Should Israel deny building materials from Gaza?

Iriemon

VIP Member
Apr 2, 2009
2,745
99
83
Miami
Should Israel deny Palestine material and equipment it needs to rebuild its war shattered buildings?

In the four months since Israel launched its offensive against Hamas militants in the Gaza Strip, little reconstruction has taken place in the Palestinian territory.

...

Every day, Israel allows 80 to 100 truckloads of humanitarian aid into Gaza, but that does not include building supplies. The United Nations is calling on Israel to allow vital reconstruction materials like cement into Gaza. But Israel is resisting the appeal, citing the continuing security threat from militants.

...

John Ging, director of the United Nations Relief and Works Agency in the Gaza Strip, says that rocket attacks have diminished in recent weeks, yet Israel has not eased its blockade.

"There's nothing going on in terms of reconstruction because the crossings are still closed. That's the key to all the misery here," Ging says. "It's hard to fathom that after all of the outpouring of concern and empathy with the plight of the people here during the January conflict, that months later they are still living in the rubble of their former lives."

...

Israeli spokesman Yigal Palmor says there is a very simple reason.

"What we have there is a rebel area in secession from its own legitimate government, in an open armed confrontation with its main neighbor, Israel," Palmor says. "The real problem here is the attitude of the Hamas de facto government."


Shortages Stymie Rebuilding Efforts In Gaza : NPR

Israel seems to take the position it will deny aid to a area it destroyed because it doesn't like what the government is doing.

The US should take note of this tactic next time Israel doesn't agree to do what the US thinks is necessary for its interests in the region.
 
I disagree with the move. As long as the Jews control the borders and crossing of Gaza, they must let in vital supplies!
 
It will be interesting to see if the Obama Govt does anything about this. Calling on Israel to allow supplies into Gaza would piss off some Israel backers, but it's really not a big cost deal to Israel, but it would score lots of points in the Arab world, which points would be useful in future negotiations to resolve the Palestine/Israel mess.
 
they can get the materils from egypt why should they have to go through israel.....israel has no obligation to rebuild gaza.....
 
well, havent they in the past used nails and screws in suicide bombs to cause as much death as possible?

while i think they should allow in building materials, i also think they should be marked in a way that if they show up in bombs it can be easily identified
 
You know, to make Nail Bombs more damaging, you can coat the nails in shit to make them infectios and more nasty.
This means that Israel to prevent SHIT from entering Gaza.
Of course, everyone in Gaza producing SHIT is therefor also a mean terrorist, since SHIT cant be used for over means!

A random question, how long does someone has to imprison you on a field of rubbish in order to make you consider blowing that someone up?
 
they can get the materils from egypt why should they have to go through israel.....israel has no obligation to rebuild gaza.....

No obligation to rebuild; however, they do have an obligation to allow supplies into Gaza. Set up an inspection systems for Christ Sakes. Israel controls Gaza's border, like it or not that comes with huge responsibilities. I rather have Israelis inspecting the imports over Egyptians of Palestian Authority members!

The ironic thing is the blockade on Gaza really hurts Israeli merchants (translation: it hurts the Israeli economy). Who is Israelis biggest trade partner outside of the US? France nope, UK Nope! Its the Palestinians: Gaza and the West Bank!

The Gaza Strip blockade could seriously harm Israel's economy - Haaretz - Israel News
2006, for example, total Israeli exports to the 60 million or so residents of France stood at slightly more than $1 billion. Israeli exports to the same amount of people in Italy stood at just below $1 billion. Very fine statistics. But total exports to both of these countries, which rank among the eight richest countries in the world, are equal to Israel's exports to the 3.5 million people of the West Bank and Gaza Strip, according to the Central Bureau of Statistics. This is more than 6 percent of all Israeli exports, excluding diamonds.

For Ilan Eshel, head of the fruit growers organization, ending these ties means a very big headache.

The Gazans buy from Israel between 60 and 80 tons of fruit per year - bananas, apples, pears, peaches and avocados. Eshel estimates that some 10 percent of the Israeli fruit harvest goes to Gaza. This statistic can be misleading. "There are producers for whom it is 100 percent of their harvest," Adiri says.

Whatever the 1.5 million people in Gaza need to live comes to them from Israel - from milk products to diapers, from medicine to cement. Even the humanitarian aid from international organizations is bought almost entirely from Israeli companies. Israeli firms also earn money as middlemen. Gas for cars is bought in Gaza via an Israeli intermediary. About 5 percent of all freight that passes through the Ashdod port is earmarked for Gaza.

This money represents hundreds of millions of dollars that Israel put aside so it could eventually serve as a whip against the Palestinians.

"A textile factory in south Tel Aviv, which produces some of its products in Gaza, cannot exist without it [the connection with the Palestinians]," Catarivas says. "There are low-tech firms that are able to exist only because of the Gaza market. The manufacturers in the Arab sector are also dependent on the market in the West Bank and Gaza Strip.

Israel, according to this research, would lose around $2 billion per year. Some 76,000 jobs would be lost

Two people that economically dependent so much on each other have to be able to come to some type of resolution!
 
No. They should not let in any food or gas or other supplies. Let the Arabs take care of them. No more help from Israel until they recognize that Israel is a Jewish state.
 
No. They should not let in any food or gas or other supplies. Let the Arabs take care of them. No more help from Israel until they recognize that Israel is a Jewish state.
its called trade, Israelis benefit from trade
 
No. They should not let in any food or gas or other supplies. Let the Arabs take care of them. No more help from Israel until they recognize that Israel is a Jewish state.

How very un Obama-like of you ........... :eusa_whistle:
 
No. All aid grants and shipment of munitions to Israel should cease immediately, and we should threaten to suspend all economic and diplomatic relations with it and Egypt if the blockade issue remains unresolved.
 
No. All aid grants and shipment of munitions to Israel should cease immediately, and we should threaten to suspend all economic and diplomatic relations with it and Egypt if the blockade issue remains unresolved.

you should reconsider. right now GAZA is dependent day by day on aid shipments ---Israeli water lines and electricity. Neither Egypt nor Israel is dependant day by day on aid. What you describe would lead to a Gaza full of dead Gazans within 30 days. are you sure that is what you want?
 

Forum List

Back
Top