We need to stop pretending that this issue is so difficult. It is obvious even to a young child.

[Hollie]

ILLEGAL IMMIGRATION
jewish scum invade Palestine

I can see you're angry and frustrated. Don't let your failure to support the silly "invasion" claim consume you. Just drink large quantities of alcohol. It will cure what ails you.

despite what your rabbi tells you masturbation is not a sin if you can't find a partner willing to put up with your shite

That's a shame about your failed attempt at supporting your silly "invasion" argument. Just resort to hurling insults... you angry Habib.

 

[rylah]

The issue is not difficult at all, IF YOU READ WHAT THEY SAY IN ARABIC.

Up until today, the vast majority of the Palestinian society is divided between 2 groups:
Southern (Yemeni) tribes and Northern Arabian tribes.

But of course in English all You hear is "we've been here since before the cave man"

Book of Soba - History of the homeland and life of the village (Ibrahim Awadallah Faqih)

 

[montelatici]

There are myths, then there are historical facts. The Palestinian "Arabs" are no more "Arabian" than modern day Egyptians.

 

[Roudy]

Exactly, the Palestinian Arabs are the same as the Egyptian Arabs, Jordanian Arabs, and the Syrian Arabs. In fact they are them. Palestinian is a new concept and fraud. Yet another instance of Monte putting his hoof in his mouth.

 

[Shusha]

There are myths, then there are historical facts. The Palestinian "Arabs" are no more "Arabian" than modern day Egyptians.

The "Palestinians" self-identify with Syrians and Jordanians at the least and with the greater Arab Muslim Nation at the greatest. Who are we to argue with their self-identification?

 

[P F Tinmore]

Exactly, the Palestinian Arabs are the same as the Egyptian Arabs, Jordanian Arabs, and the Syrian Arabs. In fact they are them. Palestinian is a new concept and fraud. Yet another instance of Monte putting his hoof in his mouth.

Not to mention that before WWI they were all the same place. Going from Amman to Jaffa was no different than going from Albany to Buffalo.

 

[rylah]

Exactly, the Palestinian Arabs are the same as the Egyptian Arabs, Jordanian Arabs, and the Syrian Arabs. In fact they are them. Palestinian is a new concept and fraud. Yet another instance of Monte putting his hoof in his mouth.

Not to mention that before WWI they were all the same place. Going from Amman to Jaffa was no different than going from Albany to Buffalo.

But You don't also mention that going from Greece, or Italy or Yemen and Hidjaz was as much available.
And there's clear evidence in the Palestinian sources about settlements of Morrocans, Egyptians, Bosnians and Arabian tribes.

It's much more than just "a myth".
Jews remained as Indians remained - a minority in their ancestral lands, and even today according to You guys.

 

[Roudy]

Exactly, the Palestinian Arabs are the same as the Egyptian Arabs, Jordanian Arabs, and the Syrian Arabs. In fact they are them. Palestinian is a new concept and fraud. Yet another instance of Monte putting his hoof in his mouth.

Not to mention that before WWI they were all the same place. Going from Amman to Jaffa was no different than going from Albany to Buffalo.

Yeah, it was all Ottoman territory and no Arab called themselves "Palestinian", nor was the land ruled or controled by Arabs. Ain't that a hoot! Then the Ottomans joined with the Germans in WWI, and lost all of it. And then once the state of Israel was restablished, out of nowhere the Arabs decided to call themselves "Palestinian", a name that only applied to the Jews of the region. In fact, if you called an Arab a Palestinian during the Ottoman Empire, he'd slap you in the face for insulting him by called him a Jew!

 

[montelatici]

Exactly, the Palestinian Arabs are the same as the Egyptian Arabs, Jordanian Arabs, and the Syrian Arabs. In fact they are them. Palestinian is a new concept and fraud. Yet another instance of Monte putting his hoof in his mouth.

Not to mention that before WWI they were all the same place. Going from Amman to Jaffa was no different than going from Albany to Buffalo.

Yeah, it was all Ottoman territory and no Arab called themselves "Palestinian", nor was the land ruled or controled by Arabs. Ain't that a hoot! Then the Ottomans joined with the Germans in WWI, and lost all of it. And then once the state of Israel was restablished, out of nowhere the Arabs decided to call themselves "Palestinian", a name that only applied to the Jews of the region. In fact, if you called an Arab a Palestinian during the Ottoman Empire, he'd slap you in the face for insulting him by called him a Jew!

Printed during Ottoman rule.

 

[Roudy]

Exactly, the Palestinian Arabs are the same as the Egyptian Arabs, Jordanian Arabs, and the Syrian Arabs. In fact they are them. Palestinian is a new concept and fraud. Yet another instance of Monte putting his hoof in his mouth.

Not to mention that before WWI they were all the same place. Going from Amman to Jaffa was no different than going from Albany to Buffalo.

Yeah, it was all Ottoman territory and no Arab called themselves "Palestinian", nor was the land ruled or controled by Arabs. Ain't that a hoot! Then the Ottomans joined with the Germans in WWI, and lost all of it. And then once the state of Israel was restablished, out of nowhere the Arabs decided to call themselves "Palestinian", a name that only applied to the Jews of the region. In fact, if you called an Arab a Palestinian during the Ottoman Empire, he'd slap you in the face for insulting him by called him a Jew!

Printed during Ottoman rule.


View attachment 148099

Printed 1906 in English! Ha ha ha. OMG

 

[montelatici]

Exactly, the Palestinian Arabs are the same as the Egyptian Arabs, Jordanian Arabs, and the Syrian Arabs. In fact they are them. Palestinian is a new concept and fraud. Yet another instance of Monte putting his hoof in his mouth.

Not to mention that before WWI they were all the same place. Going from Amman to Jaffa was no different than going from Albany to Buffalo.

Yeah, it was all Ottoman territory and no Arab called themselves "Palestinian", nor was the land ruled or controled by Arabs. Ain't that a hoot! Then the Ottomans joined with the Germans in WWI, and lost all of it. And then once the state of Israel was restablished, out of nowhere the Arabs decided to call themselves "Palestinian", a name that only applied to the Jews of the region. In fact, if you called an Arab a Palestinian during the Ottoman Empire, he'd slap you in the face for insulting him by called him a Jew!

Printed during Ottoman rule.


View attachment 148099

Printed 1906 in English! Ha ha ha. OMG

Well wouldn't a language manual for English speakers to learn Palestinian Arabic, printed during Ottoman rule be in the English language? The fact is, your whole bullshit line that Palestinians do not exist is trashed with one small language manual.

 

[Shusha]

The fact is, your whole bullshit line that Palestinians do not exist is trashed with one small language manual.

You are SUCH a hypocrite. If all it takes to create a national culture is a "small language manual" (which differentiates Palestine Arabic from Syrian or Jordanian Arabic) then the Jewish people clearly and obviously meet that criteria with the Hebrew language and therefore exist as a national culture. And yet you keep arguing that they do not. Such a hypocrite.

 

[Roudy]

Exactly, the Palestinian Arabs are the same as the Egyptian Arabs, Jordanian Arabs, and the Syrian Arabs. In fact they are them. Palestinian is a new concept and fraud. Yet another instance of Monte putting his hoof in his mouth.

Not to mention that before WWI they were all the same place. Going from Amman to Jaffa was no different than going from Albany to Buffalo.

Yeah, it was all Ottoman territory and no Arab called themselves "Palestinian", nor was the land ruled or controled by Arabs. Ain't that a hoot! Then the Ottomans joined with the Germans in WWI, and lost all of it. And then once the state of Israel was restablished, out of nowhere the Arabs decided to call themselves "Palestinian", a name that only applied to the Jews of the region. In fact, if you called an Arab a Palestinian during the Ottoman Empire, he'd slap you in the face for insulting him by called him a Jew!

Printed during Ottoman rule.


View attachment 148099

Printed 1906 in English! Ha ha ha. OMG

Well wouldn't a language manual for English speakers to learn Palestinian Arabic, printed during Ottoman rule be in the English language? The fact is, your whole bullshit line that Palestinians do not exist is trashed with one small language manual.

Because "Palestine" is the European name for an area the Ottomans called Southern Syria for 700 years. Doy!

Afternoon Map: Ottoman and Arab Maps of Palestine, 1880s-1910s

Our next map, like the rest in Jughrafiya-i Osmani (see 90, 101, 104, and 116), make no mention of Palestine anywhere. This was not uncommon for the period, as Palestine did not constitute an administrative district in the Ottoman Empire. Instead, the entire region is labeled ‘Suriye’ in all of these maps.

he final map in our collection comes from George Post’s Nabat Suriya wa-Filastin wa-al-Qatr al-Misri wa-Bawadiha (Beirut, n.p., 1884), 411 (The Flora of Syria, Palestine, and the Egyptian Country and its Desert). The title of the map itself is: The Botanical Climate of Syria (Aqalim Suriyya al-Nabatiyya). Note that Filastin does not appear anywhere on the map. Again, insofar as this is a translation of a book by one of most well-regarded botanists and geographers of Palestine in the nineteenth century, we once again see just how much the Arabs, in this case, came under the influence of their European counterparts. Indeed, this is one of the first books ever published in the Arab language which included the word ‘Filastin’ in the title of the work, and, low and behold, it is a translation from the English!

 

[Roudy]

The fact is, your whole bullshit line that Palestinians do not exist is trashed with one small language manual.

You are SUCH a hypocrite. If all it takes to create a national culture is a "small language manual" (which differentiates Palestine Arabic from Syrian or Jordanian Arabic) then the Jewish people clearly and obviously meet that criteria with the Hebrew language and therefore exist as a national culture. And yet you keep arguing that they do not. Such a hypocrite.

So Palestinians were "English speakers"?! Or perhaps, "Palestinian" is a European name for European English speakers?! I'll go with option no. 2. LOL.

 

[P F Tinmore]

This is not a difficult issue. The solution has been around for over 50 years.

The United Nations and Decolonization - Declaration

 

[Slyhunter]

This is not a difficult issue. The solution has been around for over 50 years.

The United Nations and Decolonization - Declaration

3000 years in fact. God gave that land to the Israelites. Period.

 

[Shusha]

This is not a difficult issue. The solution has been around for over 50 years.

The United Nations and Decolonization - Declaration

EXACTLY. It is not a difficult issue. Let's decolonize Israel and restore her to the Jewish people.

Oh wait, that isn't what you meant is it?

 

[Roudy]

This is not a difficult issue. The solution has been around for over 50 years.

The United Nations and Decolonization - Declaration

Oh great, now the Arabs are going to give back all the lands they invaded, looted, colonized, and then shoved their religion, language and culture down the throats of the people!