So you want to get better at catching Scum, eh? Well, it's not that easy. The later in the game it gets, the easier it becomes. It's rare to lynch Scum during Day 1, and it's uncommon during Day 2 barring PRs. There are a lot of different ways to go about catching Scum. Much of it is a matter of opinion. This link is helpful: Mastin s Guide To Scumhunting bull mafiascum.net You should always question, analyze, and weigh the motives of others. I find interactions to be one of the best ways for me to hunt Scum. There's also a list of things I'd like to list as Scummy/Not Scummy. If you want, you can share things you think might be Scummy, and I can try to weigh those instances, too. As Town I work to never take players' posts out of context. That's one thing I personally feel is Scummy. Also, you have to be careful to not indulge in hyperbole. Whenever a player evades, ignores, reacts defensively, or emotionally, or negatively, et al, that's like blood being poured in the water. Always strive to question the motives. Even if it means getting very quiet, focused, and deliberate with your questions.