The Balfour Declaration

[Sixties Fan]

The settlements are illegal. No agreement can legalize them.

Since you are not a lawyer of any kind, and understands Zero of anything which has occurred for the past 100 years........


Yawn.....

 

[P F Tinmore]

Another generation or two required to complete the clearing of Eretz Yisrael will not discourage the Jews in the slightest...

Not to mention 12 million Palestinians who will continue to push for the right to return. Israel has a long slog ahead and its military won't mean jack shit.

 

[Sixties Fan]

Not to mention 12 million Palestinians who will continue to push for the right to return. Israel has a long slog ahead and its military won't mean jack shit.

12 Million "Palestinians" do not have any right to return to the Israel. They may move to Gaza or TransJordan which are all part of the Mandate for Palestine and make a nice home there.

But Israel, they will never set foot as conquerors of the land again.

12 Million Arabs can return to Arabia, which is the only place on the planet they have any right to return to as being indigenous of that Peninsula .

Not in your lifetime will Israel will allow Muslims dictate what the rights of the Jewish People are. Nor in the next 1000 years. Jews had enough of Muslim violence against them.

 

[P F Tinmore]

12 Million "Palestinians" do not have any right to return to the Israel. They may move to Gaza or TransJordan which are all part of the Mandate for Palestine and make a nice home there.

But Israel, they will never set foot as conquerors of the land again.

12 Million Arabs can return to Arabia, which is the only place on the planet they have any right to return to as being indigenous of that Peninsula .

Not in your lifetime will Israel will allow Muslims dictate what the rights of the Jewish People are. Nor in the next 1000 years. Jews had enough of Muslim violence against them.

Israel is a castle built on sand.

 

[Sixties Fan]

Israel is a castle built on sand.

Thanks for the laugh. It is going to last for the rest of the day, maybe even longer.

 

[Kondor3]

Not to mention 12 million Palestinians who will continue to push for the right to return. Israel has a long slog ahead and its military won't mean jack shit.

Not to worry, Hassain... I'm sure the Jordanians will find a place for you, once you move east of the Jordan...

 

[Hollie]

Not to mention 12 million Palestinians who will continue to push for the right to return. Israel has a long slog ahead and its military won't mean jack shit.

Not to mention Arabs foreigners have no ''right of return''.

Maybe you want to lead the charge for those 12 million... by barking out orders from your basement?

 

[Hollie]

Israel is a castle built on sand.

You stole that slogan from the prayer leader at your madrassah, right?

 

[rylah]

Minus the 750,000 who were kicked off the voter rolls.

The 750,00 who tried to establish a colony
under the rule of thee prince of Mecca?

 

[rylah]

Indeed, the natives generally don't get along with colonial settlers. The British didn't understand the problem.

Could the British understand that if even the smallest nation,
manages to prevent exclusive Arab hegemony over the
entire Middle East - then Arab colonials already lost?

 

[RoccoR]

RE: The Balfour Declaration
SUBTOPIC: What it means...
⁜→ P F Tinmore, et al,

I think we need to cleanup some of this bogus implications you have spread.
.

Indeed, the natives generally don't get along with colonial settlers. The British didn't understand the problem.

.(COMMENT)

First, the natives of the day natives of the 1920s don't exist any more.

Second, there were NO (repeat NO) "colonial settlers." You make this allegation and yet, cannot identify the colonial power funding the settlements.

Minus the 750,000 who were kicked off the voter rolls.

.(COMMENT)

These displaced persons are significantly reduced in numbers. There could not be very many left. Of the original ≈ 750K displaced persons, only about 5k to 6k remaining.

​

​

.

San Remo was not a land treaty.

.(COMMENT)

San Remo was an agreement by the powers that be at the time. You might think that agreements and names must meet your lexicon, but that is not true. When the Allied Powers come together and set a path, they can effectively make any determination they want. In the Case of the 1920 San Remo Convention, the Supreme Council (among other things) set the path for the framework concerning the Mandate for Palestine
.

Not to mention 12 million Palestinians who will continue to push for the right to return. Israel has a long slog ahead and its military won't mean jack shit.

.(COMMENT)

There are not 12 million Arab Palestinians that could possibly hold the definition of Arab Palestinian Refugee. The definition is set by the
Convention Relating to the Status of Refugees --- NOT the Consolidated Eligibility and Registration Instructions (CERI) for refugees.

I know that Arab Palestinians believe that the CERI eligibility criteria which allows services to be rendered to descendants of the original 750,000 displaced, but that is simply not true. Refugee populations descend, not grow.
.

Most Respectfully,
R

 

[P F Tinmore]

First, the natives of the day natives of the 1920s don't exist any more.

So, the status of "native" can expire?

Interesting.

Link?

 

[Sixties Fan]

So, the status of "native" can expire?

Interesting.

Link?

Rocco misspoke. Being born in a place does not make one native/indigenous of the place.

Arabs, Palestinians or not, are not natives, or indigenous of Palestine, North African, the Middle East. Or Europe and the Americas.

Thousands of Jews spent 2500 years in Mesopotamia. It does not make them indigenous/natives of Mesopotamia/Iraq.

Thousands of Jews have lived in Rome since Caesar and later on after the 2nd Temple destruction. They do not consider themselves natives/indigenous of the land, nor have they ever claimed to be for one reason or another. They know that they are indigenous of the Land of Israel.


Arabs do not get to become "natives" of everywhere they moved to or invaded.

Move on.

 

[Sixties Fan]

9 protesters outside Jerusalem UK consulate against Balfour Declaration. 10 articles about them.​

Today, a group of Palestinians protested outside the British Consulate in Jerusalem to mark the 105th anniversary of the Balfour Declaration.

They attempted to present a lengthy letter of protest, demanding an apology and compensation from the British. The consulate refused to accept the letter so they placed it on the grate of the front door.

I count nine protesters.


Sama News, SND news, Al Siasi, Maan, AlQuds, Roya News, Wattan, NABD, Al Watan Voice and Safa are all covering the story.

That means more Palestinian news sites wrote about the protest than the number of protesters to begin with.

And the Israel haters do this often. While they do sometime get big crowds to their demonstrations, they cover even the tiniest protests as big news, to give the impression of far more political power than they really have.

After all, perception is as important as reality, and the anti-Israel side is excellent at propaganda techniques.

9 protesters outside Jerusalem UK consulate against Balfour Declaration. 10 articles about them.

Blogging about Israel and the Arab world since, oh, forever.

elderofziyon.blogspot.com