Afghan women rally, turning men red-faced with anger

I can't climb into Daveman's head and give his reason for posting this, but I was delighted to read it.

A movement has to start somewhere, and these 30 women had the courage to start it themselves, knowing they're putting their lives in danger of doing so.

Heros
 
I agree with that also.

But Americans love to point their fingers at other nations.

When in reality, a couple of hundred American women are raped every hour of every day.

Right here in the good old US of A :doubt:

they are raped by crimminals, not society as a whole which is done by Muslim communities which are lead by men only.
 
Go ahead and manipulate and twisted figures however you want.

But the truth is that Muslim women are treated better in their countries then women are treated here in America. :cool:

i'd prefer that statement to come from a woman that lives in the ME
 
How do they even know who each other is?

If a chick in a burka goes to meet her friend in a burka at a restaurant and their are a bunch of other chicks in burka there,

how the fuck do they find each other?

Well if they live in a society where the burka is mandated by law, they are not allowed to go anywhere without a male escort, so the males will be able to find each other. That is a good question though, I have never thought of it.
 
Go ahead and manipulate and twisted figures however you want.
Ummm...it's called "math", and I used it to prove your assertion wrong.
But the truth is that Muslim women are treated better in their countries then women are treated here in America. :cool:
Patently false. But I'd expect no less from someone who has to lie about his religion.
 
Absolutely.:clap2:

Hopefully the next one has 100 and the number grows :).

Oh no doubt, the sad thing is women in Afghanistan in the 60s and 70s had alot more freedom than they do now, after the war with the Soviets the influx of Islamic Militants totally fucked that society.

tumblr_lae5gufMfA1qavyn8o1_500.jpg


100527_19afghanistan1481.jpg


63580_435160608391_620483391_5252312_6694973_n.jpg


Good point though I am not sure so much about the 60's and 70's overall. When I was in Afghanistan in the 70's all the Afghan women we could see were covered. However the women who lived in outside villages were frequently not. Shortly before the Soviet invasion there was a lot of work done on liberating women and other liberal moves and that caused friction between different bands.

Afghanistan had a fairly mild form of Sharia law before the Soviet invasion and women had had times of greater and lesser liberty.

The big problem came after the war when first the Northern Alliance went mad and then the Taliban got in and if we are going to be honest that was because the US saw the fanatic's like Bin Laden as a better bet than decent pro democracy Afghan warriors like Abdul Haq and allowed refugee children who would become the Taliban to be taught by the Saudi's who gave them the most extremist education at expense of a proper education covering all the basics and their own heritage.

I loved the Afghan people. My heart goes out to them the way they have been used and abused....and women fighting for liberation in nothing new in Afghanistan. RAWA have been doing it since 1978. They are the people who the US should have been helping but you will find they are very critical of what the US has done.

Great women, always working for women and for a democratic Afghanistan. Unfortunately the US turned a blind eye when the Al Qaeda mob bumped off most of the democratic warriors of Afghanistan and failed both to listen to Abdul Haq before they attacked and protect him when he himself went in. They even ignored the information he gave them on where they could find Bin Laden. Abdul Haq was possibly the only person left who could have united the tribes of Afghanistan.

I knew I would get started if I came in here!!

RAWA News I actually went looking here for details of this march and did not find it as recent news. Is this the march they had went Karzai was going to take away the new rights they had been given a year or two ago? because they certainly had a march then.
 
Last edited:
Hopefully the next one has 100 and the number grows :).

Oh no doubt, the sad thing is women in Afghanistan in the 60s and 70s had alot more freedom than they do now, after the war with the Soviets the influx of Islamic Militants totally fucked that society.

tumblr_lae5gufMfA1qavyn8o1_500.jpg


100527_19afghanistan1481.jpg


63580_435160608391_620483391_5252312_6694973_n.jpg


Good point though I am not sure so much about the 60's and 70's overall. When I was in Afghanistan in the 70's all the Afghan women we could see were covered. However the women who lived in outside villages were frequently not. Shortly before the Soviet invasion there was a lot of work done on liberating women and other liberal moves and that caused friction between different bands.

Afghanistan had a fairly mild form of Sharia law before the Soviet invasion and women had had times of greater and lesser liberty.

The big problem came after the war when first the Northern Alliance went mad and then the Taliban got in and if we are going to be honest that was because the US saw the fanatic's like Bin Laden as a better bet than decent pro democracy Afghan warriors like Abdul Haq and allowed refugee children who would become the Taliban to be taught by the Saudi's who gave them the most extremist education at expense of a proper education covering all the basics and their own heritage.

I loved the Afghan people. My heart goes out to them the way they have been used and abused....and women fighting for liberation in nothing new in Afghanistan. RAWA have been doing it since 1978. They are the people who the US should have been helping but you will find they are very critical of what the US has done.

Great women, always working for women and for a democratic Afghanistan. Unfortunately the US turned a blind eye when the Al Qaeda mob bumped off most of the democratic warriors of Afghanistan and failed both to listen to Abdul Haq before they attacked and protect him when he himself went in. They even ignored the information he gave them on where they could find Bin Laden. Abdul Haq was possibly the only person left who could have united the tribes of Afghanistan.

I knew I would get started if I came in here!!

RAWA News I actually went looking here for details of this march and did not find it as recent news. Is this the march they had went Karzai was going to take away the new rights they had been given a year or two ago? because they certainly had a march then.

Well if you say you were there in the 70s I'll take your word for it, what I have read about Afghanistan in the 1970s was that the situation was way better for them at the time, they could go to school without being harassed or assaulted, they wouldn't be beheaded if they went outside without a burka, they could actually go to school and pursue a career. etc it is the polar opposite of what is going on now in Afghanistan, it is like they went from one end of the spectrum to another, it will take decades for Afghan women to regain what was lost during all these wars.
 
Sending Afghan women to school is counter productive.

There isn't enough jobs for men let alone women.

The Afghan people want boys sent to school first since they will be the main bread winners in any family.

Only after the male population is educated should women be sent to school.
 
Sending Afghan women to school is counter productive.

There isn't enough jobs for men let alone women.

The Afghan people want boys sent to school first since they will be the main bread winners in any family.

Only after the male population is educated should women be sent to school.

There was never a problem with both men and women going to school before, why is it a problem now?
 
Sending Afghan women to school is counter productive.

There isn't enough jobs for men let alone women.

The Afghan people want boys sent to school first since they will be the main bread winners in any family.

Only after the male population is educated should women be sent to school.

That's where we differ, I think the most education a person (male or female) can possibly get is the best situation.
 
Once again, there are not enough jobs for the men.

Men are the primary bread winners for Afghan families.

Every time that you educate a woman so that she can get a job.

That is another job that is being taken from the Afghan man.

That is why women going to school are being attacked.

The Afghan people are not against women being educated.

But for the society to function the males must be educated first and then the females.
 
Once again, there are not enough jobs for the men.

Men are the primary bread winners for Afghan families.

Every time that you educate a woman so that she can get a job.

That is another job that is being taken from the Afghan man.

That is why women going to school are being attacked.

The Afghan people are not against women being educated.

But for the society to function the males must be educated first and then the females.

Equal opportunity capitalism says the best person for the job should get it, if a woman is a better candidate, too bad for the man.

People shouldn't be speaking out against women being educated no matter what, unless you view men as better or more important than women, which I don't.
 
Thankfully, Afghanistan does not operate under equal opportunity capitalism.

That is an artificial Western convention that would not work in Afghan society or culture.

The Afghan woman's primary responsibility is to take care of her husband, the house, and to bare his children. :cool:
 
Thankfully, Afghanistan does not operate under equal opportunity capitalism.

That is an artificial Western convention that would not work in Afghan society or culture.

The Afghan woman's primary responsibility is to take care of her husband, the house, and to bare his children. :cool:

Yes but if something happens to the husband than the Afghan woman has to go out and support the family, this happens all the time in war zones like Iraq and Afghanistan. Better for the woman to be educated to have a better chance of supporting the family just in case.
 
Oh no doubt, the sad thing is women in Afghanistan in the 60s and 70s had alot more freedom than they do now, after the war with the Soviets the influx of Islamic Militants totally fucked that society.

tumblr_lae5gufMfA1qavyn8o1_500.jpg


100527_19afghanistan1481.jpg


63580_435160608391_620483391_5252312_6694973_n.jpg


Good point though I am not sure so much about the 60's and 70's overall. When I was in Afghanistan in the 70's all the Afghan women we could see were covered. However the women who lived in outside villages were frequently not. Shortly before the Soviet invasion there was a lot of work done on liberating women and other liberal moves and that caused friction between different bands.

Afghanistan had a fairly mild form of Sharia law before the Soviet invasion and women had had times of greater and lesser liberty.

The big problem came after the war when first the Northern Alliance went mad and then the Taliban got in and if we are going to be honest that was because the US saw the fanatic's like Bin Laden as a better bet than decent pro democracy Afghan warriors like Abdul Haq and allowed refugee children who would become the Taliban to be taught by the Saudi's who gave them the most extremist education at expense of a proper education covering all the basics and their own heritage.

I loved the Afghan people. My heart goes out to them the way they have been used and abused....and women fighting for liberation in nothing new in Afghanistan. RAWA have been doing it since 1978. They are the people who the US should have been helping but you will find they are very critical of what the US has done.

Great women, always working for women and for a democratic Afghanistan. Unfortunately the US turned a blind eye when the Al Qaeda mob bumped off most of the democratic warriors of Afghanistan and failed both to listen to Abdul Haq before they attacked and protect him when he himself went in. They even ignored the information he gave them on where they could find Bin Laden. Abdul Haq was possibly the only person left who could have united the tribes of Afghanistan.

I knew I would get started if I came in here!!

RAWA News I actually went looking here for details of this march and did not find it as recent news. Is this the march they had went Karzai was going to take away the new rights they had been given a year or two ago? because they certainly had a march then.

Well if you say you were there in the 70s I'll take your word for it, what I have read about Afghanistan in the 1970s was that the situation was way better for them at the time, they could go to school without being harassed or assaulted, they wouldn't be beheaded if they went outside without a burka, they could actually go to school and pursue a career. etc it is the polar opposite of what is going on now in Afghanistan, it is like they went from one end of the spectrum to another, it will take decades for Afghan women to regain what was lost during all these wars.

There is no question the situation was way better for them and this is before the Soviet invasion. I am sure they went to school like children anywhere. I am just saying that I never met an Afghan adult woman who was not in a burka. I have also read that they were supposed to have had this enormous emancipation but that doesn't fit in with what I saw.

I have no difficulty believing that girls were being educated and were able to join professions. I understand that Afghanistan was going through a strong process of liberalisation at the time. However when I was there most adult women were in Burkas.

I read an article which may be what you are talking about which spoke of this amazing sort of westernisation of Afghanistan. I am not sure that it does not come from rose tinted glasses because it does not go with what I saw and if there had been so much liberalisation of women in the 60's and 70's, RAWA would have had no reason to come into being.

As far as I am aware it was the speed of the push towards secular democracy including liberalisation of women that created in some of the tribes in for instance Kandahar region, the situation of unrest which allowed a window for the Soviets to come in.

Totally agree with you that Afghanistan was completely different to how it was after the Taliban had been ruling.

It was a country with decent proud people. As a young Western woman I walked the streets in western tops and suffered no problems at all. As I said it had mild Sharia law. No one was stoned, no one was getting their head chopped off, girls were not molested on the way to school, none of the things you suggested - just not as Westernised as you were suggesting which I suspect came from someone who probably was better off and did have those opportunities in Afghanistan and where I am sure Afghanistan could have gone if she had not been invaded, but where she had not yet got.

The situation that Afghan women suffer now is imo a direct result of the US Afghan Soviet war and the financing of fanatical Arabs who were allowed out of Arab jails to fight in Afghanistan instead of democratic Afghan warriors and the turning of a blind eye to a) the murder of Afghan's who would not listen to their foul ideas and b) to the fanatical salafi education given to Afghan refugees.
 
Thankfully, Afghanistan does not operate under equal opportunity capitalism.

That is an artificial Western convention that would not work in Afghan society or culture.

The Afghan woman's primary responsibility is to take care of her husband, the house, and to bare his children. :cool:

Thankfully, in 2011 in the United States we no longer put the lives and welfare of men above that of women, like you wish we would.

And thankfully these 30 women are brave enough to take a stand against the backwards point of view you and the afghan culture share.

If a husband can't take care of himself and needs his wife to do it, he's a pansy.
 
Good point though I am not sure so much about the 60's and 70's overall. When I was in Afghanistan in the 70's all the Afghan women we could see were covered. However the women who lived in outside villages were frequently not. Shortly before the Soviet invasion there was a lot of work done on liberating women and other liberal moves and that caused friction between different bands.

Afghanistan had a fairly mild form of Sharia law before the Soviet invasion and women had had times of greater and lesser liberty.

The big problem came after the war when first the Northern Alliance went mad and then the Taliban got in and if we are going to be honest that was because the US saw the fanatic's like Bin Laden as a better bet than decent pro democracy Afghan warriors like Abdul Haq and allowed refugee children who would become the Taliban to be taught by the Saudi's who gave them the most extremist education at expense of a proper education covering all the basics and their own heritage.

I loved the Afghan people. My heart goes out to them the way they have been used and abused....and women fighting for liberation in nothing new in Afghanistan. RAWA have been doing it since 1978. They are the people who the US should have been helping but you will find they are very critical of what the US has done.

Great women, always working for women and for a democratic Afghanistan. Unfortunately the US turned a blind eye when the Al Qaeda mob bumped off most of the democratic warriors of Afghanistan and failed both to listen to Abdul Haq before they attacked and protect him when he himself went in. They even ignored the information he gave them on where they could find Bin Laden. Abdul Haq was possibly the only person left who could have united the tribes of Afghanistan.

I knew I would get started if I came in here!!

RAWA News I actually went looking here for details of this march and did not find it as recent news. Is this the march they had went Karzai was going to take away the new rights they had been given a year or two ago? because they certainly had a march then.

Well if you say you were there in the 70s I'll take your word for it, what I have read about Afghanistan in the 1970s was that the situation was way better for them at the time, they could go to school without being harassed or assaulted, they wouldn't be beheaded if they went outside without a burka, they could actually go to school and pursue a career. etc it is the polar opposite of what is going on now in Afghanistan, it is like they went from one end of the spectrum to another, it will take decades for Afghan women to regain what was lost during all these wars.

There is no question the situation was way better for them and this is before the Soviet invasion. I am sure they went to school like children anywhere. I am just saying that I never met an Afghan adult woman who was not in a burka. I have also read that they were supposed to have had this enormous emancipation but that doesn't fit in with what I saw.

I have no difficulty believing that girls were being educated and were able to join professions. I understand that Afghanistan was going through a strong process of liberalisation at the time. However when I was there most adult women were in Burkas.

I read an article which may be what you are talking about which spoke of this amazing sort of westernisation of Afghanistan. I am not sure that it does not come from rose tinted glasses because it does not go with what I saw and if there had been so much liberalisation of women in the 60's and 70's, RAWA would have had no reason to come into being.

As far as I am aware it was the speed of the push towards secular democracy including liberalisation of women that created in some of the tribes in for instance Kandahar region, the situation of unrest which allowed a window for the Soviets to come in.

Totally agree with you that Afghanistan was completely different to how it was after the Taliban had been ruling.

It was a country with decent proud people. As a young Western woman I walked the streets in western tops and suffered no problems at all. As I said it had mild Sharia law. No one was stoned, no one was getting their head chopped off, girls were not molested on the way to school, none of the things you suggested - just not as Westernised as you were suggesting which I suspect came from someone who probably was better off and did have those opportunities in Afghanistan and where I am sure Afghanistan could have gone if she had not been invaded, but where she had not yet got.

The situation that Afghan women suffer now is imo a direct result of the US Afghan Soviet war and the financing of fanatical Arabs who were allowed out of Arab jails to fight in Afghanistan instead of democratic Afghan warriors and the turning of a blind eye to a) the murder of Afghan's who would not listen to their foul ideas and b) to the fanatical salafi education given to Afghan refugees.

I agree with you 100% on the last part, the influx of Islamic Militants into the country during the 1980s for the Jihad against the Soviets and the formation of the Taliban in the 1990s SCREWED that country, if the Russians never invaded Afghan, if we and the Saudis didn't fund guys like Bin Laden to go in there, who knows how Afghanistan would be right now? when you look at the pictures of Afghanistan in the 1970s and look at it now, it looks like 2 different galaxies, its actually fascinating in a sad way to see how many steps backwards man can take when devestation occurs.
 
Good point though I am not sure so much about the 60's and 70's overall. When I was in Afghanistan in the 70's all the Afghan women we could see were covered. However the women who lived in outside villages were frequently not. Shortly before the Soviet invasion there was a lot of work done on liberating women and other liberal moves and that caused friction between different bands.

Afghanistan had a fairly mild form of Sharia law before the Soviet invasion and women had had times of greater and lesser liberty.

The big problem came after the war when first the Northern Alliance went mad and then the Taliban got in and if we are going to be honest that was because the US saw the fanatic's like Bin Laden as a better bet than decent pro democracy Afghan warriors like Abdul Haq and allowed refugee children who would become the Taliban to be taught by the Saudi's who gave them the most extremist education at expense of a proper education covering all the basics and their own heritage.

I loved the Afghan people. My heart goes out to them the way they have been used and abused....and women fighting for liberation in nothing new in Afghanistan. RAWA have been doing it since 1978. They are the people who the US should have been helping but you will find they are very critical of what the US has done.

Great women, always working for women and for a democratic Afghanistan. Unfortunately the US turned a blind eye when the Al Qaeda mob bumped off most of the democratic warriors of Afghanistan and failed both to listen to Abdul Haq before they attacked and protect him when he himself went in. They even ignored the information he gave them on where they could find Bin Laden. Abdul Haq was possibly the only person left who could have united the tribes of Afghanistan.

I knew I would get started if I came in here!!

RAWA News I actually went looking here for details of this march and did not find it as recent news. Is this the march they had went Karzai was going to take away the new rights they had been given a year or two ago? because they certainly had a march then.

Well if you say you were there in the 70s I'll take your word for it, what I have read about Afghanistan in the 1970s was that the situation was way better for them at the time, they could go to school without being harassed or assaulted, they wouldn't be beheaded if they went outside without a burka, they could actually go to school and pursue a career. etc it is the polar opposite of what is going on now in Afghanistan, it is like they went from one end of the spectrum to another, it will take decades for Afghan women to regain what was lost during all these wars.

There is no question the situation was way better for them and this is before the Soviet invasion. I am sure they went to school like children anywhere. I am just saying that I never met an Afghan adult woman who was not in a burka. I have also read that they were supposed to have had this enormous emancipation but that doesn't fit in with what I saw.

I have no difficulty believing that girls were being educated and were able to join professions. I understand that Afghanistan was going through a strong process of liberalisation at the time. However when I was there most adult women were in Burkas.

I read an article which may be what you are talking about which spoke of this amazing sort of westernisation of Afghanistan. I am not sure that it does not come from rose tinted glasses because it does not go with what I saw and if there had been so much liberalisation of women in the 60's and 70's, RAWA would have had no reason to come into being.

As far as I am aware it was the speed of the push towards secular democracy including liberalisation of women that created in some of the tribes in for instance Kandahar region, the situation of unrest which allowed a window for the Soviets to come in.

Totally agree with you that Afghanistan was completely different to how it was after the Taliban had been ruling.

It was a country with decent proud people. As a young Western woman I walked the streets in western tops and suffered no problems at all. As I said it had mild Sharia law. No one was stoned, no one was getting their head chopped off, girls were not molested on the way to school, none of the things you suggested - just not as Westernised as you were suggesting which I suspect came from someone who probably was better off and did have those opportunities in Afghanistan and where I am sure Afghanistan could have gone if she had not been invaded, but where she had not yet got.

The situation that Afghan women suffer now is imo a direct result of the US Afghan Soviet war and the financing of fanatical Arabs who were allowed out of Arab jails to fight in Afghanistan instead of democratic Afghan warriors and the turning of a blind eye to a) the murder of Afghan's who would not listen to their foul ideas and b) to the fanatical salafi education given to Afghan refugees.

Thanks for your great insight.
 
Thankfully, Afghanistan does not operate under equal opportunity capitalism.

That is an artificial Western convention that would not work in Afghan society or culture.

The Afghan woman's primary responsibility is to take care of her husband, the house, and to bare his children. :cool:

Thankfully, in 2011 in the United States we no longer put the lives and welfare of men above that of women, like you wish we would.

And thankfully these 30 women are brave enough to take a stand against the backwards point of view you and the afghan culture share.

If a husband can't take care of himself and needs his wife to do it, he's a pansy.

These 30 women are nothing but Western backed trouble makers.

As soon as the Western occupiers leave Afghanistan these miscreant women will be history.

Groups like RAWA are nothing but Western busy bodies who have no business telling Afghan women what they can and cannot do.

Also, their time in Afghanistan will be dramatically cut short when the U.S. abandons Afghanistan in the near future.
 
Last edited:
Sending Afghan women to school is counter productive.

There isn't enough jobs for men let alone women.

The Afghan people want boys sent to school first since they will be the main bread winners in any family.

Only after the male population is educated should women be sent to school.
Allah forbid that women learn they're being treated like cattle.
 

Forum List

Back
Top