I Don't Want to be Eaten

[Misty]

"NEW YORK (Reuters) - New York City's accused "cannibal cop" crossed the line from fantasy to reality in plotting to kidnap, cook and eat women, a federal prosecutor told a jury in closing arguments on Thursday.

Defense attorney Julia Gatto countered in summations that her client was playing a fantasy role online, and told jurors "we don't convict human beings because of ugly thoughts ... even if they are police officers."

Jurors begin deliberations in New York cannibal cop case

 

[Misty]

 

[Misty]

How can my thread be "old" when I just fucking put it up? Hmmm?!

 

[Katzndogz]

Ohhhh it's this way.

Discussing and planning how to kidnap, kill and eat women is just fantasy. Shooting in a world of warcraft game is real!

There is a time to despair over this sad once great nation. This is one of those times.

At least the cannibal cop wasn't gay, or he would really have done it.

Revealed: Gay porn star 'cannibal' suspected of killing and eating parts of former lover threatened Canadian Prime Minister Stephen Harper | Mail Online

 

[Sallow]

How can my thread be "old" when I just fucking put it up? Hmmm?!

It's "old" to you..because you are the only posting in it.

I've been following this story.

His defense might fly if he wasn't using real people or the police database.

My take is that he needs some jail time...along with therapy.

And even after he's released..he needs to be monitored.

 

[Misty]

Is this a common fantasy of men? I mean I watched Louis CK the other night, not his series but his comedy special, and he says men have really sick perverted thoughts all day long. He said he is tired of always thinking about sick thoughts that women can't even imagine.

I think this cop needs to have his arms cut off and his teeth removed like on the walking dead.

 

[Bill Angel]

The Other White Meat
So what's the problem?​

 

[Misty]

Ohhhh it's this way.

Discussing and planning how to kidnap, kill and eat women is just fantasy. Shooting in a world of warcraft game is real!

There is a time to despair over this sad once great nation. This is one of those times.

At least the cannibal cop wasn't gay, or he would really have done it.

Revealed: Gay porn star 'cannibal' suspected of killing and eating parts of former lover threatened Canadian Prime Minister Stephen Harper | Mail Online

Lol good point video games are real but chatting about eating women is fantasy.

I wonder if cannibals will now become a special interest group.

 

[Misty]

The Other White Meat
So what's the problem?​

Some people want to be eaten. So they kill themselves and give the cannibal permission to eat them.

And I have heard we do taste like chicken.

 

[PaulS1950]

What crime was committed? I don't profess to know much about the case but I am wondering if someone actually did anything to facilitate a crime or it is now wrong to use imagination?

 

[there4eyeM]

I can't believe the title of this thread. Really took my attention.

It is unusual to speak so openly about x-u-all preferences.

 

[Sallow]

Is this a common fantasy of men? I mean I watched Louis CK the other night, not his series but his comedy special, and he says men have really sick perverted thoughts all day long. He said he is tired of always thinking about sick thoughts that women can't even imagine.

I think this cop needs to have his arms cut off and his teeth removed like on the walking dead.

1. Nope.

2. He didn't do anything..but the planning thing is problematic. Over punishing is just as bad as under punishing.

 

[Sallow]

What crime was committed? I don't profess to know much about the case but I am wondering if someone actually did anything to facilitate a crime or it is now wrong to use imagination?

Planning to kill someone is a crime.

 

[Misty]

What crime was committed? I don't profess to know much about the case but I am wondering if someone actually did anything to facilitate a crime or it is now wrong to use imagination?

There in lies the controversy.

They will have to make a law that you can't fantasize about eating women.

 

[Misty]

I can't believe the title of this thread. Really took my attention.

It is unusual to speak so openly about x-u-all preferences.

Heehee. I wanted to get people's attention.

I don't like that term in regard to cunnilingus.

We need a new term for that sexual action.

 

[Misty]

Is this a common fantasy of men? I mean I watched Louis CK the other night, not his series but his comedy special, and he says men have really sick perverted thoughts all day long. He said he is tired of always thinking about sick thoughts that women can't even imagine.

I think this cop needs to have his arms cut off and his teeth removed like on the walking dead.

1. Nope.

2. He didn't do anything..but the planning thing is problematic. Over punishing is just as bad as under punishing.

Do zombie shows promote the eating of people the way video games promote shooting of people.

I don't believe video games encourage the killing of people.

 

[Papawx3]

Why kill a woman just to eat her? I'd think it would be much better if she were alive to enjoy it.

 

[Misty]

Why kill a woman just to eat her? I'd think it would be much better if she were alive to enjoy it.

Seems like waste of a good women doesn't it.

 

[Papawx3]

Why kill a woman just to eat her? I'd think it would be much better if she were alive to enjoy it.

Seems like waste of a good women doesn't it.

For real, Misty. One thing I can't stand is the abuse (or waste) of a good woman.

 

[MikeK]

What crime was committed? I don't profess to know much about the case but I am wondering if someone actually did anything to facilitate a crime or it is now wrong to use imagination?

Those are exactly my thoughts.

Is this fellow being charged with a crime based on expressed fantasy, which could be a casual sketch for a Quentin Tarantino-type screenplay? Or has he taken actual steps to affirm intentions to commit a crime, or to engage in a conspiracy to do so, or to entice others into criminal activity? Are there any tangible factors or is he being prosecuted because of a perception that his homicidal thoughts are in fact actual intentions? If so, this is a very dangerous precedent -- regardless of how unpleasant the subject matter of his thoughts.

So far as I've read, the whole things seems like nothing more bizarre in the way of onanistic fantasy than a number of tv movies, such as The Devil's Own (a really sick one). The question is whether freedom of expression is being challenged here.