# What is the highest form of proof?

Discussion in 'Religion and Ethics' started by proletarian, Jan 9, 2010.

?

## What is the Highrs Form of Proof?

0 vote(s)
0.0%

0 vote(s)
0.0%

2 vote(s)
50.0%

2 vote(s)
50.0%
1. Online

### &#9773;proletarian&#9773;Guest

Ratings:
+0
In your opinion, what is the highest form of proof in logical inquiry?

Is it

Mathematics, assuming the validity of the axioms

Logical implication/extrapolation, assuming the validity of the starting point

Observation, assuming the validity of the observation and interpretation thereof

Or something else?

(this was supposed to be a public poll, but that didn't work)

Last edited by a moderator: Jan 9, 2010
2. Offline

### amrchaosPentheus torn apart

Joined:
Nov 1, 2008
Messages:
9,500
Thanks Received:
926
Trophy Points:
215
Location:
Miami
Ratings:
+2,580
Actually

a priori logic--mathematics is just a sub-branch of logic that deals largely with quantities and comparisons.

3. Offline

### Baruch Menachem'

Joined:
Sep 12, 2008
Messages:
14,203
Thanks Received:
3,235
Trophy Points:
185
Ratings:
+3,309
A combination of the above.

Appeals to authority are not a valid proof at all. Just because Newton said Apples fall from trees does not in fact mean that they do. Demonstration of the attraction between apples and the great green earth is what proves that apples fall out of trees.

4. Offline

### dilloduckDiamond Member

Joined:
May 8, 2004
Messages:
53,240
Thanks Received:
5,552
Trophy Points:
1,850
Location:
Austin, TX
Ratings:
+6,411
getting someone else to believe you and act on it.

5. Online

### &#9773;proletarian&#9773;Guest

Ratings:
+0
Or that the apple stays put while the Earth moves, and the tree with it.

6. Offline

### Avatar4321Diamond MemberGold Supporting Member

Joined:
Feb 22, 2004
Messages:
78,024
Thanks Received:
9,366
Trophy Points:
2,070
Location:
Minnesota
Ratings:
+18,828
As all science and faith is based on personal observation, i would say the highest form is what we can learn through our senses.

7. Offline

### uscitizenSenior Member

Joined:
May 6, 2007
Messages:
45,940
Thanks Received:
4,789
Trophy Points:
48
Location:
My Shack
Ratings:
+4,817
The highest for of Proof? I saw it on Fox.

8. Online

### &#9773;proletarian&#9773;Guest

Ratings:
+0
How do we know our senses tell us anything at all? A walk through the crazyhouse tells us that personal experience tells us nothing.

9. Offline

### Avatar4321Diamond MemberGold Supporting Member

Joined:
Feb 22, 2004
Messages:
78,024
Thanks Received:
9,366
Trophy Points:
2,070
Location:
Minnesota
Ratings:
+18,828
How can we know anything else? how can we use reason and expect any sort of accuracy in our reasoning if we dont have data we've experienced to make those rational conclusions?

Reason is only as good as the data you have to put into it. Problem is people become obsessed with reason and dont reality there are other ways to learn things. Experience is far superior in my mind.

10. Online

### &#9773;proletarian&#9773;Guest

Ratings:
+0
You claimed experience is superior to reason, but is not the interpretation of expericnce itself an attempt at reason?

Title
Replies Views
Last Message

Replies:
2
Views:
14

Replies:
11
Views:
135

Replies:
41
Views:
601

Replies:
258
Views:
2,192

Replies:
6
Views:
148