WinterBorn
Diamond Member
Ok, but other than spirits and such I can’t think of anything which is incorporeal that isn’t from the material world.I am trying to explain to you that your beliefs are mutually exclusive.If it didn't originate from the material world and it didn't originate from the spiritual world, then it must have originated from winterborn's mind.
You are defining the spiritual world, not me. I said I do not believe it originated from the material world. If there are incorporeal things, that does not necessarily mean there are sentient spirits.
And I am trying to explain to you that they are not. I simply believe that not all incorporeal things are god.
To be considered a believer in dualism beliefs in spirits are required. Believing in the incorporeal won’t make you a believer in dualism.
So you would be considered a materialist because you don’t believe in spirits.
According to you, belief in spirits is a belief in god. I have repeatedly stated that I do not believe in any sentience in the incorporeal.