R
rdean
Guest
- Thread starter
- #21
You said: However, I think your thread would be more effective if you remove "GOP" and make it open to all 50 Governors. Plus, exactly how do we want to measure this? Lots of mitigating factors, here.Pretty good OP, rdean . However, I think your thread would be more effective if you remove "GOP" and make it open to all 50 Governors. Plus, exactly how do we want to measure this? Lots of mitigating factors, here. And for every factoid we bring, someone somewhere will scream that it is wrong. Considering the terrible mess that Kansas is in, Brownback should go on that list as well. But I am quite sure we will find a "blue" state or two that is not doing well, either.
Actually, I am getting very tired of the designations of "blue" and "red". The larger swath nation is more purple than either side really wants to admit.
Let's get members of all persuasions to help make a list of criteria first and then turn this into a serious thread about accomplishments and failures. And yes, Education should be at the top of the pile. I give it a 6% chance that this will happen.
I suspect there are fewer mitigating factors than can be admitted. It's the big issues and the majorities that determine the directions of the parties regardless of the outliers.
It reminds me of the way liberals see the majority of Muslims. I have a thread brewing for that.
Anyway, it seems to me that you want to kind of celebrate the similarities between Democrats and Republicans and minimize the differences. Only you can't. Simply by the fact of their membership. A perfect example is the fact Eric Cantor, the only GOP Jew in either house was replaced with "David Dukes without the baggage" and the GOP is 90% white and 100% Christian in congress.
While some GOP point to the fact the Democrats are over 60% white, look at who those whites are. Gays, atheists, scientists, college professors, liberals, feminists and others not welcome in the GOP. Then you have all the minorities in the Democratic Party, even conservatives making it a true coalition party. A very, very far cry from the GOP. Not something you can deny.
So, with such a GOP base of the same, crazy has hijacked the party. Ask Republicans individually if they believe in "let him die" and "feed the poor and they will breed" and they will say of course not. I suspect (only suspect) most will say education is a good thing. That vaccines work. That scientists are hard working people. The problem is, that's not what the party believes. The GOP base follows the party leadership and not the other way around.
The GOP hilarity isn't confined to the USMB. If you want, read the comments under Rick Perry's job poaching videos on Youtube. Comments like education is for liberals and is over rated. You don't need liberal indoctrination to learn to do a job. Yea, as long as that job is sweeping or mopping. .
None of what Republicans say can hide the fact GOP policies are terrible disasters. 8 years under George Bush caused enormous damage to the country and to the world. The problem is that he followed orthodox GOP policy to the tee. Deregulated the economy. Tax cuts for the wealthy. Bomb our enemies. Bring Democracy to the rest of the world. And Republicans, instead of reviewing the positive effects of their policies (which I admit I couldn't find), decided to run away with excuses. Bush wasn't a real Republican. Iraq was ungrateful and so on. Ask USMB Republicans what they used reconciliation on three times and they won't respond. Remember how outraged they were when Democrats used it once?
And it's the same with the states. 150 years of conservative policies in Red States and they tend to make money in two ways. Grow something out of the ground or dig up something out of the ground. And their hatred of Obama, of minorities, of education, of science and so on is over the top. Their foreign policy would lead us into even more disaster.
Can you name a single GOP policy that would help the US. And explain how. You can't.
And they cherry pick their awful policies and point with glee - see? they work!
Only they don't. How can you see minimum wage jobs without benefits or a future as "success"? No wonder the government needs to give food stamps and health care to minimum wage workers. And what does the GOP say? Get a better job. What job are they talking about?
Sure, you can have a few Democrats who do as crappy a job as Republicans. Because there are conservatives in the Democratic Party. But the GOP does crappy everywhere.