Sure, actually I can. Money is directly taken from my paycheck, to give to GM as a grant to develop batteries for Electric Vehicles. Money is given as subsidy for Ethanol, which otherwise would be completely eliminated from the market lacking that money. So I can point to numerous things that with government money, directly affect my life. Like the cost of electricity going up, to pay for subsidized 'renewable' energy, such as wind turbines. These are things that directly impact society, that are not due to tax breaks and tax deductions and tax abatement. I know this, because without a direct subsidy, these things would be unprofitable. No amount of a tax deduction, or tax break, can make an unprofitable business survive. If your business isn't making money, getting a discount on your land tax, isn't going to magically make you profitable. You might pick the lease spot on the left-side or right-side of the street, or town, or even state, based on lower taxes.... but a profitable business is profitable, or it isn't. I'm not going to change which company I do business with, or buy a computer from, or where I order stuff online, based if Apple has a 'data center' in Iowa, or Amazon has an office in Dublin Ohio. So I can confidently say that giving a tax break, to either one, will have zero impact on me, and likely have zero impact on the vast majority of people on the fact of the Earth, and I would wager even the majority in Dublin. And no, you have no made the case. At least not so far as I have read in this thread. You have made tons of claims. But claims, are not facts.