I'm one of the fans they GAINED with the Black Album. Early stuff just sounded too cold and brittle. But now after hearing them in concert tuned down to Eb, their early stuff sounds much better.
I hated St Anger and put it away for a few years then went back to it. There's plenty of heavy riffs in it but its just hard to hear in slinky Cb. I put together a compilation of St. And Death Magnetic tunes that run about an hour or so. Believe it or not, those two albums fit together pretty well!
I keep playing this one concert over and over. They let the fans chose the set list and some come on stage and introduce the songs. How cool is that?