Joe the Plumber...err...Joe the WELFARE recipient

I don't know Kath, I think there's a legitimate reason to criticize this guy now. He was used directly by the McCain campaign to promote the idea, through his own words, that redistributing the wealth is bad policy, meanwhile he himself benefitted from just such a policy.

To me, that's morally and ethically wrong.

A bit of hyperbole going on here. Apparently, Joe has received a handout at some point or another, though I haven't read the specifics of what exactly he received. I received low interest student loans to pay for my college tuition. Sure, I guess that's a handout.

However, I completely disagree with the premise of giving people tax credits who don't pay into the system. Dude, that's just whack.
 
Joe wanted to be in the media spotlight - so he got what he deserved. Gee, I wonder who tipped off the media about Joe's welfare. :eusa_whistle:

Not at first he didn't. The media attacked a private citizen for asking a question and hardly paid attention to Obama's answer. This was a disgraceful moment in American politics.
 
Last edited:
I don't know Kath, I think there's a legitimate reason to criticize this guy now. He was used directly by the McCain campaign to promote the idea, through his own words, that redistributing the wealth is bad policy, meanwhile he himself benefitted from just such a policy.

To me, that's morally and ethically wrong.

We disagree. I think all Americans have the right to question their representatives, without intimidation. If one is not intimidated by the investigation into Joe, one is a fool.
 
Do you have any idea how many people have questioned this guy? Not only is he black, not only is he relatively unknown to the world up until 4 years ago, not only does he have questionable associations, not only did his pastor for 20 years yell out loudly "GOD DAMN AMERICA" on tape for all to see, not only did he defeat the Clinton machine, not only did he spend a good part of his youth in Inodnesia, but he is also running for president. He has held hundreds of town hall meetings with people just like you and me, he has met with hundreds of thousands if not millions of Americans like you and me who have all questioned him. Have we all been destroyed?

No.

Joe the Plumber was destroyed because he lied. He tried to make something about himself more than he was. He was at the very least, a huge idiot and hypocrite. At the most he was a plant for the McCain campaign. His entire purpose was to convince middle America that Obama's tax plan would hurt them because it was wrong to accept money from rich people. There's a passage that goes: "Do not judge lest ye' be judged." If Joe really was buying a business, which he's not, if Joe really had that kind of money to buy a business, which he doesn't, if Joe's name really was Joe, which it isn't, then Joe wouldn't be stupid enough to question Obama's tax plan, because he would know Obama's tax plan for small businesses actually help them.



Who forced him to go on FoxNews almost every other week? Who forced him to campaign for John McCain? Who forced him to say that Obama = Death to Israel? Who forced him to get his own publicit, to seek a record deal and to seek a book deal? He forced this on himself. When you put yourself out there in the view of the public and you're attacking someone who is very popular with a majority of American's, expect to get attacked. You better be squeaky clean.

Don't even go down that hypocrisy road. The biggest hypocrite is Obama. Even I spared my dime to help out his brother George living in a hut in Kenya, when he wouldn't. This is a non-story. Joe wasn't running for office, he merely stepped out of his house and asked a candidate of the presidential candidate.

People who didn't have the authority went into his private files and dug up "dirt," so that they could use it to smear Joe. This is disgusting and the people who did this should be held accountable.

Some of your posts are good, this one wasn't.
 
You guys missed the real point of Joe. His real job was to make Palin look better.

No one cared that he asked Obama a question as a citizen, just like that one student who "ambushed" Palin at that coffee shop (I think). McCain made Joe a public figure. Joe kept himself in the spotlight and he's milking it. I have no sympathy for him nor does he seem to care anyways.
 
Not at first he didn't. The media attacked a private citizen for asking a question and hardly paid attention to Obama's answer. This was a disgraceful moment in American politics.

Show me one negative story about Joe the Plumber before the final debate occured where John the McCain mentioned Joe the Plumber a million times. "My old buddy, Joe the Plumber." One negative news story about Joe the Plumber before the debate. Because JTP appeared on FoxNews the day after.
 
Show me one negative story about Joe the Plumber before the final debate occured where John the McCain mentioned Joe the Plumber a million times. "My old buddy, Joe the Plumber." One negative news story about Joe the Plumber before the debate. Because JTP appeared on FoxNews the day after.

The only story here is that Joe stole the media's thunder. They didn't like it. They're assholes and not doing their job as journalists.
 
We disagree. I think all Americans have the right to question their representatives, without intimidation. If one is not intimidated by the investigation into Joe, one is a fool.

He did ask Obama a question and Obama didn't intimidate him. If that was the extent of it, it would've been over.

Now separately: McCain used Joe the Plumber a total of 20+ times in the debate. This made Joe the Plumber famous. Joe then went out to the media and had several conversations with them. Again, no problems. Then JTP went on FauxNews and went on the Sean Hannity Show. This raised a red flag. People wanted to know who this Joe the Plumber was - so they researched him. Turns out, he owes taxes. Turns out he was on welfare. Turns out he makes $40,000 a year. Turns out he doesn't have nearly enough money to even think about buying his boss' business.

Turns out Joe lied about EVERYTHING. Then he goes around and spreads lies about Obama and socialism and Obama and Israel. Turns out this guy is nothing more than a manufacutred fraud.
 
He did ask Obama a question and Obama didn't intimidate him. If that was the extent of it, it would've been over.

Now separately: McCain used Joe the Plumber a total of 20+ times in the debate. This made Joe the Plumber famous. Joe then went out to the media and had several conversations with them. Again, no problems. Then JTP went on FauxNews and went on the Sean Hannity Show. This raised a red flag. People wanted to know who this Joe the Plumber was - so they researched him. Turns out, he owes taxes. Turns out he was on welfare. Turns out he makes $40,000 a year. Turns out he doesn't have nearly enough money to even think about buying his boss' business.

Turns out Joe lied about EVERYTHING. Then he goes around and spreads lies about Obama and socialism and Obama and Israel. Turns out this guy is nothing more than a manufacutred fraud.
Again, attack McCain if you or the media wish. He used Joe, because his answer elicited some of the information many of us feared about Barack. In the long run, no damage done, most seem comfortable with socialism. That the arms of the government and media were used to pick through his life, silences us all.
 
He did ask Obama a question and Obama didn't intimidate him. If that was the extent of it, it would've been over.

Now separately: McCain used Joe the Plumber a total of 20+ times in the debate. This made Joe the Plumber famous. Joe then went out to the media and had several conversations with them. Again, no problems. Then JTP went on FauxNews and went on the Sean Hannity Show. This raised a red flag. People wanted to know who this Joe the Plumber was - so they researched him. Turns out, he owes taxes. Turns out he was on welfare. Turns out he makes $40,000 a year. Turns out he doesn't have nearly enough money to even think about buying his boss' business.

Turns out Joe lied about EVERYTHING. Then he goes around and spreads lies about Obama and socialism and Obama and Israel. Turns out this guy is nothing more than a manufacutred fraud.
no, thats wrong
the MEDIA sought HIM out after the debate
 

Forum List

Back
Top