Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature currently requires accessing the site using the built-in Safari browser.
Arabs have lived there for 1,400 years as a majority.
Kosher people lived there as a majority for far less years.
Yes. The Jewish people were a minority in their own homeland. Do you know why that is? Shall I tell you? Its because they were invaded, displaced, ethnically cleansed, and colonized.
You are against these things, remember?
2,000 years later nobody should owe anbody anything.
To think so is insanity.
Alright, so are you saying that an invaded, displaced, ethnically cleansed and colonized people have no recourse and no rights? That an invaded, displaced, ethnically cleansed and colonized people are cut off from their homeland?
You already had a homeland.
Jewish Autonomous Oblast - Wikipedia
Arabs have lived there for 1,400 years as a majority.
Kosher people lived there as a majority for far less years.
Yes. The Jewish people were a minority in their own homeland. Do you know why that is? Shall I tell you? Its because they were invaded, displaced, ethnically cleansed, and colonized.
You are against these things, remember?
2,000 years later nobody should owe anbody anything.
To think so is insanity.
Alright, so are you saying that an invaded, displaced, ethnically cleansed and colonized people have no recourse and no rights? That an invaded, displaced, ethnically cleansed and colonized people are cut off from their homeland?
You already had a homeland.
Jewish Autonomous Oblast - Wikipedia
Oh please. You are still avoiding the question.
Try again. What recourse and rights do an invaded, displaced, ethnically cleansed and colonized people have with respect to the homeland from which they were displaced?
Well no. A displaced people, speaking a number of different languages, and having a variety of skin tones, and from a number of different locations they were displaced to returned to their homeland where they all originated.
Did you want to argue that a displaced people have no right to return to their homeland?
What homeland?
It was another people's homeland for 1,400 years.
It's complete insanity, to think you had the right to displace them after that long.
In acknowledging that it was "another people's homeland" and giving the starting point of that homeland as 1400 years ago -- the time of the Arab conquest and colonization -- you are displaying your acceptance of colonialization. At least, when its Arabs doing the colonizing. You can't have it both ways. Either you accept colonialization as a valid "transfer of homeland" or you do not.
Be clear what my position is:
1. The Jewish people have a right to return to their historical homeland. ALL of them, regardless of race, language or place of Diaspora. Subject to the rules of the State of Israel.
2. The Arab Palestinian people have a right to return to their historical homeland. Subject to the rules of the (eventual, maybe) State of Palestine.
3. The Jewish people have a right to self-determination based on the culture and values of the Jewish people on part of the territory as sovereigns.
4. The Arab Palestinian people have a right to self-determination based on the culture and values of the Arab Palestinian people on part of the territory as sovereigns.
5. The Jewish people have a right to live in peace and security within their sovereign territory.
6. The Arab Palestinian people have a right to live in peace and security within their sovereign territory.
Are you sensing the theme here? BOTH peoples have the SAME rights.
There is and never was a "right" to displace peoples. On either side. Nor was there ever a "right" to colonize people. There is and was a conflict between these two peoples, largely driven by one group's intent to erase the other, in many small and large ways. The Jewish people refuse to be erased.
Arabs have lived there for 1,400 years as a majority.
Kosher people lived there as a majority for far less years.
Arabs have lived there for 1,400 years as a majority.
And that's long enough.
Time for them to go back to Saudi Arabia.
Palestinians maybe more Hebrew blooded than the Ashkenazim.
Oh please, the Arab Wars that they initiated was to wipe Israel off the face of the map
Lol, you started the war by stealing Palestinian land.
LOL.,,, The Arabs started the War by not respecting U.N . Resolutions. . Please tell us why the “ peacekeepers “ left in 1967
Your ilk stole Palestine.
The U. N. Declared Israel had the right to exist May 14, 1948. Deal with it
An historic blunder, because Palestinians owned more land & made up the majority into the 1940s.
