US 'hushed up' Soviet guilt over Katyn

[ginscpy]

New evidence appears to back the idea that the Roosevelt administration helped cover up Soviet guilt for the 1940 Katyn massacre of Polish soldiers.

Historians said documents, released by the US National Archives, supported the suspicion that the US did not want to anger its wartime ally, Joseph Stalin.

They showed the US was sent coded messages suggesting the Soviets, not the Nazis, carried out the massacre.

More than 22,000 Poles were killed by the Soviets on Stalin's orders.

Soviet Russia only admitted to the atrocity in 1990 after blaming the Nazis for five decades.

BBC News - US 'hushed up' Soviet guilt over Katyn

When was the last time you heard about somebody "blaming the Nazis" for something?

But in the case of the Katyn Massecre - they were innocent of the crime.

 

[mememe]

mememe, consider this: your argument is full of crap, the Soviets did it, and let's move on.

It's not "my" argument.

Polish Red Cross as well as US comission that visited Katyn came to the same conclusion: Germans did it.

If you support Dr Goebbels's claim (which is not surprising), then explain away this:

1. German manufactured cord;
2. Mountains of personalised artefacts in the grave;
3. Some of those identified as "Katyn dead" found alive in Poland;
4. Refusal of Poland to support its claim with documents.

You need professional help.

To set the record straight:
- The Polish Red Cross that exhumed the bodies in 1943 found the Soviets were guilty for the mass execution, NOT the Germans Polish Report Blames Russians for Katyn Massacre - NYTimes.com
- The Congressional Madden Commission in 1952 came to the same conclusion - the Soviets did it www.kresy-siberia.com/1952_Katyn_report_to_Congress.pdf

Records show that the governments of FDR and Churchill knew that the Soviets were guilty and the Russians have more recently admitted to their guilt and provided supporting documentation to that effect.

If you weren't such a tragic mess, you would be laughable. Seriously - get help.

No, darling, it's not me who needs "help". Your bollox from NYTimes (dated 1989) was written for those who don't know that Polish Red Cross report was the basis for Nuremberg decision on Katyn.

And the words your article attribute to "Polish Red Cross" were taken by your juornos from Dr Goebbels report of 1943. "The Official Statement Concerning the Mass Murder at Katyn. Collected, prepared and edited by the German Information Bureau on the basis of documentary evidence by order of the German Foreign Office."[Amthches Material zum Massenmord van Katyn. Im Auftrage aea Auswartigen Amtes auf Grund urkundlichen Beweismaterials zusammengestellt, bearbeitet und herauagegeben von der Deutschen mjormationastelle"—Berlin 1943.]
To verify the report Germans were using very "independent" witnesses: Polish and British POW. Not the Red Cross.

You need to start reading at least what you can find in your, Western, archives instead of swallowing loose interpretation digests composed for you by your propagandists.

So, why then Poland refused to submit the documents in support of its claim when it was asked to do so?

 

[mememe]

I have to defend fdr here, he had to keep the coalition viable, this would have done any good, its sux but there it is.

The price that was ultimately paid in lives and suffering as a result of turning a blind eye to that murderous bastard is very hard to justify. Realpolitik doesn't justify it.

You people, really live on a different planet...

What do you think US was in 1940-s? A superpower? No, it was a RISING from economic disaster country. US was NOT in a position to dictate or decide.

 

[JakeStarkey]

Fact: the Soviets were responsible for Katyn.

Fact: those who argue against it are simply wrong and possibly nuts.

 

[Decus]

It's not "my" argument.

Polish Red Cross as well as US comission that visited Katyn came to the same conclusion: Germans did it.

If you support Dr Goebbels's claim (which is not surprising), then explain away this:

1. German manufactured cord;
2. Mountains of personalised artefacts in the grave;
3. Some of those identified as "Katyn dead" found alive in Poland;
4. Refusal of Poland to support its claim with documents.

You need professional help.

To set the record straight:
- The Polish Red Cross that exhumed the bodies in 1943 found the Soviets were guilty for the mass execution, NOT the Germans Polish Report Blames Russians for Katyn Massacre - NYTimes.com
- The Congressional Madden Commission in 1952 came to the same conclusion - the Soviets did it www.kresy-siberia.com/1952_Katyn_report_to_Congress.pdf

Records show that the governments of FDR and Churchill knew that the Soviets were guilty and the Russians have more recently admitted to their guilt and provided supporting documentation to that effect.

If you weren't such a tragic mess, you would be laughable. Seriously - get help.

No, darling, it's not me who needs "help". Your bollox from NYTimes (dated 1989) was written for those who don't know that Polish Red Cross report was the basis for Nuremberg decision on Katyn.

And the words your article attribute to "Polish Red Cross" were taken by your juornos from Dr Goebbels report of 1943. "The Official Statement Concerning the Mass Murder at Katyn. Collected, prepared and edited by the German Information Bureau on the basis of documentary evidence by order of the German Foreign Office."[Amthches Material zum Massenmord van Katyn. Im Auftrage aea Auswartigen Amtes auf Grund urkundlichen Beweismaterials zusammengestellt, bearbeitet und herauagegeben von der Deutschen mjormationastelle"—Berlin 1943.]
To verify the report Germans were using very "independent" witnesses: Polish and British POW. Not the Red Cross.

You need to start reading at least what you can find in your, Western, archives instead of swallowing loose interpretation digests composed for you by your propagandists.

So, why then Poland refused to submit the documents in support of its claim when it was asked to do so?

Why do some people find the mentally ill entertaining? You are a train wreck. Seriously - get help.

 

[JakeStarkey]

mememe is representative of the type of damaged mentality that clings to trutherism or birtherism.

 

[mememe]

Fact: the Soviets were responsible for Katyn.

.

According to Dr Goebbels and his brilliant disciples -- the US.