Women and the draft

[Quantum Windbag]

Are they going to have to register for Selective Service before they can apply for student loans or other government benefits? If not, why not?

 

[AmyNation]

Not yet, but they should.

 

[del]

they'll have to rewrite the law as it now refers to "male persons"

 

[bodecea]

Don't see why not...and if they don't, some guy will sue (and should) to make it equal.

 

[Quantum Windbag]

they'll have to rewrite the law as it now refers to "male persons"

Wouldn't that make the law discriminatory and a violation of the Constitution?

 

[del]

they'll have to rewrite the law as it now refers to "male persons"

Wouldn't that make the law discriminatory and a violation of the Constitution?

it would now; it didn't when women were restricted from combat, as the court held that the purpose of the draft was to supply combat troops.

rostker v. goldberg

 

[waltky]

Uncle Ferd says if dey can jump tree trunks den dey oughta be drafted...

Congress Shelves Plans to Have Women Register for Draft
29 Jun 2017 | Proposals to have women register for the draft have been dropped from Senate and House committee defense budget markups.

The Senate Armed Services Committee's markup of the defense budget Thursday left out proposals to have women register for the draft. The move essentially tabled the controversial issue following similar action Monday in the House Armed Services Committee's markup of the National Defense Authorization Act for fiscal 2018. Proposals by Rep. Jackie Speier, D-Calif., and others to have women register for Selective Service were dropped from that bill.

Speier unsuccessfully argued for an amendment to the NDAA that would have required women to register for the draft. "It's time to stop delaying the inevitable with parliamentary gymnastics," she said. "If it does come to a draft, men and women should be treated equally." Her amendment failed by a vote of 33-28 in the committee. Committee Chairman Rep. Mac Thornberry, R-Texas, opposed Speier's amendment, saying it was getting ahead of an ongoing review of the Selective Service System.

U.S. Army Soldiers negotiate obstacles during the Cultural Support Assessment and Selection program.​

Last year, committee members approved a similar measure requiring women to register for the draft, but Republican leaders stripped the language on the House floor. The Senate last year also backed the draft for women but dropped the issue in budget negotiations with the House. Women have always been exempt from the law requiring all men ages 18 to 26 to register for possible military service with the Selective Service System.

The main argument against women registering for the draft had been that they were excluded from serving in combat jobs. However, the Defense Department has since lifted combat restrictions. At a May 22 Brookings Institution forum, Thornberry was asked to state his position on women and the draft. He responded, "We have appointed a commission to look at this. We'll see what they have to say," but he gave no timeline for the study to be completed and no indication whether Congress would be prepared to act when the commission files a report.

Congress Shelves Plans to Have Women Register for Draft | Military.com