By wanting to defund Planned Parenthood Rand Paul has betrayed his Libertarian base in favor of the extremist rightwingers.
As for the rest of the GOP this is just a red meat issue that incites the base while giving the Dems ammunition to use that the GOP is still waging a war on women.
Those quotes in the OP will be used against whomever is the GOP candidate.
Defunding Planned Parenthood is very consistent with being a libertarian.
But opposing abortion is anti-Libertarian.
And using the government to deny anyone their rights is anti-Libertarian.
So what Rand Paul is using as his excuse to defund PP is anti-Libertarian which is where the betrayal comes in.
Nope.
A libertarian may believe that someone has a right to an abortion - as Ayn Rand did - but a libertarian never believes that someone has the right to have the abortion funded by the taxpayers.
Your argument is tantamount to saying because we have the right to own a gun, the government is denying you your rights if the government doesn't buy the gun for you. No libertarian would ever advance that argument.
Your position is based upon a falsehood.
The federal government is banned from funding abortions by law.
The PP federal funding is for non-abortion services only.
Therefore your baseless allegation about my argument is completely fallacious.
Your argument is flat out wrong.
I'm not arguing the merits of the policy. I'm arguing what you think defines a libertarian.
If you think that opposing taxpayers funding of abortions doesn't make you a libertarian, you have no idea what it means to be a libertarian.
You might as well argue that Soviet communists supported privately owned multinational corporations. It's just as wrong.