Mansour El-Kikhia: Latest cartoon disrespect is call for change

Stephanie

Diamond Member
Jul 11, 2004
70,230
10,864
2,040
http://www.mysanantonio.com/opinion/columnists/melkikhia/stories/MYSA020206.2O.mansour.1bdb12e0.html
Web Posted: 02/02/2006 12:00 AM CST
San Antonio Express-News

I watched only part of President Bush's State of the Union address. I just couldn't bring myself to watch the whole speech. I soon discovered that I wasn't alone.

Since then, I had the opportunity to talk to a number of academic acquaintances in the Middle East. I was interested in getting a firsthand Arab response to the turmoil taking place between the Europeans and Muslims, but I also took the opportunity to get some feedback on Bush's speech.

To my surprise, none of them heard the address. When I told one that Bush had promised to put in place programs to end America's dependence on Middle Eastern oil by 2025, he retorted, "From your mouth to God's ear." He was hoping without the need for the region's oil, the United States would be less inclined to involve itself in the area's politics.

However, Bush might need to speed up the effort.

A huge storm has been brewing between Europe and the Islamic world since the publication in the Danish daily Jyllands-Posten of 12 cartoons depicting Muhammad, the prophet of Islam, as a terrorist. A Norwegian newspaper also carried the cartoons.

Muslims throughout the world took offense, and many were even angrier at the Danish editor's claim to freedom of speech. Demonstrations worldwide denouncing Denmark were followed by the closure of the Libyan Embassy in Copenhagen and the recall of the Saudi ambassador.

Worse yet were the public boycotts of Danish goods in the Muslim world. Danish companies in Saudi Arabia were forced to shut down, and a huge dairy factory under construction had to be put on hold. The citizens of Kuwait and the United Arab Emirates also boycotted Danish products.

France Soir, Germany's Die Welt, Italy's La Stampa and Spain's La El Periodico have come to the support of Jyllands-Posten. In Europe, fliers and posters are asking Europeans to boycott Muslim businesses.

Mr. Bush, whether you want it or not, you now have what your neocon advisers planned all along. You have a global religious and cultural war, and I promise no one will emerge a winner. As an American Muslim, I found the cartoons offensive and unnecessary, even if sanctioned by freedom of expression. Can you friggen believe this!

Fifteen million Muslims in Europe and 8 million in America have been subjected to alienation, discrimination, cultural, political and legal barriers by governments and citizens alike, all done in the name of security or freedom of expression.

To deal with this, Arab and Muslim peoples, not only governments, must swallow a difficult pill that includes the following:

First, they need to borrow from Gandhi's book and its emphasis on resistance without violence, for violence only gives Western society the incentive and excuse to interfere in their lives.

Second, they need to respect themselves and demonstrate freedom of expression by weaning themselves off Western aid, goods and services. Moreover, they must divest themselves from Western markets.

Third, I never thought I would agree with the Libyan dictator Moammar Gadhafi, but I urge Muslims to sever political and economic relations with any country using "freedom of expression" as an excuse to manifest hate for them.

Fourth, sell to and buy from each other and countries that respect them. That will mean dealing with Latin American countries, as well as China, India and South Korea.

Fifth, investment must be done within Islamic societies. There are 1.7 billion Muslims, and they don't need Western society to create their own common currency and market.

Only by becoming truly independent will they be able to stand up to the nonsense coming from Washington, London, Amsterdam, Copenhagen and elsewhere.
 
Stephanie said:
http://www.mysanantonio.com/opinion/columnists/melkikhia/stories/MYSA020206.2O.mansour.1bdb12e0.html
Web Posted: 02/02/2006 12:00 AM CST
San Antonio Express-News

I watched only part of President Bush's State of the Union address. I just couldn't bring myself to watch the whole speech. I soon discovered that I wasn't alone.

Since then, I had the opportunity to talk to a number of academic acquaintances in the Middle East. I was interested in getting a firsthand Arab response to the turmoil taking place between the Europeans and Muslims, but I also took the opportunity to get some feedback on Bush's speech.

To my surprise, none of them heard the address. When I told one that Bush had promised to put in place programs to end America's dependence on Middle Eastern oil by 2025, he retorted, "From your mouth to God's ear." He was hoping without the need for the region's oil, the United States would be less inclined to involve itself in the area's politics.

Hopefully we would be able to stay out of their economies too. With no need for oil, the Arabs could go back to herding camels and living in tents.

However, Bush might need to speed up the effort.

A huge storm has been brewing between Europe and the Islamic world since the publication in the Danish daily Jyllands-Posten of 12 cartoons depicting Muhammad, the prophet of Islam, as a terrorist. A Norwegian newspaper also carried the cartoons.

I got news for ya. The strom has been brewing ever since the peaceful religion of Islam decided that all infidels must convert or die.

Muslims throughout the world took offense, and many were even angrier at the Danish editor's claim to freedom of speech. Demonstrations worldwide denouncing Denmark were followed by the closure of the Libyan Embassy in Copenhagen and the recall of the Saudi ambassador.

No isolationism there, eh. Of course that is exactly what a 14th century society needs is isolationism!

Worse yet were the public boycotts of Danish goods in the Muslim world. Danish companies in Saudi Arabia were forced to shut down, and a huge dairy factory under construction had to be put on hold. The citizens of Kuwait and the United Arab Emirates also boycotted Danish products.

Good. Let the Arabs have their goat milk and camel dung.

France Soir, Germany's Die Welt, Italy's La Stampa and Spain's La El Periodico have come to the support of Jyllands-Posten. In Europe, fliers and posters are asking Europeans to boycott Muslim businesses.

Now there is a sane and rational response. Are they calling for the execution of Muslims and kidnapping Arab businessmen too?

Mr. Bush, whether you want it or not, you now have what your neocon advisers planned all along. You have a global religious and cultural war, and I promise no one will emerge a winner. As an American Muslim, I found the cartoons offensive and unnecessary, even if sanctioned by freedom of expression. Can you friggen believe this!

Actually, Europe has just discovered that the nation of Islam has been at war with them all along (and winning). I hope the writer realizes that there are many who find Islam offensive and unnecessary even if it is sanctioned by freedom of religion.

Fifteen million Muslims in Europe and 8 million in America have been subjected to alienation, discrimination, cultural, political and legal barriers by governments and citizens alike, all done in the name of security or freedom of expression.

And just how many have been jailed, tortured, beheaded, and discriminated against over the centuries all in the name of Allah?

To deal with this, Arab and Muslim peoples, not only governments, must swallow a difficult pill that includes the following:

First, they need to borrow from Gandhi's book and its emphasis on resistance without violence, for violence only gives Western society the incentive and excuse to interfere in their lives.

Great Idea...borrow from someone elses ideology because yours sucks!

Second, they need to respect themselves and demonstrate freedom of expression by weaning themselves off Western aid, goods and services. Moreover, they must divest themselves from Western markets.

Awesome idea...go back to your camel herds. Want to see what an Arab country looks like when they dont have Western aid go take a look at Afghanistan when the Taliban wass in power....it was an Islamic paradise!

Third, I never thought I would agree with the Libyan dictator Moammar Gadhafi, but I urge Muslims to sever political and economic relations with any country using "freedom of expression" as an excuse to manifest hate for them.

Aw, cmon. I bet you agreed with good ol Moammar when he was trying to defy the United States. Of course, you will notice that the writier does not suggest that Muslims should stop hating anyone else.

Fourth, sell to and buy from each other and countries that respect them. That will mean dealing with Latin American countries, as well as China, India and South Korea.

Good idea...maybe you can sell some camels for a couple of bags of rice...Better yet, sell em all that oil you will have extra cause you are not selling it to the West. Then China can interfere in your region. They are so much nicer than the US and Europre. Just ask Nepal and Tibbet!

Fifth, investment must be done within Islamic societies. There are 1.7 billion Muslims, and they don't need Western society to create their own common currency and market.

I thought they were already doing that...where else are they getting all those guns and explosives?

Only by becoming truly independent will they be able to stand up to the nonsense coming from Washington, London, Amsterdam, Copenhagen and elsewhere.

And only by destroying Islam and every Muslim country on the planet will we be rid of the terrorism, hate and violence that plagues the world today.

The more the Muslims talk, the more I think we should drop some nuclear democracy on ALL the capitols of Muslim countries.
 

Forum List

Back
Top