Should Israel have been created?

[toastman]

There were many Jewish faction in Mandatory Palestine, why do you keep on lying?

 

[P F Tinmore]

Tinnie just keeps on lying and lying. There were plenty of Jewish communities before the main immogration in 1947. Type in 'mandatory palestine civil war' and tell me how many articles you find...

Nice duck. The number is not the defining factor.

 

[toastman]

Tinnie just keeps on lying and lying. There were plenty of Jewish communities before the main immogration in 1947. Type in 'mandatory palestine civil war' and tell me how many articles you find...

Nice duck. The number is not the defining factor.

That doesnt even make sense.

You're the one ducking. There were plenty of Jewish communities before 1947 and the Fakestinians tried to wip them out

 

[toastman]

G

 

[P F Tinmore]

Weird, because when I look at a current map that area, it shows me Israel...

BTW, the map you showed me is not a country, but the BRITISH MANDATE OF PALESTINE. IT was a TERRITORY .

DO you have documents showing how PAlestinians legally acquired land?

The mandate was not a territory. It was to render assistance and advise to Palestine. It owned no territory and had no borders.

Since 1949 the west has made fake maps using the 1949 armistice lines. These were not borders but they use them anyway because Israel has no borders.

Fake maps hahaha !

Tinnie, you are a complete moron. ANything that you don't believe, you call fake or propaganda.

Palestine - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

First line :
Palestine (Arabic: فلسطين* Filasṭīn, Falasṭīn, Filisṭīn; Greek: Παλαιστίνη, Palaistinē; Latin: Palaestina; Hebrew: פלשתינה Palestina) is a conventional name, among others, for the geographic region in Western Asia between the Mediterranean Sea and the Jordan River, and various adjoining lands

GEOGRAPHIC REGION, not country

Then why is Israel always shown inside lines that are not borders?

Why don't they show Israel inside its real borders?

 

[toastman]

The mandate was not a territory. It was to render assistance and advise to Palestine. It owned no territory and had no borders.

Since 1949 the west has made fake maps using the 1949 armistice lines. These were not borders but they use them anyway because Israel has no borders.

Fake maps hahaha !

Tinnie, you are a complete moron. ANything that you don't believe, you call fake or propaganda.

Palestine - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

First line :
Palestine (Arabic: فلسطين* Filasṭīn, Falasṭīn, Filisṭīn; Greek: Παλαιστίνη, Palaistinē; Latin: Palaestina; Hebrew: פלשתינה Palestina) is a conventional name, among others, for the geographic region in Western Asia between the Mediterranean Sea and the Jordan River, and various adjoining lands

GEOGRAPHIC REGION, not country

Then why is Israel always shown inside lines that are not borders?

Why don't they show Israel inside its real borders?

Nice deflection. Are you acknowledging that Palestine wasn't a state?

 

[member]

"There is reality then there is what Tinnie believes."

"There is reality then there is what 'Toastman' believes."

seems, it's a two-way street

with 'everyone.' that's why no one wants to make friends.

 

[P F Tinmore]

Tinnie just keeps on lying and lying. There were plenty of Jewish communities before the main immogration in 1947. Type in 'mandatory palestine civil war' and tell me how many articles you find...

Nice duck. The number is not the defining factor.

That doesnt even make sense.

You're the one ducking. There were plenty of Jewish communities before 1947 and the Fakestinians tried to wip them out

You are the one who brought up the civil war. A civil war would be Palestinian V Palestinian. That was not the case.

ALIEN: By contrast, an "alien" is generally understood to be a foreigner -- a person who comes from a foreign country -- who does not owe allegiance to our country.

Definitions: Alien, Immigrant, Illegal Alien, Undocumented Immigrant

 

[P F Tinmore]

Fake maps hahaha !

Tinnie, you are a complete moron. ANything that you don't believe, you call fake or propaganda.

Palestine - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

First line :
Palestine (Arabic: فلسطين* Filasṭīn, Falasṭīn, Filisṭīn; Greek: Παλαιστίνη, Palaistinē; Latin: Palaestina; Hebrew: פלשתינה Palestina) is a conventional name, among others, for the geographic region in Western Asia between the Mediterranean Sea and the Jordan River, and various adjoining lands

GEOGRAPHIC REGION, not country

Then why is Israel always shown inside lines that are not borders?

Why don't they show Israel inside its real borders?

Nice deflection. Are you acknowledging that Palestine wasn't a state?

????

 

[toastman]

Nice duck. The number is not the defining factor.

That doesnt even make sense.

You're the one ducking. There were plenty of Jewish communities before 1947 and the Fakestinians tried to wip them out

You are the one who brought up the civil war. A civil war would be Palestinian V Palestinian. That was not the case.

ALIEN: By contrast, an "alien" is generally understood to be a foreigner -- a person who comes from a foreign country -- who does not owe allegiance to our country.

Definitions: Alien, Immigrant, Illegal Alien, Undocumented Immigrant

Tinnie, the jewish communities were not foreigners . For fucks sake, it wasnt even a country.
Try making some sense here.

 

[toastman]

Then why is Israel always shown inside lines that are not borders?

Why don't they show Israel inside its real borders?

Nice deflection. Are you acknowledging that Palestine wasn't a state?

????

I expected a response like that. You can't own up t o your own mistakes :

 

[P F Tinmore]

Nice deflection. Are you acknowledging that Palestine wasn't a state?

????

I expected a response like that. You can't own up t o your own mistakes :

What "mistake" are you talking about.

 

[P F Tinmore]

That doesnt even make sense.

You're the one ducking. There were plenty of Jewish communities before 1947 and the Fakestinians tried to wip them out

You are the one who brought up the civil war. A civil war would be Palestinian V Palestinian. That was not the case.

ALIEN: By contrast, an "alien" is generally understood to be a foreigner -- a person who comes from a foreign country -- who does not owe allegiance to our country.

Definitions: Alien, Immigrant, Illegal Alien, Undocumented Immigrant

Tinnie, the jewish communities were not foreigners . For fucks sake, it wasnt even a country.
Try making some sense here.

Did those communities have allegiance to Palestine or to the foreigners who imported them?

 

[Hossfly]

You are the one who brought up the civil war. A civil war would be Palestinian V Palestinian. That was not the case.

Tinnie, the jewish communities were not foreigners . For fucks sake, it wasnt even a country.
Try making some sense here.

Did those communities have allegiance to Palestine or to the foreigners who imported them?

Well, Tinnie, wouldn't your ancestors have stayed in their own Middle East country if the Jews didn't have jobs for them? For the Jews who had lived there as one old time Israeli poster on a different forum said his ancestors did for hundreds of years. don't you think those Arabs who came for jobs were foreigners to them?

 

[P F Tinmore]

Tinnie, the jewish communities were not foreigners . For fucks sake, it wasnt even a country.
Try making some sense here.

Did those communities have allegiance to Palestine or to the foreigners who imported them?

Well, Tinnie, wouldn't your ancestors have stayed in their own Middle East country if the Jews didn't have jobs for them? For the Jews who had lived there as one old time Israeli poster on a different forum said his ancestors did for hundreds of years. don't you think those Arabs who came for jobs were foreigners to them?

Everyone went to Palestine seeking a better life but that is not the issue.

 

[irosie91]

Did those communities have allegiance to Palestine or to the foreigners who imported them?

Well, Tinnie, wouldn't your ancestors have stayed in their own Middle East country if the Jews didn't have jobs for them? For the Jews who had lived there as one old time Israeli poster on a different forum said his ancestors did for hundreds of years. don't you think those Arabs who came for jobs were foreigners to them?

Everyone went to Palestine seeking a better life but that is not the issue.

The forces that determined the demographics or Palestine aka Judea/Israel---which
is the "holy" land of the jews is VERY MUCH an issue

"SEEKING A BETTER LIFE"?

-----flight from oppression ----is not the same as -----"things are looking up over
there----the jews are HIRING" Jews who fled to palestine in the 1800s---
did so under very significant peril ------but in many cases it was a lot better than
the filth of shariah and the stink of dhimmia ----
however you do make an interesting point-----arab/muslim who
left Israel in 1948----had good reason to try to get to those
fantastically rich OIL places-----for a BETTER LIFE----life
was tough in the place that had been called "palestine"
during the 1800s and first half of 1900s ---it was a veritable
petri dish of Tuberculosis, Polio, Cholera, Malaria, Shisto-
somiasis and even Leprosy