Germany Gets It... Why Don't We?

Okay.......I see where this is going........

The GOPer's want us all to reduce OUR tax rate by the same percentage that Germany has lowered theirs, only we won't start at Germany's rate of 29.8 or 45 percent, we want to have it reduced from 20 and 35 percent, at the same percentage as Germany.

Got it. The greedy are getting greedier and feeling like they deserve it.

Entitlement is a bitch goddess and will kill you people. Don't do it.

How is it greed to want to keep the fruits of your own labor.

Oh??

And the super wealthy got that way through their own labor?
It is the worker who wants to recapture what has been lost in his standard of living. salaries have not kept pace with housing, healthcare, education and energy costs. While worker salaries have stagnated, the percentage of wealth maintained by the top 5% has increased annually


THEN STOP WORKING FOR SOMEONE ELSE!!!! START A BUSINESS AND WORK FOR YOURSELF!!!!!! Sheesh, it's not that F&*%N hard to figure out is it???????

But you won't do that because it is much easier to sit there at the computer and bitch about other people who risked their money to start a business instead of start one yourself.... :cuckoo:
 
German Taxes
Corporate: 29.8% on average
Individual: 0-45%
Payroll: None
VAT/Sales: 19%

Compared to ours
Corporate: 20% on average
Individual: 0-35%
Payroll: 15%
VAT/Sales: None

Nice play with numbers, why did you exclude the state tax rate from your figures? Corporations pay state tax, 20% average federal is too low.

The tax rate is closer to 39%, thats much higher than germany.

I didn't include state taxes in the United States because that would skew the comparison (since both the lander and towns also levy taxes in Germany). The 20% federal average is not "too low". The corporate income tax rate in the United States is not 39%. 39% is the tax levied on corporations in the top bracket. Those in the lowest bracket pay 15%. Beyond that, the large numbers of deductions available result in the average company paying around 20%.

No your wrong, the tax rate is much higher for corporations, much higher than 20% so your statement that Germany's tax rate is "much higher" is wrong. You want to get nit picky lets include property tax, sale tax, medicare, social security (7.5% on every dollar) and lets not forget workmen comp. thats an additional 10 cent on every dollar.

So you got an excuse when you intentionally skew the figure, you make a very low average, exclude tons of tax.

The USA pays too much tax.
 
And it should be noted that the Merkel elections were not simply support of Merkel and her more economically moderate CDU party, but rather the significantly increased support for the much more aggressively pro-business support of the FDP - which Merkel will now have to form a coalition government with, and by way of their victories, be required to accept much of the FDP's pro-business agenda. The FDP now dominates the once-powerful liberal Social Democrat Party in Germany.

Even in what was a sizable loss for the SDP, they still got more votes (23% versus 15%) and a larger share of the seats (146 to 93) than the FDP.

The election was a near absolute repudiation of Germany's old socialist government power structure.

It might well prove a bellwether election that will sweep across Europe. The EU has already seen a decided shift toward more right of center political parties, and with the election of Europe's #1 economy, more such shifting could very well continue...

This just shows how little you know about German politics. Germany has typically been ruled by CDU-lead coalitions.

1949: CDU/CSU/FDP
1953: CDU/CSU/FDP/DP
1957: CDU/CSU/FDP
1961: CDU/CSU/FDP
1965: CDU/CSU/FDP -> FDP leaves government in 1966 over budget dispute, CDU-lead grand coalition with SDP formed
1969: SDP/FDP
1972: SDP/FDP
1976: SDP/FDP
1980: SDP/FDP -> FDP leaves government in 1982, forms new coalition with CDU/CSU to form a CDU/CSU/FDP cabient
1983: CDU/CSU/FDP
1987: CDU/CSU/FDP
1990: CDU/CSU/FDP
1994: CDU/CSU/FDP
1998: SDP/A90
2002: SDP/A90
2005: CDU/CSU/SDP
2009: CDU/CSU/FDP

With the exception of 1994 to 2005, the parties of the left have never secured a majority.
 
Germany still has MUCH higher taxes than the US.

Are you proposing we should assume the German tax rate?


Let's Compare:
Corporate Tax: (you know the tax the drives business overseas):
Germany 29%
USA 35% (2nd highest in the world)

Income tax:
Germany 0-45%
USA 0-35% Fed + 0-10.3% = 0-45.3%

Payroll Tax:
Germany 0%
USA 15.3%

Sales Tax:
Germany 19.7%
USA - Varies by state 0-12%

Also we pay some of the highest property taxes in the WORLD!
Property tax - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Don't be fooled America has been a taxation hell that our forefathers would be rolling over in their grave of!


Tax rates around the world - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
 
Germany still has MUCH higher taxes than the US.

Are you proposing we should assume the German tax rate?

How much higher?

German Taxes
Corporate: 29.8% on average
Individual: 0-45%
Payroll: None
VAT/Sales: 19%

Compared to ours
Corporate: 20% on average
Individual: 0-35%
Payroll: 15%
VAT/Sales: None

So that 12% sales tax I paid for lunch was?

Corporate taxes in America are largely hailed as the second largest in the world.
Individual 0-35% at the Fed level, but it can be up to another 10.5% at the State level (hello CA and NY)!
 
So lets get this straight.

If we assume Germany's tax rate, do we get healthcare thrown in?

How about all those vacation days?

To answer your question, YES we should start following German's model and start reducing taxes and develop a public/private healthcare system!
 
Nice play with numbers, why did you exclude the state tax rate from your figures? Corporations pay state tax, 20% average federal is too low.

The tax rate is closer to 39%, thats much higher than germany.

I didn't include state taxes in the United States because that would skew the comparison (since both the lander and towns also levy taxes in Germany). The 20% federal average is not "too low". The corporate income tax rate in the United States is not 39%. 39% is the tax levied on corporations in the top bracket. Those in the lowest bracket pay 15%. Beyond that, the large numbers of deductions available result in the average company paying around 20%.

No your wrong, the tax rate is much higher for corporations, much higher than 20% so your statement that Germany's tax rate is "much higher" is wrong. You want to get nit picky lets include property tax, sale tax, medicare, social security (7.5% on every dollar) and lets not forget workmen comp. thats an additional 10 cent on every dollar.

So you got an excuse when you intentionally skew the figure, you make a very low average, exclude tons of tax.

The USA pays too much tax.

You want to take all of it together? So be it.

http://www.doingbusiness.org/documents/Paying_Taxes_2008.pdf

That's a study of corporate taxes put together by the World Bank in conjunction with PricewaterhouseCoopers. German corporations pay 50.8 percent of commercial profits in taxes. American firms pay 46.2 percent.
 
I didn't include state taxes in the United States because that would skew the comparison (since both the lander and towns also levy taxes in Germany). The 20% federal average is not "too low". The corporate income tax rate in the United States is not 39%. 39% is the tax levied on corporations in the top bracket. Those in the lowest bracket pay 15%. Beyond that, the large numbers of deductions available result in the average company paying around 20%.

No your wrong, the tax rate is much higher for corporations, much higher than 20% so your statement that Germany's tax rate is "much higher" is wrong. You want to get nit picky lets include property tax, sale tax, medicare, social security (7.5% on every dollar) and lets not forget workmen comp. thats an additional 10 cent on every dollar.

So you got an excuse when you intentionally skew the figure, you make a very low average, exclude tons of tax.

The USA pays too much tax.

You want to take all of it together? So be it.

http://www.doingbusiness.org/documents/Paying_Taxes_2008.pdf

That's a study of corporate taxes put together by the World Bank in conjunction with PricewaterhouseCoopers. German corporations pay 50.8 percent of commercial profits in taxes. American firms pay 46.2 percent.



Except now the Germans are looking to slash said taxes.

Yeah - let's go there...
 
How much higher?

German Taxes
Corporate: 29.8% on average
Individual: 0-45%
Payroll: None
VAT/Sales: 19%

Compared to ours
Corporate: 20% on average
Individual: 0-35%
Payroll: 15%
VAT/Sales: None

So that 12% sales tax I paid for lunch was?

Corporate taxes in America are largely hailed as the second largest in the world.
Individual 0-35% at the Fed level, but it can be up to another 10.5% at the State level (hello CA and NY)!

If you're going to run that comparison, you'll need to add in Germany's local taxes too.
 
German Taxes
Corporate: 29.8% on average
Individual: 0-45%
Payroll: None
VAT/Sales: 19%

Compared to ours
Corporate: 20% on average
Individual: 0-35%
Payroll: 15%
VAT/Sales: None

So that 12% sales tax I paid for lunch was?

Corporate taxes in America are largely hailed as the second largest in the world.
Individual 0-35% at the Fed level, but it can be up to another 10.5% at the State level (hello CA and NY)!

If you're going to run that comparison, you'll need to add in Germany's local taxes too.

Germany doesn't tax like we do! Comparing US Fed and State with German's posted numbers is an apples to apples comparison.
 
The left leaning/statist parties of Germany ruled for well over a decade and in that time, Germany's economy began to become stifled under the burden of an increasingly wasteful socialized system.

It appears the new coalition government in Germany will be deliberating sweepting tax cuts post-haste, shelving the plan to tax investment transactions, limiting minimum wage expansion, and moving to increase/speed up privatization of the banking industry.

These new elections indicate a significant shift to a far more business-friendly form of government to unleash German industry once again...


SCENARIOS-German coalition likely to take small reform steps | Markets | Markets News | Reuters
 
So that 12% sales tax I paid for lunch was?

Corporate taxes in America are largely hailed as the second largest in the world.
Individual 0-35% at the Fed level, but it can be up to another 10.5% at the State level (hello CA and NY)!

If you're going to run that comparison, you'll need to add in Germany's local taxes too.

Germany doesn't tax like we do! Comparing US Fed and State with German's posted numbers is an apples to apples comparison.

No, it's not, because you're ignoring taxes levied by the Lander.
 
Germany is a socialist nation as is the United States. banks, Insurance Companies, Automobile manufacturing firms are all owned by the US Government. This is socialism at its best.
 
I didn't include state taxes in the United States because that would skew the comparison (since both the lander and towns also levy taxes in Germany). The 20% federal average is not "too low". The corporate income tax rate in the United States is not 39%. 39% is the tax levied on corporations in the top bracket. Those in the lowest bracket pay 15%. Beyond that, the large numbers of deductions available result in the average company paying around 20%.

No your wrong, the tax rate is much higher for corporations, much higher than 20% so your statement that Germany's tax rate is "much higher" is wrong. You want to get nit picky lets include property tax, sale tax, medicare, social security (7.5% on every dollar) and lets not forget workmen comp. thats an additional 10 cent on every dollar.

So you got an excuse when you intentionally skew the figure, you make a very low average, exclude tons of tax.

The USA pays too much tax.

You want to take all of it together? So be it.

http://www.doingbusiness.org/documents/Paying_Taxes_2008.pdf

That's a study of corporate taxes put together by the World Bank in conjunction with PricewaterhouseCoopers. German corporations pay 50.8 percent of commercial profits in taxes. American firms pay 46.2 percent.

Why should we beleive what you post here when your busy argueing that the Nazi party never formed an alliance with the Communist party in order to oust the Prussia government.

Whats the point in your arguement, that Americans are not taxed high and the Communist never did anything bad?
 
No your wrong, the tax rate is much higher for corporations, much higher than 20% so your statement that Germany's tax rate is "much higher" is wrong. You want to get nit picky lets include property tax, sale tax, medicare, social security (7.5% on every dollar) and lets not forget workmen comp. thats an additional 10 cent on every dollar.

So you got an excuse when you intentionally skew the figure, you make a very low average, exclude tons of tax.

The USA pays too much tax.

You want to take all of it together? So be it.

http://www.doingbusiness.org/documents/Paying_Taxes_2008.pdf

That's a study of corporate taxes put together by the World Bank in conjunction with PricewaterhouseCoopers. German corporations pay 50.8 percent of commercial profits in taxes. American firms pay 46.2 percent.

Why should we beleive what you post here when your busy argueing that the Nazi party never formed an alliance with the Communist party in order to oust the Prussia government.

Whats the point in your arguement, that Americans are not taxed high and the Communist never did anything bad?


Yes - it is quite possibly so.

The fact is, so many who support higher taxes in the United States actually pay very little in taxes - at least income tax. They do not own a business, they do not provide jobs, create wealth, etc. - and as such, the idea is one in which they are perfectly comfortable with.

They are a minority - albeit a loud whiny one...
 
The fact is, so many who support higher taxes in the United States actually pay very little in taxes - at least income tax. They do not own a business, they do not provide jobs, create wealth, etc. - and as such, the idea is one in which they are perfectly comfortable with.

They are a minority - albeit a loud whiny one...


How could they be in the minority? The fact is that there are more less affluent people than affluent people. They ARE the majority. Saying otherwise is ludicrous. Everybody can't own a business or there would be no one to give jobs to. Businesses cannot run without employees either.
 
The fact is, so many who support higher taxes in the United States actually pay very little in taxes - at least income tax. They do not own a business, they do not provide jobs, create wealth, etc. - and as such, the idea is one in which they are perfectly comfortable with.

They are a minority - albeit a loud whiny one...


How could they be in the minority? The fact is that there are more less affluent people than affluent people. They ARE the majority. Saying otherwise is ludicrous. Everybody can't own a business or there would be no one to give jobs to. Businesses cannot run without employees either.


We are talking of those who support higher taxes pard.

They are in the minority...
 
No your wrong, the tax rate is much higher for corporations, much higher than 20% so your statement that Germany's tax rate is "much higher" is wrong. You want to get nit picky lets include property tax, sale tax, medicare, social security (7.5% on every dollar) and lets not forget workmen comp. thats an additional 10 cent on every dollar.

So you got an excuse when you intentionally skew the figure, you make a very low average, exclude tons of tax.

The USA pays too much tax.

You want to take all of it together? So be it.

http://www.doingbusiness.org/documents/Paying_Taxes_2008.pdf

That's a study of corporate taxes put together by the World Bank in conjunction with PricewaterhouseCoopers. German corporations pay 50.8 percent of commercial profits in taxes. American firms pay 46.2 percent.

Why should we beleive what you post here when your busy argueing that the Nazi party never formed an alliance with the Communist party in order to oust the Prussia government.

Whats the point in your arguement, that Americans are not taxed high and the Communist never did anything bad?

Now here you go, making shit up. You claimed that the KPD was part of the Nazi Party, then you tried to change your argument later after that was ripped to pieces.
 
German lander taxes are the equivalent of the water bill in the US which goes to city government.


Yup - I have an aquaintance who came from Germany about six years ago. He and his American wife own a book store/coffee shop with about seven employees.

He rants about the complexities of the US tax system all the time, saying it is "just as bad or maybe worse" than the system he left in Germany.

There should be no arguement - the German tax system needs work. So too does the American tax system. The German voters are pushing for reduced taxes and more government efficiency. So too are/will the American voters...
 

Forum List

Back
Top