Interesting Concept on Electric Vehicles

candycorn

Diamond Member
Aug 25, 2009
107,306
39,335
2,250
Deep State Plant.
Imagine This:

Not having to charge your electric vehicle. Instead, what you do is once a week or so, you drive to a swap station and an automated robot removes your depleted battery and installs a fully charged one. The whole process takes about 10 minutes--about the same amount of time you would spend at a Chevron station--and off you go.

This is supposedly going to become the reality in China:

DETROIT/BEIJING, March 25 (Reuters) - A year ago Tesla dismissed the alternative path of electric car battery swapping as "riddled with problems and not suitable for widescale use". It seems Beijing disagrees.
In fact, China is pushing hard for swappable batteries for electric vehicles (EVs) as a supplement to regular vehicle charging, with the government throwing its weight behind several companies advancing the technology.
Four companies - automakers Nio and Geely, battery swap developer Aulton and state-owned oil producer Sinopec (600028.SS) - say they plan to establish a total of 24,000 swap stations across the country by 2025, up from about 1,400 today.

The article mentions the benefits of not having to hunt for a place that may or may not have your specific car's compatible charging station. It would be much like having to hunt for a specific brand of gasoline for which you have a credit card--a Chevron as opposed to an Exxon station. It would also help simplify the power grid demand. Instead of placing charging stations in the parking lot of a Truck Stop or Cracker Barrel, there would be a centralized area where you could take your vehicle.

The big issue, of course, is standardization across a single manufacturer and, if possible across multiple manufacturers. It would be like the VHS was...every company who made a VHS player may put their own spin on the features and quality but the mechanics of the device. Every studio who put out a movie, did so on VHS. It was the standard. Currently there is no standard. But this looks like it could be a game changer because it doesn't require you to upgrade your house, you can live in an apartment and simply have your batteries swapped out, and it is scalable for micro uses as well. Consider your local police department for example. Largely, they have the same vehicles. They could have a private battery swapping operation that services only their vehicles. Ditto for a local package carrier like USPS and Federal Express. Internal combustion engines would still be required to go from city to city carrying heavy loads but last mile deliveries could be all electric if they could standardize the vehicles.
 
SOOOOOO many problems with this.

These batteries would cost triple what they do now!
Warehousing batteries would be a logistically nightmare because of thier size and contents.
Warehousing would have to be secured and climate controlled, resulting in higher expenses.
A battery warehouse catching fire would do unimaginable deadly/toxic damage to the local environment for decades.
AI and automation is only as good as it's programmed to be, which can be deadly for the consumer if even one little thing is missed.
The constant wear and tear on constant battery replacement on the vehicle would become immeasurable and ultra expensive to fix.
The batteries removed would just be recharged and reused, more than likely without any qualtiy control of any kind, making it even
more dangerous for the consumer, as they wouldn't know if they recieved a damaged battery or not until it is too late.



The auto companies are just looking for ways to fuck people over even more than they do right now.
There is NOTHING wrong with creating a battery system in any EV where it recharges itself while driving!!!
And NOBODY has every answered my question.......WHAT the hell happened to the ORIGINAL Tesla's, where they had solar roofs to recharge the battery while parked?
 
SOOOOOO many problems with this.

These batteries would cost triple what they do now!
Not sure why that is the case. Explain.
Warehousing batteries would be a logistically nightmare because of thier size and contents.
That doesn't seem to make any sense because (a) you can limit the size of the facility by the number of batteries and (b), a battery pack for a car isn't all that large.
Warehousing would have to be secured and climate controlled, resulting in higher expenses.
Probably. It looks like they would be underground so that would mitigate a lot of the issue.
A battery warehouse catching fire would do unimaginable deadly/toxic damage to the local environment for decades.
Gee, we have battery warehouses now. Nobody is worrying too much about them.
AI and automation is only as good as it's programmed to be, which can be deadly for the consumer if even one little thing is missed.
I guess so...maybe? It doesn't sound like you're thought this thing through if you're relying on "one little thing" silliness.
The constant wear and tear on constant battery replacement on the vehicle would become immeasurable and ultra expensive to fix.
Possibly. It would be like saying your gas cap is going to wear out from over use.
The batteries removed would just be recharged and reused, more than likely without any qualtiy control of any kind, making it even
more dangerous for the consumer, as they wouldn't know if they recieved a damaged battery or not until it is too late.
This would be an issue I guess. My limited exposure to EVs involved knowing how much juice was left at all times. It would seem like the driver would know pretty quick if there was a short charge on the battery.
The auto companies are just looking for ways to fuck people over even more than they do right now.
There is NOTHING wrong with creating a battery system in any EV where it recharges itself while driving!!!
And NOBODY has every answered my question.......WHAT the hell happened to the ORIGINAL Tesla's, where they had solar roofs to recharge the battery while parked?
And off the deep end he goes!
 

Forum List

Back
Top