Quote: Originally Posted by
AllieBaba
Quote:
Can you please round up all your rightwing friends and email the RNC and the McCain campaign demanding that they promote Creationism in science classes, and that they express doubts about Evolution.
This is an old debate, and one which is wearisome because there is no evidence that, even if it wasn't just a theory, the existence of evolution rules out the existence of an intelligent creator, or that the theory of creationism in any way is less valid than the theory of evolution. If you're going to discuss theories about how the earth came to be, there's no reason to leave out the theory that the biblical version is a possibility. By leaving it out, you are encouraging children to accept a viewpoint that is not complete, and by presenting it as fact, you are forcing, essentially, the "religion" of evolution down their throats.
We'll just agree to disagree, I suppose.
There is a
practical reason to leave it out of the science classroom, in that there are hundreds of creation stories.
There is a
rational reason to leave it out as well, in that creationism and ID do not have qualities that make them science. They are
not science. They make
no testable predictions. They are positions of faith. They are not subject to change.
A "viewpoint that is not complete?" That is meaningless. Any subject (math, reading, science, social studies, whatever) teaches a child a particular disciplne. The place to teach
faith is in faith classes.
Evolution
never purports to be religion. Only those who believe
creationism call evolution a religion. Scientists generally have no difficulty distinguishing between science and religion.
Creationists seem to confuse the two regularly.
Scientists have no problem with faith. Scientists do have a problem with religion viewpoints being taught in science classes.
I mean really, we don't ask to come into your churches and spout evolution to you on Sundays, but that would be the analogous situation, think about it.
Then respect the differences between faith and science..