When did vigilantism become a bad thing? The history of community defense against crime was pure vigilantism. Only when cities began to create official police departments in the early-mid 1800s did that change. Before that, volutary citizens, watchmen, guarded the cities and called out the people, you remember the people, don't you? They were, at the time, often called the militia when called to defend their cities.
In fact the word vigilante meant watchman.
VIGILANTE Meaning: "member of a vigilance committee," 1856, American English, from Spanish vigilante, literally "watchman,"… See definitions of vigilante.
www.etymonline.com
Somehow we've forgotten liberty and have grown to love the police state.
The police have no obligation to defend us and we have no right to expect them to defend us. What the police do very well, though, is to defend those who place themselves above us.
Vigilantism is actually the natural form of defense of a community against violence and crime. The role of the police is to take those who survive their crime to jail and hold them for, and deliver them to, trial.
That is all the police do to day, as well. Jump a turnstile in the NYC subway? The police are there; you've robbed the city. Rob or rape a woman in the subway? No cop to be found. Later, they take the report.
A bodega worker gets robbed, not a cop to be found. Defend yourself and suddenly the cops are there to arrest you.
This isn't an attack on the police indiviually; it's simply an acknowledgment of the law and of reality. The law is very clear that the police are not there to protect you. When one happens to see a crime and stops it, that's great but it is neither the norm nor the expectation. The norm is that the police come later and do the paperwork.
The preference would be vigilantes stopping the crime and holding the criminal for the police. In these clips from Brazil, the criminals are armed. You don't negotiate or demand surrender of an armed bad guy. You stop them with overwhelming force.
These video clips demonstrate exactly how a crime should end in every city in the world, especially in the US.