SCOTUS Rules On Race As A Placement Factor

[Annie]

Against:

http://corner.nationalreview.com/post/?q=NDk1ZjQ0MmFhMWNlZGEyZDQ4MjI1ZDgwZDA3NTM2Nzg=

Supremes' Race Case [Andy McCarthy]

The decision is 185 pages long, but Chief Justice Roberts, according to ScotusBlog, appears to have summed it up in one memorable sentence: "The way to stop discrimination on the basis of race is to stop discriminating on the basis of race."

06/28 11:44 AM

 

[Larkinn]

Hello segregation!

 

[Larkinn]

Its interesting that all of the cases handed down in the past few days were 5-4 verdicts. Not a good sign imo...

 

[RetiredGySgt]

Its interesting that all of the cases handed down in the past few days were 5-4 verdicts. Not a good sign imo...

BUT it was ok when the 5-4 was liberal majority I take it?

The problem is we have 4 Justices that are more interested in legislating then ruling on law.

 

[Annie]

Hello segregation!

LOL! These were areas where segregation was not an overwhelming problem. Did you read the case?

 

[RetiredGySgt]

The only segregation occurring in the US now is on College Campuses by Blacks demanding segregated living and studying arrangements.

Can you imagine the uproar if whites demanded a White only facility?

 

[Larkinn]

BUT it was ok when the 5-4 was liberal majority I take it?

On one of them, the 5-4 was a liberal majority...or at least the "liberal" justices formed much of the majority. That was the death penalty case...which, if you notice would be included in the "all of the cases handed down in the past few days".

The problem is we have 4 Justices that are more interested in legislating then ruling on law.

I doubt you even know their names, much less what they are interested in.

LOL! These were areas where segregation was not an overwhelming problem. Did you read the case?

Most white students live in the northern part of Seattle, most students of other racial backgrounds in the southern part

Regardless, whether you think that it was a problem or not in Seattle, this will affect other places where it may be an overwhelming problem.

The only segregation occurring in the US now is on College Campuses by Blacks demanding segregated living and studying arrangements.

Go to NYC sometime...take the F train up to Columbia. Its mostly black with a smattering of whites. At the Columbia stop all the whites get off.

Sorry, but this country has a lot of segregation even now. It is mostly based around income inequality.

 

[RetiredGySgt]

Ahh yes, lets be all Star trek now, since you won't admit to Socialist or Communist idealogy. The entire argument your making now is that because someone has more money then someone else that is segregation and I assume your solution would involve coming up with some magic number that everyone should have a set amount of income and BIG BROTHER should take from those that have more and give to those that have less?

Using your logic, Families generally segregate them selfs from non families ( well at least those with children) since they tend to all move into the same housing areas with extra bedrooms. Perhaps we should require that all hoses be built with exactly the same floor plan and same number of rooms and that EVERYONE married, family , single be given their own home? That nasty segregation.

I can further assume that your TOTALLY against the predominately Black Colleges that exist and think each of them should provide preferential treatment at acceptance for whites to "even" out that segregation?

 

[maineman]

"The only segregation occurring in the US now is on College Campuses by Blacks demanding segregated living and studying arrangements."


did you forget to add , "in my inexpert layman's opinion", because that statement sure reads like it's presented as a statement of fact.

 

[RetiredGySgt]

"The only segregation occurring in the US now is on College Campuses by Blacks demanding segregated living and studying arrangements."


did you forget to add , "in my inexpert layman's opinion", because that statement sure reads like it's presented as a statement of fact.

It is a fact. I notice when you make your statements of "fact" about Islam and Sunni/shiite behavior you never add " my inexpert layman's opinion"

 

[Larkinn]

Ahh yes, lets be all Star trek now, since you won't admit to Socialist or Communist idealogy

Thinking that there should be be people living on the street in the richest country in the world is hardly Socialist. But alright.

The entire argument your making now is that because someone has more money then someone else that is segregation and I assume your solution would involve coming up with some magic number that everyone should have a set amount of income and BIG BROTHER should take from those that have more and give to those that have less?

No, thats not the argument I am making. When whites and blacks live separate and don't intermingle, thats segregation. Whether the reason is income inequality, government laws, or community intimidation, its segregation. The argument only has to do with income because when talking about race in this country income invariable comes into it.

Using your logic, Families generally segregate them selfs from non families ( well at least those with children) since they tend to all move into the same housing areas with extra bedrooms.

Unlike poor neighborhoods, houses with extra bedrooms are not generally all clustered around each other. You've used neither my logic, nor none of your own.

I can further assume that your TOTALLY against the predominately Black Colleges that exist and think each of them should provide preferential treatment at acceptance for whites to "even" out that segregation?

No, you can't further assume that without knowing the reason that I believe that desegregation is a good thing, which you don't know.

Assume less and ask more.

 

[Larkinn]

It is a fact. I notice when you make your statements of "fact" about Islam and Sunni/shiite behavior you never add " my inexpert layman's opinion"

You really think its a fact that the only segregation in the US is black only dorms?

If I disprove that "fact", will you not make any generalizations for a week?

 

[maineman]

It is a fact. I notice when you make your statements of "fact" about Islam and Sunni/shiite behavior you never add " my inexpert layman's opinion"

that is hilarious.

the ONLY segregation going on in America is on college campuses????

and I am neither inexpert nor a layman on those matters.

I notice you didn't respond to my questions about marine corps opinions or about your providing certification of your retired gunnery sergeant status.

 

[RetiredGySgt]

Do you live anywhere near subdivisions either already built or being built? Near any apartment complexes or complexes built for people with out children?

Your wrong. Subdivisions are built with a variety of floor plans but they ARE built for a set type of occupant. 2-4 bedroom, predominantly 3 and 4 are built with the intent of attracting families or those planning families. Complexes ( usually multi storied) with facilities like pools and gyms and such are generally one or two bedroom units ( there will be a few with more but again the vast majority are for families or singles with no children).

I will admit I have no experience with Housing projects in big cities meant to give free or near free apartments to people.

 

[RetiredGySgt]

that is hilarious.

the ONLY segregation going on in America is on college campuses????

and I am neither inexpert or a layman on those matters.

I notice you didn't respond to my questions about marine corps opinions or about your providing certification of your retired gunnery sergeant status.

I notice you have not provided any proof of world recognition on your "Expert" status on Muslim sects and the religion. Nor have I seen any DD-214 from you proving you were ever an Officer in any service, much less orders stating you served in any UN commands or were stationed anywhere you have claimed.

YOU have made Statements that your opinion holds more weight then anyone that disagrees with you on the matter of Muslims and sects. Provide some evidence that somehow you have been recognized in some capacity as an "expert" or admit your opinion is no better than anyone else.

 

[RetiredGySgt]

I spent 6 and a half years on Okinawa. I lived in the local community, I had Okinawan and Japanese neighbors and friends. That does not make me some kind of EXPERT on them.

 

[Larkinn]

Do you live anywhere near subdivisions either already built or being built? Near any apartment complexes or complexes built for people with out children?

I lived in apartment complexs for a few years. All of them had studios, single bedrooms, 2 bedroom, and 3 bedroom places.

Besides the fact that there is an obvious difference between the interest in desegregation of whites and blacks and the desegregation of those with children and those without children.

By the way...no response to my challenge about the "fact" you posted?

 

[Truthmatters]

I have seen MM posting for years now.

He was involved in the middle east as a part of his military duties.

I have know him for years and the story has never changed.

He is completely consistnant with what he claims his duties were during his service.

In my experience people who make false claims foul up somewhere along the line and change what they claim as expertice when it is false.

I believe him about his claims ,again they always stay consistant and he has never lied about anything to my knowledge and I have known him for about 5-6 years.

He has never given me ay reason not to believe him.

 

[RetiredGySgt]

I lived in apartment complexs for a few years. All of them had studios, single bedrooms, 2 bedroom, and 3 bedroom places.

Besides the fact that there is an obvious difference between the interest in desegregation of whites and blacks and the desegregation of those with children and those without children.

By the way...no response to my challenge about the "fact" you posted?

Every major University has Black Study centers, I forget the specific name, they include dorms and include efforts by the black students to discourage any non blacks from using them. Been a fact for quite some time now. You can easily discover this for your self by researching it. But of course you won't because you don't care. It says loads about your knowledge that your not aware of this.

 

[RetiredGySgt]

I have seen MM posting for years now.

He was involved in the middle east as a part of his military duties.

I have know him for years and the story has never changed.

He is completely consistnant with what he claims his duties were during his service.

In my experience people who make false claims foul up somewhere along the line and change what they claim as expertice when it is false.

I believe him about his claims ,again they always stay consistant and he has never lied about anything to my knowledge and I have known him for about 5-6 years.

He has never given me ay reason not to believe him.

But of course, I on the other hand, am as he has insinuated, a liar?