Aaron Rogers is the closest I've seen to Joe Montana

[ginscpy]

comparing apples to apples at similar ages. I didnt think I was ever going to see a better QB than Montana than in the 85 Super Bowl vs Marino. and and the Dolphins. Took over the game. Headline: Big Sky Falls On Miami.

Rogers is just as mobile as Montana was and has a stronger arm - by far. Extends plays, decisive, doesnt make mistakes.

Has by far the better group of recievers than Montana had - maybe the best group that ever played. Although Jennings injury may prove to be a hinderence.

Sort of came out of nowhere - was good but not great at Cal.

Farves backup at GB.

Barring injury - may go down as the best-ever.

 

[chikenwing]

comparing apples to apples at similar ages. I didnt think I was ever going to see a better QB than Montana than in the 85 Super Bowl vs Marino. and and the Dolphins. Took over the game. Headline: Big Sky Falls On Miami.

Rogers is just as mobile as Montana was and has a stronger arm - by far. Extends plays, decisive, doesnt make mistakes.

Has by far the better group of recievers than Montana had - maybe the best group that ever played. Although Jennings injury may prove to be a hinderence.

Sort of came out of nowhere - was good but not great at Cal.

Farves backup at GB.

Barring injury - may go down as the best-ever.

He is good,best ever??? there will always be someone bigger faster stronger smarter coming along,but heck its cool to watch.

 

[TruthSeeker56]

comparing apples to apples at similar ages. I didnt think I was ever going to see a better QB than Montana than in the 85 Super Bowl vs Marino. and and the Dolphins. Took over the game. Headline: Big Sky Falls On Miami.

Rogers is just as mobile as Montana was and has a stronger arm - by far. Extends plays, decisive, doesnt make mistakes.

Has by far the better group of recievers than Montana had - maybe the best group that ever played. Although Jennings injury may prove to be a hinderence.

Sort of came out of nowhere - was good but not great at Cal.

Farves backup at GB.

Barring injury - may go down as the best-ever.

You obviously didn't see any of Rodger's games when he played at Cal. He had a great college career, and lit up USC when USC was a powerhouse.

What is this orgasmic love for everything "Joe Montana" with some of you people? Montana was not anywhere near as mobile as some of you think. Maybe you're confusing Montana with Steve Young? Montana didn't have anywhere near the arm strength of Rodgers or Favre or Brady or either of the Manning brothers. Montana had the best wide receiver in NFL history to throw to, not to mention several other receiving options (running backs, tight ends, 2nd receiver, etc.).

Brady and Rodgers are BOTH better than Montana ever was. Period.

Get your facts straight. You're making a habit out of embarrassing yourself with "faux facts".

 

[Leweman]

Montana maybe was the closest thing to Rodgers you've seen since Young, Manning, Marino, Brady, and Rothlesburger. I mean come on.

 

[ginscpy]

comparing apples to apples at similar ages. I didnt think I was ever going to see a better QB than Montana than in the 85 Super Bowl vs Marino. and and the Dolphins. Took over the game. Headline: Big Sky Falls On Miami.

Rogers is just as mobile as Montana was and has a stronger arm - by far. Extends plays, decisive, doesnt make mistakes.

Has by far the better group of recievers than Montana had - maybe the best group that ever played. Although Jennings injury may prove to be a hinderence.

Sort of came out of nowhere - was good but not great at Cal.

Farves backup at GB.

Barring injury - may go down as the best-ever.

You obviously didn't see any of Rodger's games when he played at Cal. He had a great college career, and lit up USC when USC was a powerhouse.

What is this orgasmic love for everything "Joe Montana" with some of you people? Montana was not anywhere near as mobile as some of you think. Maybe you're confusing Montana with Steve Young? Montana didn't have anywhere near the arm strength of Rodgers or Favre or Brady or either of the Manning brothers. Montana had the best wide receiver in NFL history to throw to, not to mention several other receiving options (running backs, tight ends, 2nd receiver, etc.).

Brady and Rodgers are BOTH better than Montana ever was. Period.

Get your facts straight. You're making a habit out of embarrassing yourself with "faux facts".

Montana won a NC and 2 major Bowl games at ND. Not to mention 4 Super Bowls.

Rogers didnt do squat a t Cal.

Lets see how he progresses.

 

[rightwinger]

Of the QBs today, Tom Brady is the closest to Joe Montana. Both are overachievers not expected to do well in the NFL. Montana won four Superbowls and Brady won three and had what could have been the winning drive in the fourth. Montana was never the best QB in terms of arm strength, speed or mobility. What Montana had that other QBs lacked was coolness under pressure and a will to win. Brady has those same qualities. Both Montana and Brady have signature victories where they brought their team back in critical games

Aaron Rogers is more like Steve Young to me. Great QBs that sat behind HOF QBs waiting for a shot. Both had their HOF QBs traded so that they could get a shot. Both led their teams to SuperBowls three years later.

Rogers has a way to go before he is a Joe Montana. He needs to win more championships and he needs those victories for the ages that Johnny Unitas, Elway and Montana had

 

[Toro]

Brady is better than Rodgers, at least thus far.

 

[Quantum Windbag]

comparing apples to apples at similar ages. I didnt think I was ever going to see a better QB than Montana than in the 85 Super Bowl vs Marino. and and the Dolphins. Took over the game. Headline: Big Sky Falls On Miami.

Rogers is just as mobile as Montana was and has a stronger arm - by far. Extends plays, decisive, doesnt make mistakes.

Has by far the better group of recievers than Montana had - maybe the best group that ever played. Although Jennings injury may prove to be a hinderence.

Sort of came out of nowhere - was good but not great at Cal.

Farves backup at GB.

Barring injury - may go down as the best-ever.

Excuse me, but you are deluded. Joe Montana's best year does not hold up to Aaron Rogers year. He is on pace to break every single QB record for a season this year.

 

[rightwinger]

comparing apples to apples at similar ages. I didnt think I was ever going to see a better QB than Montana than in the 85 Super Bowl vs Marino. and and the Dolphins. Took over the game. Headline: Big Sky Falls On Miami.

Rogers is just as mobile as Montana was and has a stronger arm - by far. Extends plays, decisive, doesnt make mistakes.

Has by far the better group of recievers than Montana had - maybe the best group that ever played. Although Jennings injury may prove to be a hinderence.

Sort of came out of nowhere - was good but not great at Cal.

Farves backup at GB.

Barring injury - may go down as the best-ever.

Excuse me, but you are deluded. Joe Montana's best year does not hold up to Aaron Rogers year. He is on pace to break every single QB record for a season this year.

It was a different era back then.

QBs did not wear dresses, receivers could be chucked until the ball was released and catching a pass across the middle was risking your life

You can't compare pass statistics from the 80s with today

 

[Quantum Windbag]

comparing apples to apples at similar ages. I didnt think I was ever going to see a better QB than Montana than in the 85 Super Bowl vs Marino. and and the Dolphins. Took over the game. Headline: Big Sky Falls On Miami.

Rogers is just as mobile as Montana was and has a stronger arm - by far. Extends plays, decisive, doesnt make mistakes.

Has by far the better group of recievers than Montana had - maybe the best group that ever played. Although Jennings injury may prove to be a hinderence.

Sort of came out of nowhere - was good but not great at Cal.

Farves backup at GB.

Barring injury - may go down as the best-ever.

Excuse me, but you are deluded. Joe Montana's best year does not hold up to Aaron Rogers year. He is on pace to break every single QB record for a season this year.

It was a different era back then.

QBs did not wear dresses, receivers could be chucked until the ball was released and catching a pass across the middle was risking your life

You can't compare pass statistics from the 80s with today

Did you miss the part where I said every single season record?

 

[ginscpy]

Of the QBs today, Tom Brady is the closest to Joe Montana. Both are overachievers not expected to do well in the NFL. Montana won four Superbowls and Brady won three and had what could have been the winning drive in the fourth. Montana was never the best QB in terms of arm strength, speed or mobility. What Montana had that other QBs lacked was coolness under pressure and a will to win. Brady has those same qualities. Both Montana and Brady have signature victories where they brought their team back in critical games

Aaron Rogers is more like Steve Young to me. Great QBs that sat behind HOF QBs waiting for a shot. Both had their HOF QBs traded so that they could get a shot. Both led their teams to SuperBowls three years later.

Rogers has a way to go before he is a Joe Montana. He needs to win more championships and he needs those victories for the ages that Johnny Unitas, Elway and Montana had

I agree with you about Brady. Too much of a celebrity- like being in People Magazine for my tastes. But underneath his pretty-boy image (Randy Moss said he looks like a girl) has a fierce competitive desire. Always an underdog.

Did you see how he got into it with the Pats offensive coordinator on the sidelines after he threw the pick in the endzone??

Then afterwards in the press conference said I srewed up - I made a bad play, I deserved to get yelled at.

A winner.

 

[rightwinger]

Excuse me, but you are deluded. Joe Montana's best year does not hold up to Aaron Rogers year. He is on pace to break every single QB record for a season this year.

It was a different era back then.

QBs did not wear dresses, receivers could be chucked until the ball was released and catching a pass across the middle was risking your life

You can't compare pass statistics from the 80s with today

Did you miss the part where I said every single season record?

Did you miss the part where I said the NFL has fixed the rules so that you are not allowed to defend against the pass and that any new records do not equate to what you had to do in the 80s?

Did you see where Manning smashed all the passing records only to be smashed by Brady and now smashed by Rodgers? Passing is too easy now

 

[Zander]

Of the QBs today, Tom Brady is the closest to Joe Montana. Both are overachievers not expected to do well in the NFL. Montana won four Superbowls and Brady won three and had what could have been the winning drive in the fourth. Montana was never the best QB in terms of arm strength, speed or mobility. What Montana had that other QBs lacked was coolness under pressure and a will to win. Brady has those same qualities. Both Montana and Brady have signature victories where they brought their team back in critical games

Aaron Rogers is more like Steve Young to me. Great QBs that sat behind HOF QBs waiting for a shot. Both had their HOF QBs traded so that they could get a shot. Both led their teams to SuperBowls three years later.

Rogers has a way to go before he is a Joe Montana. He needs to win more championships and he needs those victories for the ages that Johnny Unitas, Elway and Montana had

 

[Dont Taz Me Bro]

Brady > Rodgers

 

[sealybobo]

You obviously didn't see any of Rodger's games when he played at Cal. He had a great college career, and lit up USC when USC was a powerhouse.

What is this orgasmic love for everything "Joe Montana" with some of you people? Montana was not anywhere near as mobile as some of you think. Maybe you're confusing Montana with Steve Young? Montana didn't have anywhere near the arm strength of Rodgers or Favre or Brady or either of the Manning brothers. Montana had the best wide receiver in NFL history to throw to, not to mention several other receiving options (running backs, tight ends, 2nd receiver, etc.).

Brady and Rodgers are BOTH better than Montana ever was. Period.

Get your facts straight. You're making a habit out of embarrassing yourself with "faux facts".

This morning a guy on ESPN asked if Aaron Rogers is obligated to show up to training camp. FUCK NO. He's in a unique position. He's in the drivers seat. If they had someone better, they'd play them. Or they'd trade Rogers. They don't have anyone better. So see you at the first pre season game. I'm in Cabo.

At this point in his career?

Aaron Rogers is better on paper than Tom Brady. Except for when it matters most.

 

[Unkotare]

comparing apples to apples at similar ages. I didnt think I was ever going to see a better QB than Montana than in the 85 Super Bowl vs Marino. and and the Dolphins. Took over the game. Headline: Big Sky Falls On Miami.

Rogers is just as mobile as Montana was and has a stronger arm - by far. Extends plays, decisive, doesnt make mistakes.

Has by far the better group of recievers than Montana had - maybe the best group that ever played. Although Jennings injury may prove to be a hinderence.

Sort of came out of nowhere - was good but not great at Cal.

Farves backup at GB.

Barring injury - may go down as the best-ever.

None of the above fit to be backup to Brady.

 

[candycorn]

comparing apples to apples at similar ages. I didnt think I was ever going to see a better QB than Montana than in the 85 Super Bowl vs Marino. and and the Dolphins. Took over the game. Headline: Big Sky Falls On Miami.

Rogers is just as mobile as Montana was and has a stronger arm - by far. Extends plays, decisive, doesnt make mistakes.

Has by far the better group of recievers than Montana had - maybe the best group that ever played. Although Jennings injury may prove to be a hinderence.

Sort of came out of nowhere - was good but not great at Cal.

Farves backup at GB.

Barring injury - may go down as the best-ever.

Few have made the QB position look as easy as Montana and Rodgers

 

[Unkotare]

Of the QBs today, Tom Brady is the closest to Joe Montana. Both are overachievers not expected to do well in the NFL. Montana won four Superbowls and Brady won three and had what could have been the winning drive in the fourth. Montana was never the best QB in terms of arm strength, speed or mobility. What Montana had that other QBs lacked was coolness under pressure and a will to win. Brady has those same qualities. Both Montana and Brady have signature victories where they brought their team back in critical games

Aaron Rogers is more like Steve Young to me. Great QBs that sat behind HOF QBs waiting for a shot. Both had their HOF QBs traded so that they could get a shot. Both led their teams to SuperBowls three years later.

Rogers has a way to go before he is a Joe Montana. He needs to win more championships and he needs those victories for the ages that Johnny Unitas, Elway and Montana had

Brady owns the NFL’s record book​

All-time NFL rankings for Tom Brady in significant statistical categories

CATEGORY	VALUE	ALL-TIME RANK
Super Bowl wins	7	1st
Super Bowl appearances	10	1st
Super Bowl MVPs	5	1st
NFL MVPs	3	T-2nd
Pro Bowl selections	15	1st
Games started	316	1st
Playoff games started	47	1st
QB regular-season wins	243	1st
QB playoff wins	35	1st
Pass completions	7,263	1st
Passing yards	84,520	1st
Passing touchdowns	624	1st
Playoff pass completions	1,165	1st
Playoff passing yards	13,049	1st
Playoff passing touchdowns	86	1st
Game-winning drives*	67	1st
Fourth-quarter comebacks*	51	1st
Approximate Value	316	1st

*Includes both playoffs and regular season.