Criminal Prosecution for a Teacher Bringing an Inappropriate Book into the Classroom?

Seymour Flops

Diamond Member
Nov 25, 2021
13,537
10,852
2,138
Texas
Well, not so far.


BLAIR COUNTY, Pa (WTAJ) – In early November, outrage circulated on social media over the book ‘Gender Queer’ appearing in a classroom in the Hollidaysburg Junior High.

The book itself was brought into school by a teacher and when school officials found out about the situation, they informed parents that the teacher was told to never bring the book back.

Hollidaysburg Police conducted multiple individual interviews of both students and school district personnel. At the current point of the investigation, none of the witnesses interviewed by law enforcement have disclosed first-hand observations that would rise to criminal conduct under Pennsylvania law, according to a statement from District Attorney’s Office.

In addition to the Blair County District Attorney’s Office releasing their findings in the investigation. Below is an updated statement to parents from the Hollidaysburg Superintendent Robert Gildea.


Dear Junior High Parents,
The intent of this message is to update you on the status of Ms. Nicole Stouffer. Ms. Stouffer will be returning to the classroom effective January 3, 2023. No further comment will be made regarding any corrective action that may or may not have been taken against the teacher as it is an internal personnel matter.
A press release will soon be issued by the Blair County District Attorney regarding the external investigation.

‘Gender Queer’ has been the center of controversy the past few years as schools began to ban it from being used in curriculums or put on library shelves. The book is a 2019 graphic memoir written and illustrated by Maia Kobabe.

That book is indeed "graphic" in two senses. It is basically a bound comic book like schools have turned to in order to get students to read, and it is very graphic in describing and depicting sex among children, including a top down view of a gender confused early teenager performing oral sex on a male.

Still, I think that the prosecutors made the only decision they could have made. The teacher brought in a book that is widely known to be included in may school libraries so proving criminal intent would be impossible.
 
That book is indeed "graphic" in two senses. It is basically a bound comic book like schools have turned to in order to get students to read, and it is very graphic in describing and depicting sex among children, including a top down view of a gender confused early teenager performing oral sex on a male.

Still, I think that the prosecutors made the only decision they could have made. The teacher brought in a book that is widely known to be included in may school libraries so proving criminal intent would be impossible.

By any rational definition, that clearly constitutes child pornography.

Merely having it in one's possession would be a valid basis for criminal charges, much less bringing it to a school where it might be seen by minors.

That others are known to be getting away with a particular crime is no defense for on who is caught and prosecuted for that crime.
 
719.jpeg
 

Forum List

Back
Top