- Thread starter
- #21
Not to hit you over the head with this..and kibosh the thread.
But what the heck.
1. Well, then, let's stipulate that The Big Bad Wolf fervently believes, and wishes, that the United States of America be subject to whatever laws the United Nations chooses, drafts, endorses.
2. Further, be clear that Wolfie has not the foggiest that Congress must agree to any such laws...as his quote from the Constitution was meant to rebut the OP....
...it does not.
"The draft of the Constitution submitted to the Convention of 1787 by its Committee of Detail empowered Congress to declare the law and punishment of piracies and felonies committed on the high seas, and the punishment of counterfeiting the coin of the United States, and of offences against the law of nations. In the debate on the
floor of the Convention, the discussion turned on the question as to whether the terms, felonies and the law of nations, were sufficiently precise to be generally understood. The view that these terms were often so vague and indefinite as to require definition eventually prevailed and Congress was authorized to define as well as punish piracies, felonies, and offenses against the law of nations.
M. FARRAND, THE RECORDS OF THE FEDERAL CONVENTION OF 1787 168, 182 (Rev. ed. 1937). at 316
3. For your further edification,
In Medellin vs. Texas (2008), the International Court of Justice ruled that Texas could not execute a convicted murderer. The Supreme Court ruled that decisions of the International Court of Justice are not binding domestic law. The vote was 6 to 3 (Souter, Breyer, Ginsburg).
So, at least until the assumption of Barak Obama...the United States had and enforced soveriegnty, and did not bow, accede to the 'law of nations'....
You may not withdraw your paws from your mouth now.
Um..not quite.
No where did I point out that international law supercedes domestic law. That's a wild extrapolation that's constantly made by you and your ilk..when anyone recognizes that:
A. The United States was never meant to be an Empire.
B. The United States should be good citizens of the world and play nice with it's neighbors.
Do keep up.
1. Why don't you begin by informing yourself as to the meaning of 'sovereignty.'
2. "The United States should be good citizens of the world and play nice with it's neighbors."
This sounds like an eight-year-old...and an eight-year-old that had been subjected to a public school what-passes-for-an-education.
Grow up. Wise up.
3. "No where did I point out that international law supercedes domestic law."
Actually, that's pretty much what your post implied....but I understand this retreat.