faith-based support groups for men addicted to pornography

[dilloduck]

Why is castration of rapists recommended as a method of treatment?

 

[Gunny]

Why is castration of rapists recommended as a method of treatment?

I recommend castrating them at the neck. :chains:

 

[Annie]

Why is castration of rapists recommended as a method of treatment?

I would guess this has to do with 'getting it up' to commit the rape. Wouldn't change the mental intent though.

 

[Powerman]

Why is castration of rapists recommended as a method of treatment?

Castration reduces testosterone which not only gives men their sex drive but their aggressive behavior. Nothing will change the fact that these people are simply sick in the head though. I don't care how horny you are; unless you are dimented you don't go around raping people, period.

 

[Shattered]

This has gotten too convoluted. I still think most rapes are about the end result of achieving orgasm. I'm also curious as to how a guy rapes somebody without even getting it up. However, this is going nowhere. No matter how wrong I supposedly am, nobody has yet refuted me with anything but stating 'facts' without backup, and assuming that they're right without giving me a reason to believe them, so I feel no reason to change my mind. I also find it infantile to get so worked up over a typo. That being the case, I'm going with one of my dad's favorites: "It's better to lose an argument than a friend." That being said, you're right. I'm out. See ya in another thread.

*shakes head*

Believe me.. It's all about control. They may not be able to control the events in their lives, but they can damn well control another person..It may be the ONLY thing they can control, if only for a short time... You stated that most rapists choose people they know.. Why do you suppose that is?

 

[dilloduck]

I would guess this has to do with 'getting it up' to commit the rape. Wouldn't change the mental intent though.

That's sorta what i was thinking. Wouldn't this just result in the rapist choosing another "weapon"?

 

[Gunny]

That's sorta what i was thinking. Wouldn't this just result in the rapist choosing another "weapon"?

Possibly. Depends on how mental the rapist is.

 

[dilloduck]

Possibly. Depends on how mental the rapist is.

If rape is ALL about power I wouldn't think that castration would help one iota.

 

[Said1]

This has gotten too convoluted. I still think most rapes are about the end result of achieving orgasm. I'm also curious as to how a guy rapes somebody without even getting it up. However, this is going nowhere. No matter how wrong I supposedly am, nobody has yet refuted me with anything but stating 'facts' without backup, and assuming that they're right without giving me a reason to believe them, so I feel no reason to change my mind. I also find it infantile to get so worked up over a typo. That being the case, I'm going with one of my dad's favorites: "It's better to lose an argument than a friend." That being said, you're right. I'm out. See ya in another thread.

I don't know why you find it so hard to make the connection. You even looked it up yourself and quoted it (with out the link). Why should I have to look up and link what you did for me? No body is to blame for your misunderstanding but you.

And you got to admit, the typo WAS funny. No one was worked up over it, just larfing a little. :

 

[Shattered]

It doesn't.. But death would sure as hell solve the problem. How many times do I have to tell you people that bullets are cheap?

 

[Gabriella84]

You stated that most rapists choose people they know.. Why do you suppose that is?

Rapists don't always know their victims. They choose someone who fits their profile. A lot of rapists don't even like women.

 

[Shattered]

Rapists don't always know their victims. They choose someone who fits their profile. A lot of rapists don't even like women.

Go back and read his posts, and then let him answer my question. He made a statement, and I'm asking him to clarify his reasoning for it.

 

[Gunny]

If rape is ALL about power I wouldn't think that castration would help one iota.

Right. Execute them. They've effectively stolen their victim's life.

 

[Shattered]

Right. Execute them. They've effectively stolen their victim's life.

Copycat.

 

[Gunny]

Copycat.

Well, stop doing that.

 

[dilloduck]

It doesn't.. But death would sure as hell solve the problem. How many times do I have to tell you people that bullets are cheap?

probably a lot because I think you are a little to eager to kill everyone who commits a crime.

 

[Shattered]

probably a lot because I think you are a little to eager to kill everyone who commits a crime.

*shrug* People will smarten up REAL quick, once they realize there's REAL consequences for their actions.

 

[dilloduck]

*shrug* People will smarten up REAL quick, once they realize there's REAL consequences for their actions.

Right--like deaths resulting from going over the speed limit

 

[Hobbit]

I don't know why you find it so hard to make the connection. You even looked it up yourself and quoted it (with out the link). Why should I have to look up and link what you did for me? No body is to blame for your misunderstanding but you.

And you got to admit, the typo WAS funny. No one was worked up over it, just larfing a little. :

I've made the connection. I just doubt its strength. I also just remembered one more study. This is one I heard on the radio about a month ago, so sorry, no link. Can't even remember the details. It was a study in some European country where rapists were chemically 'neutered.' The testes were left mostly intact, but sex drive was completely removed. Those rapists that had this done were at least 70% less likely to commit another sexual offense (can't remember the exact number). You still gonna say that the orgasm has nothing to do with it?

Anyway, it's all irrelivant. I've already broken my word to myself that I'd politely bow out. Even if I'm right, I'm clearly not provoking anything but hostility and opposition, which serves no real purpose no matter how right you are. If anyone has a link to any actual evidence to back yourself up and you think it may actually change my mind, pm me. So far, all I've seen is, "Well [insert theory] is true. What about that?" I don't consider anything true without *something* other than your self-confidence to back it up, and that includes my faith, so those of you who are thinking about it, don't start. You know who you are.

 

[Shattered]

Right--like deaths resulting from going over the speed limit

No... Those going over the speed limit are not impeding traffic.. Those going too far under, in the wrong lane, are.. Therefore, a few paintballs to the back window of their car should be sufficient enough to get them to speed up, or get the hell off the road.

Intentionally inflicting lifelong harm, or death itself on another individual is worthy of death in return.