Israel passes controversial law on West Bank settlements

[rylah]

Finally we can say they worth their money. Congrats on the Hasdara law.

Why do you think this law is a good thing? It is legitimizing theft of land that is Palestinian private property. Is that a good thing?

Latest expulsion from Ammona happened as a result of a collaboration between B'tselem NGO and the Palestinian family (who didn't even know they owned any land).

Their claim was for 4% of the Ammona territory. However they could NOT point to the exact plot- and the Court decided it was enough to demolish the whole town.
This was a precedent as I understand.
How many more thousands of Jews have to be cleansed from Judea Samaria because of such shady claims?

What will the Palestinians do when Palestinian Jews demand back their lands in Jerusalem they were expelled from several times just in the last 100-150 yrs?

How many Palestinians were cleansed when they instituted their absentee landowner policies? Shady indeed.


Meh.

Is a peasant the owner of a land he works on, especially after the landlord sells it?

 

[Shusha]

Why do you think this law is a good thing? It is legitimizing theft of land that is Palestinian private property. Is that a good thing?

That is an statement designed to evoke emotion rather than present the rather more complex situation. One would have to start to understand the complexities of the issues by being very careful how one defines "private property" and "theft".

 

[rylah]

Just for perspective-1 day before the same Judge ordered the evacuation of Ammona, signed an order to let Arab families who happen to live on private Jewish land in Jerusalem. have more time before they find a suitable arrangement for a living.

In comparison- Gush Katif residents are still waiting for such an arrangement, (promised) and the Ammona evacuation started hours before the time set in the order.

What most of the westerners don't understand is the purpose of this law in relation to the Court and the NGO's.

How long has the fight over Ammona been going on?

Too long, these people were evacuated more than once. Each time rebuilding their life on their own...and still no new town as promised to them.

 

[Coyote]

Just for perspective-1 day before the same Judge ordered the evacuation of Ammona, signed an order to let Arab families who happen to live on private Jewish land in Jerusalem. have more time before they find a suitable arrangement for a living.

In comparison- Gush Katif residents are still waiting for such an arrangement, (promised) and the Ammona evacuation started hours before the time set in the order.

What most of the westerners don't understand is the purpose of this law in relation to the Court and the NGO's.

How long has the fight over Ammona been going on?

Too long, these people were evacuated more than once. Each time rebuilding their life on their own...and still no new town as promised to them.

The Israeli government should not have allowed it in the first place. That is part of the problem. It's not fair to the settlers and it's not fair to the Palestinians.

 

[rylah]

Just for perspective-1 day before the same Judge ordered the evacuation of Ammona, signed an order to let Arab families who happen to live on private Jewish land in Jerusalem. have more time before they find a suitable arrangement for a living.

In comparison- Gush Katif residents are still waiting for such an arrangement, (promised) and the Ammona evacuation started hours before the time set in the order.

What most of the westerners don't understand is the purpose of this law in relation to the Court and the NGO's.

How long has the fight over Ammona been going on?

Too long, these people were evacuated more than once. Each time rebuilding their life on their own...and still no new town as promised to them.

The Israeli government should not have allowed it in the first place. That is part of the problem. It's not fair to the settlers and it's not fair to the Palestinians.

Why not allow it? These people were actually encouraged to build and thus be a safety barrier for the rest. It's A 10-15 minutes ride from Jerusalem and Tel-Aviv.
Petah Tikva once was a 'settlement' too, but now officially recognized part of Israel, with Arabs living there too.

Maale Adumim, Ariel and Petah Tikva are the same...it's just that this time it's Judea Samaria- and some just can't see Jews prospering there.

 

[Shusha]

The Israeli government should not have allowed it in the first place. That is part of the problem. It's not fair to the settlers and it's not fair to the Palestinians.

The Israeli government shouldn't have allowed WHAT, exactly?

They shouldn't have allowed Jews to build on State land in territory under its complete and total legal jurisdiction because the Arab Muslims don't like living next to Jews? That is a political argument. And an immoral one as well.

They should not have allowed Israeli citizens to build on "private Palestinian land"? How do you define "private land"? Which laws are you using to determine that the land is "privately owned Palestinian land"? The Ottoman Empire's? Jordan's? Israel's? Some sort of vague appeal to a "wanna-be Palestinian State's"? "International Law"?

 

[montelatici]

You Zionists are a real barrel of laughs. Trying to rationalize theft, expropriation and Apartheid all at the same time. LOL

 

[Hollie]

You Zionists are a real barrel of laughs. Trying to rationalize theft, expropriation and Apartheid all at the same time. LOL

Not surprisingly, you use terms you don't understand.

You Islamic terrorist worshippers are a hoot.

The Avalon Project : The Palestinian National Charter

The Palestinian National Charter: Resolutions of the Palestine National Council July 1-17, 1968

Article 1:
Palestine is the homeland of the Arab Palestinian people; it is an indivisible part of the Arab homeland, and the Palestinian people are an integral part of the Arab nation.


The Avalon Project : Hamas Covenant 1988

Israel will exist and will continue to exist until Islam will obliterate it, just as it obliterated others before it" (The Martyr, Imam Hassan al-Banna, of blessed memory).



How about Islamic terrorist gender apartheid?

Hamas orders schools in Gaza to be segregated by gender

 

[Lipush]

Finally we can say they worth their money. Congrats on the Hasdara law.

Why do you think this law is a good thing? It is legitimizing theft of land that is Palestinian private property. Is that a good thing?

I think any law which tries to prevent the expulsion of Jews is a good law, and if it prevents future rift among Jews, it is even more blessed.

We all remember the rotten fruits we had to be fed with, when we chopped off the trees of Gush Kattif. History has proved-

when you expel the 'orange' (settlers), you get the 'red' (rockets)

 

[Lipush]

Just for perspective-1 day before the same Judge ordered the evacuation of Ammona, signed an order to let Arab families who happen to live on private Jewish land in Jerusalem. have more time before they find a suitable arrangement for a living.

In comparison- Gush Katif residents are still waiting for such an arrangement, (promised) and the Ammona evacuation started hours before the time set in the order.

What most of the westerners don't understand is the purpose of this law in relation to the Court and the NGO's.

I believe you're talking about Danziger; Yes, I recall reading he suspended to warrent calling to evacuate the Private Jewish proparty stolen by the Arab squatters, because it may traumatize them and it is not necessary to cause them such distress

Talk about selective justice.

 

[Lipush]

Just for perspective-1 day before the same Judge ordered the evacuation of Ammona, signed an order to let Arab families who happen to live on private Jewish land in Jerusalem. have more time before they find a suitable arrangement for a living.

In comparison- Gush Katif residents are still waiting for such an arrangement, (promised) and the Ammona evacuation started hours before the time set in the order.

What most of the westerners don't understand is the purpose of this law in relation to the Court and the NGO's.

How long has the fight over Ammona been going on?

Too long, these people were evacuated more than once. Each time rebuilding their life on their own...and still no new town as promised to them.

The Israeli government should not have allowed it in the first place. That is part of the problem. It's not fair to the settlers and it's not fair to the Palestinians.

They will get compansation. What is wrong with it?