Osomir
VIP Member
1.) Show where in the Quran it says that everyone in the Arabian peninsula must be Islamic
2.) Muhammad held close alliances with non-Muslim groups on the peninsula right up to his death.
Isn't the issue that all lands must be controlled by Muslims? Slaves and Concubines can be Christians and Jews, but for Jews to control land is an affront to Islam. It's all part of the Muslim Supremacist thing.
Muhammad was openly allied with The Christians in Abyssinia without controlling them / having dominion over them. Such statements as the above simply isn't rooted in historical evidence; it's why Rosie wasn't able to cite anything specific; the simple fact is that there is very little specific for her to cite; hence the reliance on vague general statements coupled with stubborn instance.