Tough to evauate Aaron Rodgers

[ginscpy]

They don'tletdefenses playf football anymore - so QBs are doing to havehugepasserratings,

I would lump Rogers wuth Brady and Kurt Warner so far.

 

[Wiseacre]

Your point is well taken, but right now Rodgers is as good as there is. Not easy to say that being a big Lions fan either. As far as his place in history, I think we need more time for that. I'd say maybe 10 seasons to build a body of work to judge on.

 

[TruthSeeker56]

Rodgers has the ability to run with the football. He is much more mobile than Brady or the Manning brothers or Warner or Montana.

Rodgers is already BETTER than Brett Favre ever was. That's why Favre takes cheap shots at Rodgers. Favre is a has-been crybaby.

 

[elvis]

Fuck Aaron Rodgers.

 

[Zander]

Rodgers is having an unbelievable season. He will either continue to impress, or he will revert to mean. My money is on the former...he's damn good!

 

[elvis]

I hope they go 16-0 and lose their first playoff game.

 

[ginscpy]

Montana was a mobile QB in his prime.

Nobody threw better on the run.

Still the Best QB who has ever played IMO.

Tie breakers were in college .

Both Marino and Elways were failures .

 

[TruthSeeker56]

Montana was a mobile QB in his prime.

Nobody threw better on the run.

Still the Best QB who has ever played IMO.

Tie breakers were in college .

Both Marino and Elways were failures .

All-time greatest quarterback? John Elway. Not even a close second.

Montana makes the top ten, MAYBE the top five. Johnny Unitas is easily in the top five, and Otto Graham is easily in the top ten.

It's tough to be objective when ranking athletes on the "all-time greatest" lists. You have to put your allegiances aside.

 

[Amelia]

Fuck Aaron Rodgers.

You want to have sexual relations with Rodgers?

Guess I can't blame you. He's awesome!