Greatest Non-Pitching Basebll Player in MLB History?

[Harry Dresden]

Ted Williams.

Set all the records that he did, while setting aside a significant portion of his playing career aside to serve his country.

There's no telling what he could have done, had those productive years been spent on the field.

Oh, and Ted also wasn't a 'roid shooting cheater.

aint that the truth....Joe DiMaggio and Hank Greenberg did the same... missed 3 years...

 

[Devils_Advocate]

Ricky Henderson was the Greatest in my opinion…

Look over his Stats and realize he didn’t hit a lot of dingers but the man was a run producing machine that could swipe a base and change the game with his speed…

Ty Cobb is also one of the greatest with Rod Carew and Pete Rose…

Now many of you will scream no but Henderson holds records that will never be broken…

 

[Mashmont]

View attachment 610419
View attachment 610418

Clemente may well be the greatest player in history. He played in cavernous Forbes Field most of his career or he would have had many more than 240 homers.

 

[Mashmont]

There is no place for your childish delusions in this thread, cultist.

Who are you?

 

[Jimmy_Chitwood]

Clemente may well be the greatest player in history. He played in cavernous Forbes Field most of his career or he would have had many more than 240 homers.