and doesn't go bonkers until it hits 49 Hz like happened in Texas...possibly....there were too many competing official stories to know if automatic load shedding safeties were to blame or not there.
 
The grid has far more time to adapt than "milli-seconds" to changes in supply and demand.
The reason some grid scale fast lithium ion battery storage is increasingly being used is well explained in the video here.
They can move excess capacity to move water up the hill to sit until needed at night.
Wind generators still operate at night and in dark, stormy weather. Also, peak energy demand occurs during the day so how could it be any more "needed" at night?
 
Some think of it as perpetual motion.

It is not.

Efficiency is far less than 100%. It's a game but it's not a free game.
It is not "perpetual motion" for reasons having to do with wear and tear, not efficiency. However, wherever the Sun is the ultimate energy source, as opposed to using freshly extracted carbon or other pollutants like radioactive elements, the power generated is essentially "free" since the Sun charges us nothing and there's no ongoing production of waste byproducts to clean up. This is why open systems, like water wheels, are naturally more efficient than any imaginable "closed system" competitor. What counts is C.O.P. or coefficient of performance, whereas "efficiency" is most often propaganda meaning "uses less fossil fuel to accomplish what it did before with more."
 
Last edited:
The reason some grid scale fast lithium ion battery storage is increasingly being used is well explained in the video here.

Wind generators still operate at night and in dark, stormy weather. Also, peak energy demand occurs during the day so how could it be any more "needed" at night?

He's saying the water can be moved at night, not that the peak demand is at night.
 
Here in the Pacific Northwest they plan to have a reservoir both at the top and the bottom. That alleviates environmental problems, both from leakage of coolents and lubricants, and also from water temperature. Put this in tandem with battery storage, and you have instantaneous response to the demands of the grid, as well has a huge reserve.


Glad you’ve left 1960 and joined 2021.
 

Forum List

Back
Top