Who are the Israelis?

[Challenger]

There is no such thing as "Israelis." We need to define the terms. According to history the 12 tribes of Israel never even fucking existed, ever. According to Yahweh based mythology the 12 tribes of Israel started around 980 BCE with the 10 tribes of Israel being assimilated into Syria circa 700 BCE. Folks that means Israel ceased to exist in the mythology and in real life they probably never existed. That leaves us with the 2 remaining tribes Judah and Benjamin, the "jews." At some point some inbred douchebags decided they were Judah and Benjamin and obviously most countries did not like underground, criminal enterprises back then. As a result of inbreeding, they look a certain way and have certain diseases those of us a result natural selection do not have thank God.

Like it or not, there is such a thing as "Israelis", as of 1948.

 

[P F Tinmore]

 

[Shusha]

There is no cultural link between modern European Jewish people and Palestine.

You have a very odd idea of "culture" then.

What makes a French person ethnically French? How can you distinguish someone of French ethnicity from someone of Spanish ethnicity? How do you distinguish between Spanish and Catalan culture? What makes Palestinians a distinct culture?

 

[montelatici]

Jews of Europe were/are culturally European. An Italian Jew is an Italian that practices Judaism. I don't understand what is so difficult to understand. Would you claim that an American that practices Judaism is culturally Israeli? Sheesh.

 

[theliq]

Such apaulling ......Ignorance with some Jews..."one person said the Palestinians were from Algeria and Morocco!!!!!!!I thought a Jew would that know that it was the Jews that came to Israel from these two countries because the Palestinian certainly didn't" Amazing Ignorance with some,and shows how the indoctorination since 1948 has worked...on some Jewish Israelis even though it's a lie.

Excellent Post Tinnie,...steve

 

[Phoenall]

Individuals opinions and not a government policy. You need to research your material a lot more

 

[Phoenall]

Jews of Europe were/are culturally European. An Italian Jew is an Italian that practices Judaism. I don't understand what is so difficult to understand. Would you claim that an American that practices Judaism is culturally Israeli? Sheesh.

Not according to your Nazi friends who stated that they were not European at all. Seems the new Nazis want to change the history all over again.

 

[Phoenall]

Such apaulling ......Ignorance with some Jews..."one person said the Palestinians were from Algeria and Morocco!!!!!!!I thought a Jew would that know that it was the Jews that came to Israel from these two countries because the Palestinian certainly didn't" Amazing Ignorance with some,and shows how the indoctorination since 1948 has worked...on some Jewish Israelis even though it's a lie.

Excellent Post Tinnie,...steve

Seems that you are ignorant of the facts again

 

[LaDexter]

Israelis = The worst terrorists on planet Earth

 

[Phoenall]

Israelis = The worst terrorists on planet Earth

Another Nazi who hates the Jews.

Which organisation with the authority to do so has declared Israel to be a terrorist state.

 

[Shusha]

Israelis = The worst terrorists on planet Earth

Another Nazi who hates the Jews.

Which organisation with the authority to do so has declared Israel to be a terrorist state.

Another who has no objective criteria for words they use so they can demonize Jews.

 

[Shusha]

Jews of Europe were/are culturally European. An Italian Jew is an Italian that practices Judaism. I don't understand what is so difficult to understand. Would you claim that an American that practices Judaism is culturally Israeli? Sheesh.

But what makes someone "culturally Italian"? What qualities do they possess which distinguish Italian culture from Swiss culture from Irish culture?

You are unwilling to provide the criteria you use for defining "culture", knowing, of course, that you cannot do so without exposing your unfair and unequal treatment of the Jewish people.

 

[montelatici]

If you need to have culture defined for you, it really makes no sense to discuss it.

If you haven't been taught that a common language, literature, music, painting, sculpture, mannerisms, negotiation techniques, work habits, cuisine and other aspects of a people make up its culture, you need to go back and do a little study. Italians of the Jewish, Catholic, Protestant, Hindu and now the 2nd and third generations of even the Muslims faiths share the Italian culture. Modigliani was an Italian artist of the Jewish faith just as his contemporary, Gino Romiti, was an Italian painter of the Catholic faith.

Do you think Italian Jews eat that crap that Eastern European Jews eat? Italian Jews cook and eat Italian food, like all Italians. They speak Italian, read (and write) Italian Literature, speak with their hands like all Italians, took a 3 hour break in mid day during the work day (although Italians are losing that luxury).

It's no different with American Jews. They are culturally Americans.

 

[Shusha]

...a common language, literature, music, painting, sculpture, mannerisms, negotiation techniques, work habits, cuisine and other aspects of a people make up its culture

Thank you. So denying that there is such a thing as a Jewish culture is really rather foolish of you since the Jewish people have all of the markers of culture that you have so thoughtfully just provided, as well as others which you missed.

 

[Phoenall]

...a common language, literature, music, painting, sculpture, mannerisms, negotiation techniques, work habits, cuisine and other aspects of a people make up its culture

Thank you. So denying that there is such a thing as a Jewish culture is really rather foolish of you since the Jewish people have all of the markers of culture that you have so thoughtfully just provided, as well as others which you missed.

The question to ask him is his culture that of Italian Catholic or of American first nations

 

[P F Tinmore]

 

[Hollie]

A typical mission to promote hate and derision.

 

[P F Tinmore]

Forbidden israeli history- Israeli docco maker Lia Tarachansky

 

[P F Tinmore]

Interview with Jeff Halper from Jerusalem on Israel-Palestine tensions

 

[Phoenall]

Forbidden israeli history- Israeli docco maker Lia Tarachansky

And once again all you have is islamonaxi propagands from a Palestinian source. Just your usual pack of lies and libels that you believe to be the truth