What if Israel Quite Trying to Play the Nice Guy

Its a very very simply concept.

Cause and effect

If the pali's really can't contain their violence and racism to the point where they strap bombs on 14 year olds, then there is a need for restrictions.

If the pali's get out of hand, its inevitable that the Israeli's stop playing nice guy with just restrictions.

The result

403046-01-08.jpg


This is what Gaza will look like for a long long time to come.
 
The suggestion has been made that a humanitarian removal of the Arab Muslim population is in order given the failure of the peace process.

I'd say its a bit drastic to remove ALL the Arab Muslims, just segregate the offending portion of the population exactly as specified in the Geneva conventions
 
Wrong

I'm exactly on target.

The Israeli's have a right to defend themselves

See
United Nations Charter
article 51

There is a condition of war as declared by the Arab League

see
Arab League declaration on the invasion of Palestine- 15 May 1948

Also see
Article 2 III Geneva Convention

The Israeli's have the right to detain prisoners of war

See
III Geneva Convention articles 3,4,5,6,10,23,28,33,60,65,66,67,72,73,75,109,110,118,119,122,132

Israeli has an obligation to segregate POWs from civilians and refugees.

See
Common article 3 of the geneva Conventions
Article 75 first protocol of the Geneva Conventions

Israel may repatriate POWs to neutral third parties.

See
Article 12 III Geneva Convention

Sorry but If you have any specific complaints about any of my suggestions that can be seen within the provisions on the conduct of war feel free. But so far you've offered not a shred of supporting arguments within law.
There is a condition of war as declared by the Arab League

see
Arab League declaration on the invasion of Palestine- 15 May 1948​

Was Palestine a member of the Arab League?

The Arab League invaded Palestine. They did not attack Israel.

Palestine was already under attack by foreign forces before the 1948 war and that attack continues. There were already over 300,000 Palestinian refugees before the 1948 war.






Irrelevant as members of the arab league became Palestinians. And they did become members when the all Palestinian government ( Egypt and the arab league ) tried to declare independence on land already independent.

The arab league attacked the Jews in 1947, and then invaded the lands of Palestine illegally in May 1948. The words of the arab league leaders show that they were intent on the destruction of Israel and the genocide of the Jews.

Then why didn't the UN make them refugees and set in place standard refugee policies, not set yo the UNWRA because the arab muslims did not have the two years residency required to be refugees. If the arab muslims had not left under their own free will they would not have been refugees, and the numbers you give happen to be the total population numbers for 1948 for the whole of Palestine. So how could arab muslims living in gaza and the west bank be refugees when they were on their home lands ?
And they did become members when the all Palestinian government ( Egypt and the arab league ) tried to declare independence on land already independent.


Another big Israeli lie.

You have no proof of that.





The proof is in the records that you yourself have posted. The arab league foreign influence put forward a counter claim that was denied because it was on land already claimed in the May of that year. The majority of the Palestinians did not even know about the counter claim.


Want to prove this wrong ?
 
Wrong

I'm exactly on target.

The Israeli's have a right to defend themselves

See
United Nations Charter
article 51

There is a condition of war as declared by the Arab League

see
Arab League declaration on the invasion of Palestine- 15 May 1948

Also see
Article 2 III Geneva Convention

The Israeli's have the right to detain prisoners of war

See
III Geneva Convention articles 3,4,5,6,10,23,28,33,60,65,66,67,72,73,75,109,110,118,119,122,132

Israeli has an obligation to segregate POWs from civilians and refugees.

See
Common article 3 of the geneva Conventions
Article 75 first protocol of the Geneva Conventions

Israel may repatriate POWs to neutral third parties.

See
Article 12 III Geneva Convention

Sorry but If you have any specific complaints about any of my suggestions that can be seen within the provisions on the conduct of war feel free. But so far you've offered not a shred of supporting arguments within law.
There is a condition of war as declared by the Arab League

see
Arab League declaration on the invasion of Palestine- 15 May 1948​

Was Palestine a member of the Arab League?

The Arab League invaded Palestine. They did not attack Israel.

Palestine was already under attack by foreign forces before the 1948 war and that attack continues. There were already over 300,000 Palestinian refugees before the 1948 war.






Irrelevant as members of the arab league became Palestinians. And they did become members when the all Palestinian government ( Egypt and the arab league ) tried to declare independence on land already independent.

The arab league attacked the Jews in 1947, and then invaded the lands of Palestine illegally in May 1948. The words of the arab league leaders show that they were intent on the destruction of Israel and the genocide of the Jews.

Then why didn't the UN make them refugees and set in place standard refugee policies, not set yo the UNWRA because the arab muslims did not have the two years residency required to be refugees. If the arab muslims had not left under their own free will they would not have been refugees, and the numbers you give happen to be the total population numbers for 1948 for the whole of Palestine. So how could arab muslims living in gaza and the west bank be refugees when they were on their home lands ?
And they did become members when the all Palestinian government ( Egypt and the arab league ) tried to declare independence on land already independent.


Another big Israeli lie.

You have no proof of that.





The proof is in the records that you yourself have posted. The arab league foreign influence put forward a counter claim that was denied because it was on land already claimed in the May of that year. The majority of the Palestinians did not even know about the counter claim.


Want to prove this wrong ?
Well, I can't prove a negative so how about you posting something about Israel's defined territory in 1948. Then we can see where it conflicts with Palestine's declaration.
 
Not a problem. Israel had the entirety of the area west of the Jordan according to the Jordan memorandum. ;--) IE Mandate.
 
Mandate for Palestine
Jordan memorandum

Do your own homework

Israel should stop playing nice guy here and enact the provisions within the Geneva Convention. Segregate combatants from non combatants and repatriate all POWs to their countries of origin.

Boom problem solved
 

New Topics

Forum List

Back
Top