Do Volcanoes Produce More CO2 Than Humans?

[Liminal]

The answer: No, human activity emits far more CO2 into the atmosphere than any volcano ever has. We know that volcanic activity has dramatically changed global weather patterns in the past. Yet somehow, some people still believe that human activity couldn't possibly have any effect on climate change now.
Do volcanoes emit more CO2 than humans

 

[Liminal]

Does the average white male emit more CO2 than the average brown cow...or the average Mt. St. Helens?

Answer... Only if it's Liminal spewing his bullshit.

Oh.
Which produces more CO2 volcanic or human activity

 

[Crick]

I think the point about volcanoes vs humans is an old one and even the most ignorant of our denier buddies here (and, you are all our buddies) are aware of the reality in that regard.

 

[Mr. H.]

Why do we have 58 million acres of corn planted in the U.S. for the sole purpose of making ethanol?

Answer: The ass-fucking farmer.

Anyone with an ounce of gray matter knows that 58 million acres of forest would be far more benefit to the environment.

But- we must let Liberals have their way, mustn't we.

 

[Billy_Bob]

Too Funny:

All three of the last major Yellowstone eruptions dwarfed mans output in total by a factor of 1,000.. and with in 100 years of each eruption the air was clear, cold, but clear..

But hey, dont let a few facts spoil your liberal rant...

 

[jon_berzerk]

Why do we have 58 million acres of corn planted in the U.S. for the sole purpose of making ethanol?

Answer: The ass-fucking farmer.

Anyone with an ounce of gray matter knows that 58 million acres of forest would be far more benefit to the environment.

But- we must let Liberals have their way, mustn't we.

a co2 intensive project

 

[Liminal]

Too Funny:

All three of the last major Yellowstone eruptions dwarfed mans output in total by a factor of 1,000.. and with in 100 years of each eruption the air was clear, cold, but clear..

But hey, dont let a few facts spoil your liberal rant...

Yellowstone hasn't erupted since before humans walked the earth.

 

[Billy_Bob]

Too Funny:

All three of the last major Yellowstone eruptions dwarfed mans output in total by a factor of 1,000.. and with in 100 years of each eruption the air was clear, cold, but clear..

But hey, dont let a few facts spoil your liberal rant...

Yellowstone hasn't erupted since before humans walked the earth.

SO what? You claimed that volcano's can not and have not spewed more than man. That statement is an outright lie.

 

[Flopper]

Yet somehow, some people still believe that human activity couldn't possibly have any effect on climate change now.
Do volcanoes emit more CO2 than humans

The believe that man can't destroy the world is deeply rooted in Christian ideology. God will destroy the earth, not man so all this global warming has to be just nonsense. And of course, it's a liberal conspiracy.

 

[Liminal]

Too Funny:

All three of the last major Yellowstone eruptions dwarfed mans output in total by a factor of 1,000.. and with in 100 years of each eruption the air was clear, cold, but clear..

But hey, dont let a few facts spoil your liberal rant...

Yellowstone hasn't erupted since before humans walked the earth.

SO what? You claimed that volcano's can not and have not spewed more than man. That statement is an outright lie.

How about since humans have been around? How much volcanic CO2 put into the atmosphere since then?

 

[Liminal]

Yet somehow, some people still believe that human activity couldn't possibly have any effect on climate change now.
Do volcanoes emit more CO2 than humans

The believe that man can't destroy the world is deeply rooted in Christian ideology. God will destroy the earth, not man so all this global warming has to be just nonsense. And of course, it's a liberal conspiracy.

No need to worry, God's got it all under control. The end is coming and there's nothing you, or I, or anyone else can do about it, so just relax and enjoy the show.

 

[SillyWabbit]

Yet somehow, some people still believe that human activity couldn't possibly have any effect on climate change now.
Do volcanoes emit more CO2 than humans

The believe that man can't destroy the world is deeply rooted in Christian ideology. God will destroy the earth, not man so all this global warming has to be just nonsense. And of course, it's a liberal conspiracy.

It takes no ideology to understand that no human activity is going to destroy the world. Such hubris.
Aliens on the other hand...

 

[Old Rocks]

Too Funny:

All three of the last major Yellowstone eruptions dwarfed mans output in total by a factor of 1,000.. and with in 100 years of each eruption the air was clear, cold, but clear..

But hey, dont let a few facts spoil your liberal rant...

Yellowstone hasn't erupted since before humans walked the earth.

SO what? You claimed that volcano's can not and have not spewed more than man. That statement is an outright lie.

That volcano's cannot and have not spewed more than man is an outright lie. But that is what you said, not what Liminal said. Yes, before and during the P-T extinction event volcanoes spewed more GHG's than we have put in the atmosphere thus far. But we are putting the GHGs in the atmosphere at a much faster rate than did the volcanoes of that time.

What Liminal said is that the Yellowstone Caldera has not had a major eruption during that time that Homo Sapiens has been on earth, and that is correct.

 

[Liminal]

Too Funny:

All three of the last major Yellowstone eruptions dwarfed mans output in total by a factor of 1,000.. and with in 100 years of each eruption the air was clear, cold, but clear..

But hey, dont let a few facts spoil your liberal rant...

Yellowstone hasn't erupted since before humans walked the earth.

SO what? You claimed that volcano's can not and have not spewed more than man. That statement is an outright lie.

That volcano's cannot and have not spewed more than man is an outright lie. But that is what you said, not what Liminal said. Yes, before and during the P-T extinction event volcanoes spewed more GHG's than we have put in the atmosphere thus far. But we are putting the GHGs in the atmosphere at a much faster rate than did the volcanoes of that time.

What Liminal said is that the Yellowstone Caldera has not had a major eruption during that time that Homo Sapiens has been on earth, and that is correct.

I guess people should just take your word for that. Or maybe you could present some evidence.

 

[Billy_Bob]

Too Funny:

All three of the last major Yellowstone eruptions dwarfed mans output in total by a factor of 1,000.. and with in 100 years of each eruption the air was clear, cold, but clear..

But hey, dont let a few facts spoil your liberal rant...

Yellowstone hasn't erupted since before humans walked the earth.

SO what? You claimed that volcano's can not and have not spewed more than man. That statement is an outright lie.

That volcano's cannot and have not spewed more than man is an outright lie. But that is what you said, not what Liminal said. Yes, before and during the P-T extinction event volcanoes spewed more GHG's than we have put in the atmosphere thus far. But we are putting the GHGs in the atmosphere at a much faster rate than did the volcanoes of that time.

What Liminal said is that the Yellowstone Caldera has not had a major eruption during that time that Homo Sapiens has been on earth, and that is correct.

Ok moron.. How much did Sulfur-dioxide, Carbon dioxide, Carbon-monoxide, Ozone, and other GHG's/particulates did Yellowstone belched out during the last three major eruptions. Just one volcano dwarfs mans output throughout the industrial age?

You really should stop the wacky weeds..

 

[SwimExpert]

It's funny (i.e. sad and disturbing) that people have so entirely confused climate with CO2. For some, the study of climate is nothing more than talking about CO2. Everything else is ignored and deemed irrelevant.

 

[Liminal]

Too Funny:

All three of the last major Yellowstone eruptions dwarfed mans output in total by a factor of 1,000.. and with in 100 years of each eruption the air was clear, cold, but clear..

But hey, dont let a few facts spoil your liberal rant...

Yellowstone hasn't erupted since before humans walked the earth.

SO what? You claimed that volcano's can not and have not spewed more than man. That statement is an outright lie.

That volcano's cannot and have not spewed more than man is an outright lie. But that is what you said, not what Liminal said. Yes, before and during the P-T extinction event volcanoes spewed more GHG's than we have put in the atmosphere thus far. But we are putting the GHGs in the atmosphere at a much faster rate than did the volcanoes of that time.

What Liminal said is that the Yellowstone Caldera has not had a major eruption during that time that Homo Sapiens has been on earth, and that is correct.

Ok moron.. How much did Sulfur-dioxide, Carbon dioxide, Carbon-monoxide, Ozone, and other GHG's/particulates did Yellowstone belched out during the last three major eruptions. Just one volcano dwarfs mans output throughout the industrial age?

You really should stop the wacky weeds..

Let's try comparing that since man has been around.
The point of the thread, which no one has bothered to even try to rebut: Volcanoes have changed the global climate in the past, we know that much for sure. Yet somehow, human activity couldn't possibly be responsible for anything.

 

[Billy_Bob]

Too Funny:

All three of the last major Yellowstone eruptions dwarfed mans output in total by a factor of 1,000.. and with in 100 years of each eruption the air was clear, cold, but clear..

But hey, dont let a few facts spoil your liberal rant...

Yellowstone hasn't erupted since before humans walked the earth.

SO what? You claimed that volcano's can not and have not spewed more than man. That statement is an outright lie.

That volcano's cannot and have not spewed more than man is an outright lie. But that is what you said, not what Liminal said. Yes, before and during the P-T extinction event volcanoes spewed more GHG's than we have put in the atmosphere thus far. But we are putting the GHGs in the atmosphere at a much faster rate than did the volcanoes of that time.

What Liminal said is that the Yellowstone Caldera has not had a major eruption during that time that Homo Sapiens has been on earth, and that is correct.

Ok moron.. How much did Sulfur-dioxide, Carbon dioxide, Carbon-monoxide, Ozone, and other GHG's/particulates did Yellowstone belched out during the last three major eruptions. Just one volcano dwarfs mans output throughout the industrial age?

You really should stop the wacky weeds..

Let's try comparing that since man has been around.
The point of the thread, which no one has bothered to even try to rebut: Volcanoes have changed the global climate in the past, we know that much for sure. Yet somehow, human activity couldn't possibly be responsible for anything.

NO! You made a statement that is factually false. Even today the number of volcanoes and their actions are UNKOWN on the sea floors and in other volcanic zones. All they have is a hope and poke at what ghg's are being produced.

We are currently over due for the next volcanic cycle on earth (noting geological times scales are fickle things). We have even been outgasing all over the US as earth quakes happen and even that is being neglected.

CO2 is a fictional boogie man.. gawd people have got to get off this lie.

 

[Liminal]

Yellowstone hasn't erupted since before humans walked the earth.

SO what? You claimed that volcano's can not and have not spewed more than man. That statement is an outright lie.

That volcano's cannot and have not spewed more than man is an outright lie. But that is what you said, not what Liminal said. Yes, before and during the P-T extinction event volcanoes spewed more GHG's than we have put in the atmosphere thus far. But we are putting the GHGs in the atmosphere at a much faster rate than did the volcanoes of that time.

What Liminal said is that the Yellowstone Caldera has not had a major eruption during that time that Homo Sapiens has been on earth, and that is correct.

Ok moron.. How much did Sulfur-dioxide, Carbon dioxide, Carbon-monoxide, Ozone, and other GHG's/particulates did Yellowstone belched out during the last three major eruptions. Just one volcano dwarfs mans output throughout the industrial age?

You really should stop the wacky weeds..

Let's try comparing that since man has been around.
The point of the thread, which no one has bothered to even try to rebut: Volcanoes have changed the global climate in the past, we know that much for sure. Yet somehow, human activity couldn't possibly be responsible for anything.

NO! You made a statement that is factually false. Even today the number of volcanoes and their actions are UNKOWN on the sea floors and in other volcanic zones. All they have is a hope and poke at what ghg's are being produced.

We are currently over due for the next volcanic cycle on earth (noting geological times scales are fickle things). We have even been outgasing all over the US as earth quakes happen and even that is being neglected.

CO2 is a fictional boogie man.. gawd people have got to get off this lie.

Yes, I understand why you prefer to avoid addressing the premise of the thread.

 

[mamooth]

Billy is invoking his magical invisible volcanoes again.

Many denier arguments boil down to "But can you prove it's not magic, huh, can you? If you can't prove it's not magic, global warming theory must be a hoax!". That's why nobody pays any attention to them.