If it was this 17-year-old instead of Kyle, would he have got off Scott free?

[BackAgain]

Say this 17-year-old went to the demonstration.

He walks into a crowd of militia members.

One of the militia members makes a threatening move so our 17-year-old shoots him dead. Another militia member raises his rifle, so our 17-year-old shoots him dead. Still a third militia member points a handgun at our 17-year-old but doesn't pull the trigger so our 17-year-old shoots him in the arm.

Our 17-year-old then surrenders to the police.

At the hearing, he cries on the stand.

Would he have got off Scott free?

All analogies limp. Yours is crippled. In fact, it was still born.